Eating Garlic on an Empty Stomach: Benefits, Myths and Risks

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
0 0 Edit this post

Eating garlic on an empty stomach does not turn it into an antibiotic. There is no study showing that garlic works better before breakfast, and no reliable evidence that it can replace prescribed medicine for an infection. What research does support is more modest: garlic supplements can lower blood pressure a little in people with high blood pressure, may slightly improve cholesterol, and are being studied for colds with too little evidence to say much. Raw garlic on an empty stomach is also the way most likely to cause heartburn, nausea and wind.

Garlic on an Empty Stomach: Traditional Claims and Clinical Evidence

The idea of a morning clove has deep roots in folk medicine. In Russia and much of Eastern Europe, garlic has long been the first thing reached for at the start of a cold, and many families grew up treating it as a remedy rather than just a seasoning. That tradition is worth respecting as food culture. It is also worth separating from the bolder claims that travel with it online.

Where the empty-stomach idea comes from

The version of this story that spread around 2014 claimed that "scientists have found" garlic becomes far more powerful when eaten before food, because bacteria in the gut are "exposed" and cannot defend themselves. No study was named, and none is known that tested this. Bacteria in the body do not become more vulnerable because you skipped breakfast.

The chemistry actually points the other way. Garlic's best-known active compound, allicin, is not present in an intact clove. It forms only when the clove is crushed or chopped, when an enzyme called alliinase acts on a substance called alliin. That enzyme is permanently switched off in strongly acidic conditions, below about pH 3, and an empty stomach is very acidic. Allicin itself is also unstable and breaks down into other sulphur compounds within hours. So whatever garlic does in the body, an empty stomach is not a known way to make it stronger.

What is in garlic

A clove of garlic is mostly water and carbohydrate, with small amounts of vitamin C, vitamin B6, manganese, selenium and other minerals, plus a range of sulphur compounds that give it its smell and much of its research interest. Claims that garlic contains "more than 400" beneficial components are hard to pin down; the number depends on what is counted, and we could not verify the figure.

In the laboratory, allicin and related compounds do kill or slow many bacteria and fungi, which is why garlic is so often called a "natural antibiotic". The trouble is the gap between a dish of bacteria and a human body. As of the last major reviews, the safety and effectiveness of allicin for treating infections in people remained unclear. A substance that works in a test tube at high concentration may not reach an infection in the body at a useful dose.

For readers interested in garlic's long career as a household remedy, one book on the subject is Garlic: Nature’s Original Remedy; as with any remedy book, check its health claims against current research.

Garlic in history

Garlic has been cultivated for thousands of years and appears in the food and medicine of ancient Egypt, Greece, Rome, the Middle East, India and China. A frequently quoted line credits Pythagoras with calling it "the king of spices"; like many ancient attributions, it is often repeated but hard to trace to a primary text.

The Egyptian medical document usually meant in garlic articles is the Ebers Papyrus, a scroll from around 1550 BC that collects hundreds of remedies and magical formulas. Popular articles say 22 of its remedies use garlic, but we could not confirm that count in a reliable source, and the sources we checked disagree even on the total number of remedies in the scroll. Garlic's long history is real; it simply tells us people valued it, not which uses actually worked.

The popular "10 benefits", checked

The list that came with the original story mixed decent evidence with laboratory findings and guesses. Here is how each claim compares with current research:

  • Lowers blood pressure. The best supported. A 2016 meta-analysis by Karin Ried in the Journal of Nutrition found that in people with high blood pressure, garlic supplements lowered systolic pressure by about 8.7 mmHg and diastolic by about 6 mmHg compared with placebo. That is a modest but real effect, from supplements rather than raw cloves, and it is not a reason to stop prescribed medication.
  • Reduces "bad" cholesterol. Supported to a small degree. The US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) says supplements may modestly lower total and LDL cholesterol in people with high cholesterol.
  • Protects against heart disease and clogged arteries. Plausible because of the effects above, but not proven to prevent heart attacks or strokes.
  • Fights colds. Weak evidence. A 2014 Cochrane review found only one eligible trial: 146 people took a garlic supplement or placebo for 12 weeks, with 24 colds in the garlic group and 65 in the placebo group. The reviewers concluded the evidence was insufficient, and NCCIH notes the later research is small and flawed.
  • Kills bacteria and works as a natural antibiotic. True in the lab; unproven as a treatment in people.
  • Strengthens the immune system. Too vague to test as stated; some small studies report changes in immune markers.
  • Prevents ageing. No evidence.
  • Helps nervous system disorders. No good clinical evidence.
  • Kills glioblastoma cells. This comes from laboratory experiments on cancer cells, not from treatment of people with brain tumours. NCCIH notes that eating garlic does not appear to reduce stomach cancer risk.
  • Thins the blood. Garlic can affect clotting, which is exactly why it is a safety concern rather than a reason to self-treat, as explained below.

Risks of eating a lot of raw garlic

The original advice to eat a whole head of garlic a day is a lot: roughly ten or more cloves. Common side effects of large amounts include bad breath and body odour, heartburn, stomach pain, wind and nausea, and these are usually worse on an empty stomach. Some people are allergic to garlic.

The more important risk is bleeding. NCCIH warns that garlic supplements may increase the risk of bleeding, so anyone taking anticoagulants or aspirin, or preparing for surgery, should tell their doctor before using them. Garlic can also interact with some other medicines. Amounts larger than normal food use may not be safe in pregnancy or while breastfeeding. And raw garlic left on the skin can cause chemical burns, so home remedies that tape cloves to the body are a bad idea.

How to enjoy garlic sensibly

  • Use it generously in cooking for flavour; there is no need to eat it raw on waking.
  • If you like raw garlic, crush or chop it and let it sit for a few minutes before eating or cooking, which allows the allicin-forming reaction to happen, and take it with food to spare your stomach.
  • If you are considering supplements for blood pressure or cholesterol, talk to a doctor first, particularly if you take other medicines.
  • For a bacterial infection that needs antibiotics, take the antibiotic. For a cold, which is caused by a virus, neither antibiotics nor garlic are a cure; rest and fluids are the usual advice, and a doctor can help if symptoms are severe or lasting.

Sources: Original story from Living Traditionally via Truth Seeker Daily; NCCIH: Garlic; Ried K., Journal of Nutrition, 2016 (abstract record); Cochrane review: Garlic for the common cold (2014); Wikipedia: Allicin; Wikipedia: Ebers Papyrus.

Related:

Labels:

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

COMMENTS

BLOGGER