What Happens to Instant Noodles in Your Stomach? The Evidence

What Happens Inside Your Stomach When You Eat Instant Noodles?

Instant noodles are digested like other starchy foods, just a little more slowly at first. In a small 2012 experiment using a swallowable camera, instant ramen looked less broken down than fresh homemade noodles one to two hours after eating. That finding went viral, often with claims that the noodles sit in your stomach for days or poison you. The evidence does not support those claims. The real concerns are more ordinary: a lot of salt, refined flour and fat, and very little protein, fibre or vitamins.

Below is what the camera study showed, what is known about the additives people worry about, and how to make instant noodles part of a reasonable diet.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

The pill-camera experiment

The study came from Dr. Braden Kuo, a gastroenterologist at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston. Volunteers swallowed capsule cameras, the kind doctors use to look inside the digestive tract without an endoscope. On one day they ate packaged instant ramen; on another, they ate fresh ramen made at home. The cameras recorded what happened in the stomach.

At the one- to two-hour mark, the instant noodles were visibly more intact than the homemade ones. Footage from the experiment spread widely online, often stripped of context. Kuo himself described the work as small and said it could not tell whether processed ramen is harmful. As he put it in a television interview, “People have this interest in what’s going on in their bodies but we can’t see it.”

Why might instant noodles break down more slowly?

Most instant noodle blocks are cooked, then fried or dried to remove moisture, which changes the texture of the starch and makes the strands firmer. Many are fried in palm oil, and fat in a meal tends to slow the rate at which the stomach empties. Chewing matters too: firm noodles slurped quickly arrive in larger pieces. None of this means the noodles are indigestible. Over the following hours, stomach acid, enzymes and the small intestine break them down like other wheat products.

Slower digestion is not, on its own, a sign of harm. Many healthy foods, including beans and whole grains, are digested more slowly than white bread, and that is usually considered a good thing for blood sugar.

TBHQ: the preservative behind the scary headlines

Tertiary-butylhydroquinone, or TBHQ, is a synthetic antioxidant added to oils and fats to stop them going rancid. It is used in many processed foods, from crackers to frozen meals, and also appears in non-food products such as perfumes and some industrial materials. Its industrial uses are often listed to make it sound frightening, but many common substances, including salt and vinegar, have industrial uses too.

How much is allowed?

In both the United States and the European Union, TBHQ may make up no more than 0.02% of the fat or oil in a food, or 200 milligrams per kilogram of fat. The international expert committee run by the FAO and WHO has set an acceptable daily intake of 0 to 0.7 mg per kilogram of body weight, a level intended to be safe over a lifetime. European food safety regulators do not consider it a carcinogen at permitted levels.

What about “five grams is lethal”?

That figure comes from older reference books and refers to doses far beyond what any food could contain. A packet of noodles with around 15 grams of fat could contain at most about 3 milligrams of TBHQ under the US limit. Five grams is well over a thousand times that. Laboratory studies have found stomach changes and DNA effects in animals given very high doses, and some research continues on possible effects on the immune system, but a 1986 review concluded that the margin between typical human intake and harmful doses in animals is wide. The sensible reading is that TBHQ is worth keeping to normal food levels, not that a bowl of noodles is dangerous.

MSG: a long-running myth

Seasoning packets usually contain monosodium glutamate, a flavour enhancer that gives savoury, umami taste. Few food ingredients have a worse reputation, and few have been studied as much.

The US Food and Drug Administration classifies added MSG as generally recognised as safe. A scientific review it commissioned in the 1990s found that some sensitive people might have mild, short-lived symptoms such as headache after eating 3 grams or more of MSG without food. A typical serving of food with added MSG contains less than half a gram. In controlled trials, people who believed they were sensitive did not react consistently when they did not know whether they were getting MSG or a placebo.

The glutamate in MSG is chemically the same as the glutamate found naturally in tomatoes, cheese and mushrooms, and the body handles it in the same way. An average adult takes in roughly 13 grams of glutamate a day from protein in ordinary food. Claims that MSG in food causes brain damage, Alzheimer’s or Parkinson’s disease are not supported by human evidence. Studies that injected large doses into newborn rodents do not reflect eating it in a meal.

What nutrition research actually links to instant noodles

The most cited study is a 2014 paper in the Journal of Nutrition by Hyun Joon Shin and a team of US and Korean researchers. They analysed survey data from 10,711 Korean adults aged 19 to 64. Women who ate instant noodles at least twice a week were 68% more likely to have metabolic syndrome, a cluster of risk factors that includes a large waist, high blood pressure, high blood sugar and unhealthy blood fats. No such link appeared in men.

This is an association, not proof that noodles cause the problem. People who eat a lot of instant noodles may differ in many ways, such as income, working hours, sleep or the rest of their diet. The researchers suggested hormonal differences or chemicals from packaging might explain the gap between men and women, but those ideas were not tested.

The salt problem

The clearest concern is sodium. Depending on the brand, one packet with its full seasoning can contain anywhere from around 1,000 to more than 2,000 milligrams of sodium. The World Health Organization recommends that adults keep sodium below 2,000 mg a day, so a single bowl can use up most or all of a day’s allowance. High salt intake raises blood pressure, a major risk factor for heart disease and stroke.

Instant noodles are also low in protein, fibre, vitamins and minerals for the energy they provide. Eating them occasionally is not a problem; relying on them as a daily staple means missing out on nutrients you would get from a more varied meal. In 2012 South Korean regulators also reported tiny traces of benzopyrene, a cancer-linked compound, in some batches from one manufacturer; they said the amounts were not harmful, but several products were voluntarily recalled.

Common myths, briefly

“Noodles stay in your stomach for days.” No. The camera study looked at the first couple of hours. Food leaves the stomach over several hours and moves on to the intestines.
“The wax coating stops digestion.” Instant noodles are not coated in wax. The firmness comes from how the dough is cooked, dried and fried.
“Any amount is toxic.” The additives are used within regulated limits. The bigger issue is how often you eat them and what you eat alongside.

How to make instant noodles a better meal

If instant noodles are a regular part of your week because they are quick and cheap, a few changes help a lot:

Use half the seasoning packet or less. This is the simplest way to cut sodium sharply. Add flavour with garlic, ginger, chilli, lime or herbs instead.
Add protein. An egg, tofu, leftover chicken or a handful of edamame turns a snack into a meal that keeps you full longer.
Add vegetables. Frozen peas, spinach, cabbage, mushrooms or spring onions cook in the same pot in a couple of minutes.
Check the label. Air-dried noodles generally contain less fat than fried ones, and sodium varies widely between brands.
Keep them occasional. Plan a few simple meals in advance so instant noodles are a backup rather than the default.

If you have high blood pressure, kidney disease or another condition affected by salt, talk to a doctor or dietitian about how foods like these fit into your diet.

Sources: Fox 8 / WCVB, May 2012: study on ramen noodles in the stomach; Wikipedia: tert-Butylhydroquinone; JECFA evaluation of TBHQ; US FDA: Questions and answers on monosodium glutamate; LaNutrition: summary of the 2014 Journal of Nutrition study; the original article was by Dr. Joseph Mercola at Mercola, shared via Earth We Are One.

Related: