Leaked Çakabey Plan: Turkish Military Scenarios for Greece and Armenia

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-06-24.

Leaked Plans Show Turkish Military Scenarios for Greece and Armenia

In June 2020 the Swedish-based news site Nordic Monitor published what it said was a classified Turkish Armed Forces planning directive, dated 13 June 2014 and codenamed Çakabey, describing military operations against Greece. The site also referred to an older plan concerning Armenia. The documents are real planning material according to Nordic Monitor, but a contingency plan is not the same as a decision to attack, and no invasion followed.

Here is what was reported, how the papers reportedly came to light, and the history that explains why the story caused such alarm in Athens, Nicosia and Yerevan.

What the leaked Çakabey directive is said to contain

According to Nordic Monitor, the material takes the form of a PowerPoint presentation prepared for the Turkish General Staff as part of an internal planning review. Its Turkish title is TSK Çakabey Harekât Planlama Direktifi, meaning Turkish Armed Forces Çakabey Operation Planning Directive. The site suggested the June 2014 version was a finalised update of an earlier draft and that the plan was presumably still active.

The codename is pointed. Çaka Bey, known in Byzantine sources as Tzachas, was an 11th-century Turkic commander who seized Smyrna (today's İzmir), built a fleet with the help of local shipwrights and captured Aegean islands including Lesbos, Chios, Samos and Rhodes before the Byzantines pushed him back around 1092. The modern Turkish Navy counts his capture of Smyrna as its founding date. Naming an operation after him sends an obvious message about the Aegean.

How the documents surfaced, and how much weight to give them

Nordic Monitor said the files came out of a court case in Ankara. After the failed coup of 15 July 2016, prosecutor Serdar Coşkun ordered the military to hand over two months of internal email from General Staff headquarters. Classified attachments exchanged among commanders reportedly ended up in the case file because they were not removed before it was submitted to court.

Some context helps when reading the story:

  • The source has a viewpoint. Nordic Monitor is run by exiled Turkish journalist Abdullah Bozkurt and is openly critical of President Erdoğan's government. That does not make the documents false, but they have not been independently authenticated.
  • Armies plan for many scenarios. General staffs routinely prepare contingency plans for conflicts with neighbours, including allies. A plan shows what a military has thought about, not what its leaders have ordered.
  • No official confirmation. Coverage at the time, such as the Greek outlet Proto Thema, reported the claims without any response from Ankara.

The right summary, then, is that a dissident outlet published what it says is a Turkish army plan for operations against Greece. It is a warning sign about intentions and mindset, not proof of an imminent attack.

A long history of Greek–Turkish conflict

The story landed hard because the two countries share a painful past. The Ottoman Empire ruled most of Greece for centuries until the War of Independence that began in 1821. The early 20th century brought the Balkan Wars, the First World War, the Greco-Turkish War of 1919–1922 and the burning of Smyrna in 1922, as well as the genocide of Ottoman Greeks.

The 1923 population exchange, agreed at Lausanne, was based on religion rather than language. Around 1.2 million Greek Orthodox Christians from Turkey were sent to Greece, many of them already refugees, and roughly 355,000 Muslims went from Greece to Turkey. The Greeks of Istanbul and of the islands of Imbros and Tenedos, and the Muslims of Western Thrace, were exempted, although the Greek communities of Istanbul and Imbros later shrank dramatically.

Cyprus: the occupation that continues

The most recent war came in 1974. After a coup in Cyprus ordered by the Greek military junta on 15 July, Turkey invaded on 20 July and launched a second offensive on 14 August, taking about 36–37% of the island. Between roughly 140,000 and 200,000 Greek Cypriots were driven from their homes. UN Security Council resolutions called for the withdrawal of foreign troops and declared the 1983 "Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus" legally invalid. Only Turkey recognises it, and Turkish troops still occupy the north of the Republic of Cyprus today.

The tensions of 2020

The leak arrived during one of the tensest years in decades:

  • Energy and maritime borders. Turkey reportedly sought exploration licences for gas in 24 offshore blocks, some of which overlap waters Greece regards as its continental shelf, near islands such as Crete and Rhodes. Greek Foreign Minister Nikos Dendias warned that Athens would respond to any drilling.
  • Questioning the islands. Some Turkish politicians and commentators publicly questioned Greek sovereignty over Aegean islands, rhetoric that Athens treats as a direct threat.
  • The Evros border. In late February 2020 Ankara announced it would no longer stop migrants heading for Europe, and thousands gathered at the Greek land border, some reportedly bused there. Greece saw it as using refugees as pressure, echoing Erdoğan's 2016 threat to "open the gates" after the European Parliament voted to freeze accession talks.
  • Hagia Sophia. Erdoğan pushed to turn the former Orthodox cathedral, a museum since 1934, back into a mosque. Greece's government called any challenge to its status "an insult to the international community and international law". A Turkish court ruling was published on 10 July 2020, Erdoğan declared the building a mosque the same day, and the first Friday prayers were held on 24 July. Greece's culture ministry called it an "open provocation".

Critics also point to Erdoğan's wider record at home: the jailing of journalists and opponents after 2016 and a drift away from the secular principles on which modern Turkey was founded.

Armenia and the shadow of 1915

Nordic Monitor's reporting also mentioned an older plan, from around 2000, concerning Armenia, which borders Turkey to the north-east. Few details were published. For Armenians any such plan is read against the Armenian Genocide of 1915 onwards, in which up to about 1.5 million Armenians were killed by the Ottoman authorities.

The genocide is recognised by 36 states, including the United States since President Biden's statement in April 2021, and repeatedly by the European Parliament. A 1985 report to a UN human rights sub-commission (the Whitaker report) also described the massacres as genocide. Turkey still rejects the term and keeps its border with Armenia closed. In the Second World War, it is worth adding, Turkey stayed neutral for almost the entire conflict and only declared war on Germany and Japan in February 1945.

Is war between Greece and Turkey likely?

Most analysts thought not. Both countries are NATO members, and a Turkish attack on an EU state would carry enormous diplomatic and economic costs. Paul Antonopoulos, a researcher on Greek–Turkish relations, argued at the time that Athens wanted no war and that Turkey, stretched militarily in Syria and Libya and facing an economic crisis, was unlikely to start one. The crises of 2020 eased into talks, though the disputes over borders, islands and Cyprus remain unresolved.

The leak is best read as a reminder that the Aegean is a region where old grievances and military planning are never far apart, and where Greece and Cyprus look for solidarity from their European partners.

Sources: Proto Thema: Turkey has a plan for the invasion of Greece, secret documents reveal (reporting Nordic Monitor); Naftemporiki: Dissident site claims Turkish military plan to invade Greece; Wikipedia: Tzachas (Çaka Bey); Wikipedia: Population exchange between Greece and Turkey; Wikipedia: Turkish invasion of Cyprus; Wikipedia: Armenian genocide recognition; Global News: Hagia Sophia court ruling, July 2020. Quotations from the Greek government and Paul Antonopoulos as reported by the Daily Mail, June 2020.

COMMENTS