Why Women Leave Men They Love: The Cost of Not Being Present

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-12-19.

Most people assume relationships end because of a dramatic betrayal or a huge fight. Counsellors often see something quieter. A partner can still love the person they are married to and still decide to go, because over months or years they stopped feeling seen, heard and chosen. The short answer to why women leave men they love, at least in the experience of Canadian marriage counsellor Justice Schanfarber, is absence: a husband who is physically around but emotionally somewhere else.

Why Someone May Leave a Partner They Still Love

Schanfarber made this point in a widely shared 2015 essay written for men in struggling marriages. Below we look at his central idea, what relationship research says about it, why the same pattern applies to any gender, and what a distracted partner can actually do before it is too late.

The core idea: love is not the same as feeling connected

In Schanfarber's account, the men in these stories are not villains. Many are reliable providers, kind fathers and pleasant company. They work long hours, or they unwind with television, games, sport or a hobby. None of this is wrong on its own. The trouble starts when these habits fill every gap, and the partner at home slowly becomes part of the furniture.

The women he describes rarely leave on a whim. They agonise over it, sometimes for years, and they often still care deeply about their husbands when they finally walk out. Some admit to him that they feel so emotionally unattended that a stranger who simply paid attention could carry them off. That admission tends to frighten the person saying it as much as anyone else.

His message to men is blunt: a spouse is not a possession, and her closeness is not owed. It has to be earned again and again through attention, curiosity and real engagement. He also adds a note that is easy to miss: the same dynamic runs in both directions. Men leave emotionally absent wives, and partners in same-sex couples drift apart in exactly the same way.

What the research says about attention and staying together

Schanfarber's observations line up well with decades of work by psychologist John Gottman, who has studied thousands of couples. Gottman describes the small attempts partners make to connect as bids: a comment about a bird outside the window, a sigh after a hard day, a question about the weekend. Each bid gets one of three responses. A partner can turn toward it, turn away from it by not noticing, or turn against it with irritation.

In one of his best-known studies, Gottman followed newlywed couples for six years. According to the Gottman Institute, couples who were still married at the follow-up had turned toward each other's bids about 86 percent of the time, while couples who had divorced managed only around 33 percent. The Institute also points out that ignoring a bid can do more damage than openly rejecting it, because a rejection at least leaves room to argue and repair, while silence leaves nothing to work with.

That is exactly the kind of absence Schanfarber describes. It is not a single cruel act. It is hundreds of tiny moments in which one person reached out and the other was looking at a phone.

There is also a reason this story is usually told about women. In the United States, wives have filed for most divorces for a long time. National Center for Health Statistics figures from 1975 and 1988 put the share at roughly two-thirds in families with children. Filing a case is not the same as being the only one who wanted out, and the numbers do not explain any individual marriage, but they help explain why counsellors so often hear husbands say they never saw it coming.

Why emotional absence hurts so much

Being ignored by a stranger is mildly annoying. Being ignored by the person who promised to share your life is a different experience entirely. A few reasons stand out:

  • It feels like a verdict. When someone repeatedly misses your attempts to connect, it is hard not to conclude that you no longer matter to them.
  • It is hard to complain about. There is no single event to point to. Saying that a partner seems far away can sound vague or needy, so many people stay quiet until they are exhausted.
  • It builds up silently. The person who is drifting often feels that everything is fine, while the other person has been grieving the relationship for a long time. By the time the conversation finally happens, one of them may already be halfway out the door.
  • It drains desire as well as friendship. Schanfarber argues that what draws a partner in is not routine affection or rushed intimacy but a sense of aliveness and passion for life. When that disappears into autopilot, attraction often goes with it.

What being present actually looks like

Presence sounds abstract, so it helps to make it concrete. Schanfarber suggests a few simple practices, and they overlap with what many couples therapists recommend:

Listen without steering

When your partner talks about something that matters to them, notice whether your mind wanders off to your own plans. Resist the urge to fix, to debate or to play devil's advocate. A polite nod while thinking about something else is still absence. Ask one more question than you normally would.

Really look at them

After years together, it is easy to stop seeing the person in front of you. Schanfarber suggests holding eye contact a little longer than feels natural and treating your partner as someone you are still getting to know, which you are. People change, and staying curious about who they are becoming is part of staying close.

Touch with attention

He also encourages slowing down physical contact and paying attention to what you feel in the moment, a mindfulness approach applied to everyday affection. A hand on a shoulder given with full attention communicates more than a distracted hug.

Start with five minutes

The most practical part of his advice is also the most modest. Forget grand gestures for now. Commit to five minutes a day of complete, undistracted attention: phone away, television off, no multitasking. Date nights and holidays are welcome, but they cannot make up for a daily pattern of not being there.

Common myths about why people leave

Myth: if she loved him, she would stay. Love and a workable relationship are not the same thing. Many people leave while still loving their partner, because the relationship no longer gives them what they need to feel like themselves.

Myth: a good provider has done his part. Financial support and practical help matter a great deal, but they do not replace emotional connection. A partner can be grateful for the mortgage being paid and still feel lonely every evening.

Myth: there is always someone else. Sometimes there is. Often the decision comes first, built over years of feeling unseen, and a new person is a symptom rather than the cause.

Myth: this is only about men. Schanfarber himself notes that the pattern can run either way. Any partner who checks out emotionally, of any gender, risks the same outcome.

If your partner is already raising concerns

If your partner keeps bringing up the same complaint, take it as information rather than nagging. Ask what specific change would make a difference and whether past promises were kept. Repeated requests that go nowhere are often the stage just before someone stops asking at all.

Couples counselling can help both people say difficult things safely, and it works best when started early rather than as a last resort. If either partner is dealing with depression, burnout or addiction, which can all look like disinterest, talking to a doctor or a qualified therapist is a sensible step. And if the relationship involves fear or control, the priority is safety, not presence.

The encouraging part of Schanfarber's message is that the fix is within reach. Attention is free. It costs a few minutes and the willingness to put everything else down for a while, and many people who try it find they do not want to stop.

Sources: Justice Schanfarber, Why women leave men they love; The Gottman Institute, Turn Toward Instead of Away; Wikipedia, Divorce in the United States (citing National Center for Health Statistics data). Earlier shared via Idealist4ever.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 3
  1. Women act like children. Women are not held accountable for their actions growing up, so they are completely new to the concept of accountability. We have to treat women like children. As stupid as its sounds you can completely avoid a lot of arguments by ignoring everything she says and going for the underlying problem. I cant believe you never told me that you X! Aww is she hungry. She gets this way when shes hungry. Then just feed her some Greek yogurt or something, and the problem will go away. Or just take her for a walk around the block, because shes just anxious from being at work the entire day.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Why would a man take 5mins a day to appreciate a nagging, abusive hag? If your man isn't around, it's your fault. Not his. Stop berating him. Stop treating him like a child. Stop buying into the feminazism in the belief you should be worshiped on pedestal. Go out there and earn his respect. Give him a beer and flash of the boobies while he's watching the game. Have lunch ready, even a simple one, when he comes in from doing some chores. Give him a little attention and you'll get alot back. If he isn't spending time with you he has already realized he doesn't need you to thrive. You can and will be replaced by a younger model and he isn't to blame for it. Hypergamy never works out for you and you will be even more miserable once that fling has pumped-and-dumped you. Remember this, your sexual market value decreases with age because your physical beauty fades and you may have kids. A man's sexual market value usually continues to rise until the 50s because of his resource accrual.

    ReplyDelete
  3. These underpants enable you to crush into those provocative dresses and body-cognizant skirts. Constrictive supports and excruciating undergarments are a relic of times gone by. The present shapewear for ladies are agreeable, customizable and even beautiful. bodyshaper plus size

    ReplyDelete