Are Smart People Happier With Fewer Friends? What the Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-09-11.

Intelligence, Friendship and Solitude: Interpreting a Happiness Study

Headlines in 2016 announced that intelligent people are "better off alone" or "happier with fewer friends". The study behind them is real, but what it found is narrower and more modest than those headlines suggest. In a large sample of young American adults, people who saw friends more often were generally more satisfied with life, and people with higher test scores showed a slightly weaker, and at the very top a slightly reversed, version of that pattern.

Here is what the researchers measured, what they actually found, how they explained it, and why it is no reason for anyone to start avoiding their friends.

The study in brief

The paper, "Country roads, take me home… to my friends: How intelligence, population density, and friendship affect modern happiness", was published in the British Journal of Psychology in 2016. Its authors were evolutionary psychologists Norman Li of Singapore Management University and Satoshi Kanazawa of the London School of Economics.

They used data from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health (Add Health), a long-running US survey. The sample came from its third wave, collected in 2001–2002, and included 15,197 people aged 18 to 28.

  • Life satisfaction was a single question: how satisfied are you with your life as a whole, on a five-point scale.
  • Intelligence came from a shortened vocabulary test (the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test), converted to an IQ-style score.
  • Socialising meant how many times in the past seven days the person had hung out with friends or talked to them on the phone for more than five minutes.
  • Population density was measured at several levels, from the local neighbourhood to the whole state.

What the researchers found

Three main results came out of the analysis.

1. Crowded places were linked to lower satisfaction. At every geographic level, people living in more densely populated areas reported slightly lower life satisfaction than those in less crowded places.

2. Seeing friends more often was linked to higher satisfaction. This held for the sample as a whole, after controlling for factors such as marital status, income and education.

3. Intelligence changed both patterns. The negative link with density was weaker for people with higher scores. And the positive link with socialising shrank as intelligence rose. Among the most intelligent respondents, more frequent socialising was associated with slightly lower life satisfaction.

That third finding is the one that made headlines. Notice what it does and does not say. It concerns time spent with friends, not family. It does not say smart people have no friends, dislike people or are lonely. It describes a small statistical interaction in survey data from young adults in the United States.

How small were the effects?

Very small. In the authors' own figures, the difference in life satisfaction linked to socialising among high-IQ respondents was around three hundredths of a standard deviation, a size that would be invisible in everyday life. The authors themselves describe the effects as small and call for the results to be replicated.

They also note other limits. The data are correlational, so the study cannot show that socialising causes changes in happiness or the reverse. Happier people may simply choose to live in quieter places or see friends more often. Intelligence was measured with a verbal test only. "Friends" was never defined, and socialising was counted over a single week, before most online social life existed.

The savanna theory of happiness

Li and Kanazawa interpreted their results through what they called the savanna theory of happiness. The idea is that the human brain evolved for life in small groups of perhaps 150 people spread across open land, so modern conditions such as dense cities may sit uneasily with it. Frequent contact with friends and allies, which mattered for survival in ancestral groups, should feel rewarding.

Why would intelligence change that? Kanazawa has argued in earlier work that general intelligence evolved to deal with novel problems, so more intelligent people may be better at adapting to unfamiliar modern environments and less tied to ancestral preferences.

This explanation is a theory, not something the study tested directly, and it has critics. Evolutionary stories about modern behaviour are notoriously hard to prove, and Kanazawa's wider body of work has been controversial. A 2011 blog post of his on race and attractiveness was widely condemned and led to a reprimand from the LSE. That does not invalidate this dataset, but it is a reason to read the interpretation with care.

A simpler explanation: goals and time

Other researchers offered more down-to-earth readings. Carol Graham, who studies the economics of happiness at the Brookings Institution, suggested to the Washington Post that people with more intelligence and the capacity to use it are probably focused on some longer-term objective, so time spent socialising may compete with goals that matter to them.

That fits everyday experience. A medical student, a founder building a company or a researcher deep in a project may feel that a busy social calendar pulls them away from the work that gives them satisfaction. Nothing about that requires evolutionary theory, and nothing about it means friendships are bad for them.

Common myths this study does not support

  • "Loners are geniuses." The study did not look at loners, and preferring your own company is not evidence of high intelligence.
  • "Smart people are happier without friends." Even for the highest scorers, the effect was tiny, and the study did not compare people with and without friendships.
  • "Spending time with family makes smart people unhappy." Family was not part of the socialising measure.
  • "Friendship is overrated." A large body of research links strong social ties to better health and longer life. One small interaction effect does not overturn that.

What to take from it

The most useful lesson is personal rather than statistical. People differ in how much social time leaves them energised and how much leaves them drained. Some do their best thinking alone and need fewer, deeper friendships; others thrive on a full calendar. Both are normal, and neither says anything about your IQ.

If you find that solitude helps you focus, protect some of it. If you notice you are withdrawing because you feel low or isolated rather than because you are absorbed in something, that is worth talking about with someone you trust or a doctor. And whatever your test scores, a handful of good friends remains one of the more reliable ingredients of a satisfying life.

Sources: Li & Kanazawa (2016), British Journal of Psychology, SMU repository record; full paper (PDF); originally reported via Expanded Consciousness.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1
  1. Perfect! A hard thing is to explain to the people why you do the things the way you do. In our mind it is clear that to expend time talking about the same subject everyday, nothing new, makes no sense.

    ReplyDelete