Chrystul Kizer: The $400,000 Bail Campaign and How Her Case Ended

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-24.

On 22 June 2020, Chrystul Kizer, then 19, walked out of the Kenosha County Jail in Wisconsin after community groups paid her $400,000 bond. She had been held for nearly two years, charged with first-degree intentional homicide over the 2018 killing of Randall Volar, a man she said had sexually abused and trafficked her since she was 16. Bail did not end the case. It went to the Wisconsin Supreme Court, and in August 2024 Kizer was sentenced to 11 years in prison after pleading guilty to a reduced charge.

Chrystul Kizer's Release on Bail in 2020

Who Chrystul Kizer is and what happened in 2018

Kizer, a Black teenager, met Volar, a white man in his 30s from Kenosha, through the classified site Backpage in 2017, when she was 16. She said he gave her gifts and money, then sexually abused her and sold her to other men online. Court records and police files show he abused other underage girls too.

In February 2018 a 15-year-old girl called police from Volar's home saying he had drugged her. A search turned up hundreds of videos of him abusing Kizer and other underage girls. Volar was arrested on 22 February 2018 for child enticement and child sexual assault offences, then released the same day without bail. Police waited about three months before sending the case to prosecutors.

On 5 June 2018, Kizer, then 17, shot Volar dead at his house. The house was set on fire and his car was taken. She was arrested days later and charged as an adult with first-degree intentional homicide, which carries a mandatory life sentence in Wisconsin, as well as arson, car theft and other counts.

How the $400,000 bond was raised

Kizer's bail was first set at $1 million. In February 2020 Judge David Wilk lowered it to $400,000, still far beyond what her family could pay. Four organisations then pooled donations from the public: the Chicago Community Bond Fund, the Chrystul Kizer Defense Committee, the Milwaukee Freedom Fund and Survived & Punished, a national group that supports survivors of abuse who have been criminalised.

Community bail funds like these grew quickly in the US in the 2010s. Their argument is that cash bail jails people who have not been convicted simply because they are poor. Money posted as bail is normally returned when the case ends, which lets the funds reuse it; supporters said at the time that any returned money would go towards anti-trafficking work and other causes.

In a statement, the Chicago Community Bond Fund said that "far too often, survivors of violence—especially Black women and girls—are punished for defending themselves".

The two sides of the case

The defence said Kizer acted to escape a man who had abused her for over a year, and that she should never have faced a murder charge. Her supporters, organised as the Chrystul Kizer Defense Committee, described her as a trafficking victim whom the system had failed twice: first when police released Volar, and again when prosecutors charged her as an adult. The committee's comments at the time were reported by Yahoo.

Prosecutors argued that the killing was planned and that the motive was to take Volar's car, not to escape trafficking. Reports at the time said prosecutors pointed to her having obtained a police scanner before the shooting. They also said prosecutors had offered a plea deal on lesser charges that would still have meant about 21 years in prison; those terms were reportedly declined and could not be independently confirmed.

The legal question: can a trafficking victim's defence cover a killing?

Wisconsin law (section 939.46 of the statutes) gives victims of human trafficking and child sex trafficking an affirmative defence for "any offense" committed as a direct result of being trafficked. The case turned on what "any offense" means.

In December 2019 Judge Wilk ruled that the defence applied only to crimes such as prostitution, not to violent crimes, which meant Kizer could not raise it at trial. In June 2021 the Wisconsin Court of Appeals reversed him. On 6 July 2022 the Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled 4–3 that the defence can apply to any crime, including homicide, if it was a direct result of trafficking, and that it is a complete defence rather than just a reason for a lighter sentence. The case was sent back for trial, where a jury would decide whether her actions met that test.

The ruling made Wisconsin v. Kizer an important precedent for trafficking survivors across the US. It did not decide that Kizer was innocent. It decided only that she was allowed to argue the defence.

How the case ended

Several more turns followed. In October 2023 the trial court ruled that statements Kizer made to police after her arrest could not be used, because she had not been properly warned of her rights. In February 2024 her bail was revoked after a misdemeanour disorderly conduct charge, and she returned to jail.

On 9 May 2024, shortly before trial, Kizer pleaded guilty to second-degree reckless homicide, which carries a maximum of 25 years. The arson, car theft, firearm and bail-jumping charges were dismissed. On 19 August 2024 she was sentenced to 11 years in prison, with credit for more than a year and a half already served, followed by five years of extended supervision.

Why the case still matters

The Kizer case is often discussed alongside that of Cyntoia Brown, a Tennessee trafficking victim convicted of murder as a teenager and later granted clemency. Both raised the same hard question: how should the law treat a young person who kills someone who was exploiting them?

Several lessons stand out. Police and prosecutors were criticised for leaving Volar free after strong evidence of child abuse was found. The bail campaign showed how much pretrial detention depends on money. And the Supreme Court ruling clarified, for Wisconsin, that trafficking victims can raise their abuse as a defence even in the most serious cases. The final outcome, a plea and a long sentence, shows that the defence is a chance to be heard, not a guarantee.

If you think someone is being trafficked in the US, the National Human Trafficking Hotline can be reached on 1-888-373-7888. In an emergency, call 911 or your local emergency number.

Sources: Wikipedia: Wisconsin v. Kizer; AP via Upper Michigan's Source, 19 August 2024; Chicago Community Bond Fund, 22 June 2020; tweets by Chicago Community Bond Fund and Milwaukee Black & Pink.

COMMENTS