Originally published 2016-11-19.
Thorn, the nonprofit co-founded by Ashton Kutcher and Demi Moore, builds software that helps police find victims of child sexual exploitation and trafficking online. In 2016 and 2017 Kutcher said its tools had helped identify more than 6,000 trafficking victims in the United States in a single year. That figure is real in the sense that it comes from Thorn's own surveys of the police officers who use its tools, but it describes victims identified with Thorn's help, not people Thorn itself rescued.
TechCrunch
Here is where the number came from, how Thorn's technology works, what it has and has not achieved, and why Kutcher left the organisation's board in 2023.
Where the 6,000 figure came from
Kutcher first spread the number in media appearances in late 2016, including a visit to NBC's Today show while promoting his Netflix comedy The Ranch. He set out the details more fully in testimony to the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee on 15 February 2017.
In that testimony he said Thorn's main police tool, Spotlight, had helped identify more than 6,000 trafficking victims over the previous twelve months, around 2,000 of them minors, and more than 2,200 suspected traffickers. He said more than 4,000 officers across all 50 states were using it, and that some reported cutting investigation time by up to 60%.
Two points are worth keeping in mind. First, these are Thorn's own numbers, gathered by surveying officers who use Spotlight; no independent audit was published with them. Second, the 2,200 traffickers were identified, not necessarily arrested or convicted. Some coverage at the time said Thorn had put 2,000 criminals in jail, which goes further than the evidence.
The fact-checking site Snopes looked at the same confusion in 2018, after viral posts claimed Kutcher's software had rescued 6,000 children. Citing Thorn's 2017 impact report, it found that Spotlight had helped identify roughly 5,800 child victims and more than 18,000 victims overall between 2015 and 2017. Identification is a real and valuable step, but the rescue itself is carried out by police and support services.
What Thorn is and when it started
Kutcher and Moore launched the organisation in 2009 as the DNA Foundation, while they were still married. It was renamed Thorn: Digital Defenders of Children in November 2012, after the couple separated. Earlier accounts that dated it to 2008, or described Moore as Kutcher's ex-wife at the time of founding, had the details slightly wrong.
From the start, the focus was technology. The founders' argument was that the internet had become the main marketplace for the sexual exploitation of children, so the response needed to be built there too. On Today, Kutcher summed up the approach simply: abuse was being bought and sold online, "and so we're building digital tools to fight back against it."
Julie Cordua has led the organisation day to day. Its board has included Kutcher, Moore, philanthropist Ray Chambers and tech investor Jim Pitkow, who chaired Thorn's Technical Task Force.
How Thorn's tools work
Spotlight collects and analyses online escort advertisements. Traffickers post huge numbers of ads, often changing names, photos and phone numbers. The software uses data analysis and machine learning to link ads that appear to involve the same person or network and to flag signs that a minor may be involved. Investigators can then search that history instead of scrolling through thousands of listings by hand.
In his Senate testimony Kutcher described one case in which Spotlight helped officers find a missing girl in three days, a search he said could otherwise have taken months.
Thorn has also worked on tools for the dark web and, later, on Safer, a service that helps online platforms detect known child sexual abuse material uploaded to their systems. Its Technical Task Force brought in volunteers and support from technology companies; Microsoft, Mozilla, Palantir, Salesforce and Symantec are among those named as participants, and in 2013 Thorn was in talks with Facebook, Google and Twitter about a shared database of abuse images.
Pitkow's view, as he put it at the time, was that every new technology is used for both good and harm, and Thorn's job was to tilt the balance towards protecting children.
The bigger picture on trafficking
Coverage in 2016 often quoted an International Labour Organization estimate, cited by the anti-trafficking group Polaris, that about 4.5 million people worldwide were trapped in forced sexual exploitation. That estimate dated from 2012. The ILO's more recent global estimates, published in 2022, count about 27.6 million people in forced labour of all kinds, with commercial sexual exploitation one significant part.
Another widely repeated claim was that the underground sex economy in Atlanta was worth $290 million in 2014. In fact, the Urban Institute study it linked to was published in 2014 but measured the year 2007. Across the eight US cities it studied, estimates ranged from $39.9 million to $290 million, with Atlanta reported at the top. The same research found that commercial sex was moving from the street to the internet, which is exactly the shift Thorn was set up to address.
At the end of the 2016 interview Kutcher made a much bolder promise: "I'm going to eliminate child pornography from the internet." No organisation has achieved that, and child protection experts generally describe the problem as one to be reduced and contained rather than erased.
Criticism and debate
Thorn's work has broad support, but it has also drawn criticism. Sex worker advocates have argued that tools built around escort ads can blur the line between consenting adults and trafficking victims, and that headline figures can be hard to verify from outside.
In Europe, journalists at Netzpolitik.org, Follow the Money and other outlets have questioned Thorn's lobbying for the EU's proposed "chat control" law, which would require platforms to scan private messages for abuse material. They argued that Thorn's advocacy overlapped with its interest as a provider of scanning software. In 2024 the European Ombudsman also found maladministration in how Europol handled a former staff member's move to Thorn.
None of this means the tools do not help. It does mean readers should treat impact figures from any advocacy group, Thorn included, as claims to be checked rather than settled facts.
Kutcher steps down
In September 2023 Kutcher resigned as chairman of Thorn's board. He and his wife, Mila Kunis, had written letters asking a judge for leniency for their former That '70s Show co-star Danny Masterson, who had been convicted of rape and sentenced to 30 years to life. The letters caused an outcry, especially given Thorn's mission. In his resignation letter he wrote: "I cannot allow my error in judgment to distract from our efforts and the children we serve."
Thorn continued its work after his departure. Its story is a useful example of both what technology can add to child protection, and why big numbers deserve a careful look at what exactly is being counted.
Sources: US Senate Foreign Relations Committee: Ashton Kutcher testimony (15 February 2017); Snopes: Did Ashton Kutcher's software rescue 6,000 children?; Wikipedia: Thorn (organization); Urban Institute: Estimating the Size and Structure of the Underground Commercial Sex Economy (2014); International Labour Organization: Forced labour, modern slavery and trafficking. Photo: TechCrunch. Original story via True Activist.
COMMENTS