
LifeGate.com
In June 2016, the city of Buenos Aires announced it would close its historic zoo in the Palermo district and turn it into an "ecopark". Mayor Horacio Rodríguez Larreta explained the decision bluntly, saying that keeping animals in captivity this way was degrading for them. The zoo did close, and in 2018 the site reopened as the Buenos Aires Eco-Park, a space focused on conservation, rescue and education rather than on displaying caged animals for entertainment.
The move was celebrated by animal welfare campaigners around the world. Here is what was announced, why it happened, what became of the animals, and what the case says about the future of zoos.
What Buenos Aires announced in 2016
The plan, as The Guardian reported at the time, was to move most of the zoo's roughly 2,500 animals, from 89 species of mammals, 49 of reptiles and 175 of birds, to nature reserves and sanctuaries around Argentina and abroad, where they could live in more suitable conditions. Animals too old or too fragile to survive a move would stay on site, but out of public view.
The grounds themselves would become an ecopark aimed especially at children, teaching people how to care for and live alongside other species. City officials also said the park would take in wildlife rescued from illegal trafficking and help rehabilitate it.
Rodríguez Larreta framed the change as a matter of respect: if the city truly valued animals, he argued, the way they were being kept at the zoo was not the way to show it.
A zoo with a long and troubled history
The zoo opened in 1888, when the land passed from the national government to the city and mayor Antonio Crespo separated it from the surrounding Parque Tres de Febrero. Many reports in 2016 called it "140 years old"; it was in fact about 128 years old when the closure was announced. It covered around 18 hectares and was famous for its ornate buildings, many designed under early directors Eduardo Ladislao Holmberg and Clemente Onelli. The grounds were declared a National Historic Monument in 1997, and more than 40 historic structures were later restored.
By the 2010s, the zoo was also a source of controversy. Critics pointed to cramped, outdated enclosures in the middle of a hot, noisy capital. The case that drew most attention was Winner, the zoo's last polar bear, who died of fever in 2012; campaigners argued an animal adapted to the Arctic should never have been kept in Buenos Aires summers.
Another resident made legal history. In December 2014 a Buenos Aires court described Sandra, a Sumatran orangutan then about 29 years old, as a "non-human person" with basic rights, opening the door to her eventual release from her enclosure. Her case became a symbol for the wider debate about animal captivity in Argentina.
Gerardo Biglia, an animal rights lawyer who had campaigned for years for the zoo's closure, told reporters that the key step was breaking with "the model of captivity and exhibition", adding that children increasingly see caging animals as plainly wrong.
What happened to the animals
Closing a zoo is far slower than announcing it. Moving thousands of animals safely requires finding suitable homes, building transport crates, getting permits, and in some cases sedating large and stressed animals. In Buenos Aires the process took years.
- Most animals were relocated to reserves and other facilities, including the Temaikèn wildlife park outside the city.
- Sandra the orangutan moved in 2019 to the Center for Great Apes in Wauchula, Florida, a sanctuary for orangutans and chimpanzees.
- Mara the elephant, who had lived at the zoo since 1995, travelled in May 2020 to the Mato Grosso Elephant Sanctuary in Brazil, a long road journey that drew international coverage.
- Older animals that could not be moved remained, receiving care away from the public.
The relocations were not free of criticism. Some campaigners argued the moves were too slow, and there were reports of animals dying during the long transition. Those debates show how hard it is to undo decades of captivity once animals depend on human care.
From zoo to Eco-Park
The site reopened in 2018 as the Buenos Aires Eco-Park (Ecoparque). Its historic buildings have been restored and reused, and the focus has shifted to environmental education, wildlife rescue and conservation programmes. Visitors today see native birds, rodents, nutria, rabbits and peacocks wandering freely in the grounds rather than exotic species behind bars.
The transformation is still discussed as a model, and as a cautionary tale. It shows a city can change course, but also that doing so properly takes long-term funding, expert veterinary work and partner sanctuaries willing to take animals in.
Did Costa Rica really close all its zoos?
Coverage in 2016 often said Buenos Aires was following Costa Rica, which had supposedly shut down all of its zoos. That was not accurate at the time. In 2013, Costa Rica announced plans to close its two state-run zoos in San José, the Simón Bolívar Zoo and the Santa Ana Conservation Center, but legal challenges delayed the closure for roughly a decade.
According to the animal charity Born Free, the state zoos were finally closed in May 2024, with 287 animals, including a jaguar, crocodiles and spider monkeys, moved to a rescue centre for assessment. Eighteen private zoos can still operate legally in Costa Rica.
Are zoos good or bad for animals?
The Buenos Aires decision sits within a long and genuine debate. Defenders of modern zoos point to breeding programmes for endangered species, research, and the role zoos play in inspiring visitors to care about wildlife. Accredited institutions often fund field conservation as well.
Critics reply that only a minority of animals in zoos belong to conservation breeding programmes, and that large, wide-ranging or highly intelligent animals such as elephants, great apes, big cats and polar bears suffer in confinement, often showing repetitive stress behaviours. They argue that money is better spent protecting habitats in the wild.
Many people now land somewhere in between: supporting sanctuaries and rescue centres that care for animals who cannot return to the wild, while questioning the keeping of species purely for display. If you want to visit animals responsibly, look for places that do not breed for display, do not offer rides or performances, and can explain how they support conservation in the wild.
Buenos Aires showed that a big city can rethink a century-old institution. The animals it moved, and the ones that remain, are a reminder that the hardest part of ending captivity is caring well for the animals already in it.
Sources: Wikipedia: Buenos Aires Eco-Park; KFI / iHeart, 11 November 2019: Orangutan granted legal personhood finds new home in Florida; Born Free, 23 May 2024: Costa Rica closes state zoos. Story first shared by True Activist; lead photo via LifeGate.
Related:- Lehe Ledu's Caged-Vehicle Zoo Experience
- This Man Mastered The Art Of Animal Selfies! One With Parrot Is Priceless!
- 25 Amazing Pictures Of Wild Animals And Their Babies
- 15 Animals That Are In Danger Of Extinction (Unless We Try To Protect Them)
- Everything You Think You Know About Animals Is Wrong
- Jimmy Craig's They Can Talk: Animal Conversations in Comics
- Human–Animal Role Reversals in Ethical Cartoons
- Illustrations That Reverse the Roles of Humans and Animals
- Disturbing Aerial Photos Show What Killing Billions Of Animals For Meat Is Doing To The Environment
- Environmental Illustrations and the Questions Behind Their Message
- You Will Want To Recycle Everything After Seeing These Photos!
- A Film About Ocean Plastic and Seabirds
- Social Commentary in an Illustrated Gallery of Everyday Life
- Twenty-Nine Social Satire Illustrations by Paweł Kuczyński
- Twelve Satirical Cartoons by Petry and Crisan
- More Disturbing (But Amazing) Pictures Expose The Absurdities Of Modern Culture *Warning: Graphic Images*
- Disturbing (But Amazing) Pictures Expose The Absurdities Of Modern Culture *Warning: Graphic Images*

I think this is great news and that all zoos should take notice. What a sad existence for our world's beautiful animals. Next we need to stop deforestation and animal murder for stupid items like ivory. The world can be a better place with great education of why it's best to respect our planet
ReplyDelete