Chrystul Kizer Case: Trafficking Defence, Plea and 11-Year Sentence

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-02-24.

Chrystul Kizer's Case as Reported in 2020

Chrystul Kizer was 17 when she shot and killed Randall Volar, a Kenosha man in his thirties who had been sexually abusing and selling her since she was 16. Prosecutors charged her with first-degree intentional homicide, a charge that carries a mandatory life sentence in Wisconsin. Her case became a national test of one question: can a law meant to protect trafficking victims cover a violent act against the trafficker?

The answer, after six years in court, was a partial yes. In 2022 the Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled that the state's trafficking-victim defence can apply to any offence, including homicide. In 2024 Kizer took a plea deal for second-degree reckless homicide and was sentenced to 11 years in prison. Here is how the case unfolded, what the courts decided, and why so many people followed it.

Who Randall Volar was, and what police already knew

Kizer met Volar in 2017 through Backpage, a classified-ads site later shut down by federal authorities for hosting sex-trafficking adverts. According to reporting by the Washington Post and court records summarised on Wikipedia, Volar paid her, bought her gifts and gradually took control of her money and movements, selling her to other men. Investigators later linked him to about a dozen underage girls, most of them Black teenagers.

Police had a clear view of this months before he died. In February 2018 a 15-year-old girl called officers from his home, saying she had been drugged. A search turned up hundreds of video recordings showing Volar abusing underage girls, Kizer among them. On 22 February 2018 he was arrested on charges that included child enticement and second-degree sexual assault of a child.

He was released the same day without bail. Police then took about three months to refer the case to prosecutors, and no charges had been filed by the time he was killed. Many observers saw that delay as the core failure of the whole story: a man with recorded evidence of child abuse against him remained free, and the girls in those recordings remained within his reach.

The night of 5 June 2018

On 5 June 2018 Kizer shot Volar at his house in Kenosha. The house was then set on fire, and she drove away in his BMW. Police traced the car and arrested her in Milwaukee. After first offering other accounts, she admitted the shooting.

Her version, as reported by the Washington Post, is that she had gone back to Volar's home because she had nowhere else to stay, that she realised she had been drugged, and that he was touching her and trying to force himself on her when she fired. She has said she remembers little of what followed, including the fire. A friend had reportedly given her a handgun weeks earlier for protection against Volar.

Kenosha County District Attorney Michael Graveley took a different view. His office argued the killing was planned and that Kizer wanted Volar's car, not escape from abuse. It filed first-degree intentional homicide charges in adult court, along with arson, car theft, illegal firearm possession and other counts.

The affirmative defence at the centre of the case

Wisconsin, like many US states, has a law that protects trafficking victims from prosecution for crimes they were forced into. The statute, section 939.46, gives victims an affirmative defence for "any offense committed as a direct result" of being trafficked. An affirmative defence means the accused admits the act but argues it was legally excused.

Lawmakers mostly had in mind offences like prostitution or carrying drugs. Kizer's lawyers argued that the words "any offense" meant exactly what they said. In December 2019 Kenosha County Circuit Judge David Wilk disagreed. He ruled that applying the defence to a killing would be "an absurd result" and barred her from raising it at trial. If that ruling had stood, the jury would have heard almost nothing about the trafficking, and a conviction would have meant life in prison.

That was the point at which the case drew national attention. Advocates compared it with the case of Cyntoia Brown in Tennessee, who served 15 years for killing a man who had bought her for sex as a teenager before she was granted clemency in 2019.

Bail, appeals and the 2022 Supreme Court ruling

Kizer spent nearly two years in jail on a $1 million bond. In February 2020 Judge Wilk lowered it to $400,000. In June 2020 community groups, including the Chicago Community Bond Fund, the Milwaukee Freedom Fund, Survived and Punished and the Chrystul Kizer Defense Committee, raised the money and she was released.

In June 2021 the Wisconsin Court of Appeals reversed Wilk's ruling, holding that the defence applies to any offence, violent ones included. Prosecutors appealed. On 6 July 2022 the Wisconsin Supreme Court upheld the appeals court by four votes to three. Justice Rebecca Dallet's majority opinion said the defence is a complete defence, not just a factor that reduces punishment. It also set the test: there must be a logical, causal connection between the offence and the trafficking.

The ruling did not declare Kizer innocent. It only meant a jury could hear her argument and decide whether the killing was a direct result of what Volar did to her. The case went back to Kenosha for trial.

The plea deal and 11-year sentence

In October 2023 the trial court ruled that Kizer's statements to police could not be used, because she had not been properly warned of her rights and had no lawyer present. Early in 2024 she was charged with misdemeanour disorderly conduct, her bail was revoked and she returned to jail.

On 9 May 2024, shortly before trial, she pleaded guilty to second-degree reckless homicide, which carries up to 25 years. The arson, car theft, gun and bail-jumping charges were dismissed. On 19 August 2024 she was sentenced to 11 years in prison followed by five years of extended supervision, with more than a year and a half of time already served credited. A plea avoided the risk of a life sentence, but it also meant a jury never decided whether the trafficking defence applied to her.

Why the case still matters

The Kizer case is now a reference point in debates about how the justice system treats trafficking survivors who fight back. Three lessons stand out.

  • Delays in abuse cases have consequences. Volar was free because evidence sat for months without charges. Faster action would have protected every girl in those recordings.
  • Victim-defence laws need clear wording. The Wisconsin ruling now gives courts a test for the "direct result" link, which other states may look to when similar cases arise.
  • Victims of trafficking rarely look like the stereotype. Many are teenagers who were groomed with gifts, money and attention, and who may appear to go back to their abuser "willingly" because they have nowhere else to go.

People in the United States who suspect trafficking can contact the National Human Trafficking Hotline on 1-888-373-7888. Anyone in immediate danger should call emergency services.

(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)



(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)



(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)



(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

Sources: Wikipedia: Wisconsin v. Kizer; The Washington Post (2019): investigation into Volar and Kizer; Associated Press via Upper Michigan's Source (19 August 2024): Woman who argued she legally killed sex trafficker gets 11 years in prison.

COMMENTS