Russia's 2015 Accusations Against Bilal Erdoğan Over ISIS Oil

Bilal Erdogan, The Son Of Turkey's President

Did Bilal Erdoğan, son of Turkey's president, fund ISIS by shipping its oil? That accusation spread worldwide in late November 2015, days after Turkey shot down a Russian warplane on the Syrian border. Russian officials said Turkey was the main buyer of oil smuggled from Islamic State territory and that President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and his family were involved. They did not publish evidence linking the family to the trade, Bilal Erdoğan denied it, and no court or independent investigation has confirmed it.

The story still matters, though, because it sits at the meeting point of several real issues: how IS financed itself, how porous the Turkish-Syrian border was in 2014 and 2015, how Ankara's Syria policy was viewed by its neighbours and allies, and how accusations become weapons in a diplomatic crisis. Here is what was claimed, by whom, and what is and is not established.

The shootdown that started the row

On 24 November 2015 a Turkish F-16 shot down a Russian Su-24 bomber near the Syria-Turkey border, saying it had entered Turkish airspace and ignored warnings. Russia insisted the jet never left Syrian airspace. The pilot, Oleg Peshkov, was killed by gunfire from Syrian rebels as he parachuted down; the navigator was rescued, and a Russian marine died during the rescue mission.

Critics were quick to recall Erdoğan's own words from 2012, after Syria shot down a Turkish jet: "a short-term border violation can never be a pretext for an attack." Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said Moscow had "serious doubts this was an unintended incident and believe this is a planned provocation."

What Russia alleged about ISIS oil

According to the Russian foreign ministry's account of a phone call with his Turkish counterpart Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu, Lavrov argued that by downing a jet on a counter-terrorism mission Turkey had effectively sided with IS, and reminded him of Turkey's alleged role in the group's illegal oil trade through the very area where the plane fell. President Vladimir Putin made similar claims, saying oil revenue was funding terrorists.

On 2 December 2015, Deputy Defence Minister Anatoly Antonov went further at a briefing for foreign journalists, saying Turkey's top political leadership, including Erdoğan and his family, was involved in the trade. Russia showed satellite images of what it said were columns of tanker trucks moving from IS-held areas towards Turkey along three routes: to Mediterranean ports, to the Batman refinery, and towards Cizre in the south-east. It also showed footage it said proved trucks crossed the border freely. Officials acknowledged that what they had shown did not prove the Erdoğan family's involvement and said more evidence would follow.

Some Western voices had made broader criticisms. A retired French general, Dominique Trinquand, said that Turkey did very little to stop smuggling of oil, goods and people across its border. In October 2014, then US Vice President Joe Biden told students at Harvard that regional allies, naming Turkey among others, had poured money and weapons into anyone fighting Bashar al-Assad, some of which reached extremists; he apologised to Erdoğan days later.

Who is Bilal Erdoğan?

Necmettin Bilal Erdoğan, born in April 1981, is the president's younger son. After graduating from an imam hatip high school in Istanbul in 1999, he studied in the United States, earning a master's degree from Harvard's John F. Kennedy School of Government in 2004, and briefly interned at the World Bank. He returned to Turkey and went into business, becoming one of three equal shareholders in BMZ Group, a shipping company.

Russia’s 2015 Accusations Against Bilal Erdoğan Over ISIS Oil

BMZ's ships drew attention in Turkish media before the Russian claims. A 2014 report in the opposition newspaper Cumhuriyet asked what the family's vessels were carrying, and the opposition CHP politician Gürsel Tekin publicly accused Bilal Erdoğan of profiting from oil linked to IS. Those were political accusations rather than findings, and the Erdoğan family has always rejected them. Bilal Erdoğan had also been named in the December 2013 corruption investigation in Turkey, which the government called a plot and which was dropped.

The denials and responses

President Erdoğan called the allegations slander and said he would resign if they were proven true. Speaking to Corriere della Sera in Bologna, where he was then studying for a doctorate, Bilal Erdoğan said: "I have nothing to do with such a marine transport." He added that he did not consider IS to be Muslim at all.

The United States also rejected the Russian claim. A State Department spokesman said Washington did not believe the allegations against Turkey's leadership were true. American officials said at the time that most IS oil was sold and consumed inside Syria and Iraq, with smaller amounts smuggled across borders by traders, a picture that differs from a state-run trade.

In 2016 Italian prosecutors in Bologna opened a money-laundering inquiry into Bilal Erdoğan after a complaint by an exiled Turkish businessman. It was reportedly closed the following year without charges, and it was not about IS oil.

Claims that circulated without evidence

Many sites that ran this story in 2015 also reposted a long essay by the writer F. William Engdahl that went much further, alleging that the family ran ISIS oil tankers to Japan from special wharves, that the president's daughter ran a secret field hospital for wounded IS fighters, and that Turkish forces trained IS militants. These claims came largely from websites with poor track records, such as AWD News, and from the analyst Thierry Meyssan, whose site has promoted many conspiracy theories. None has been substantiated by credible reporting, so we do not present them as fact.

What is well documented is that IS sold oil through middlemen in 2014 and 2015, that smuggling across the long Turkish-Syrian border was widespread, and that critics, including US officials, accused Ankara of being slow to seal that border while it focused on fighting Assad and Kurdish forces. Those are serious criticisms of policy; they are not the same as proof that a named individual funded the group.

How the story ended

Russia imposed sanctions on Turkey, banning charter tours and some food imports. The crisis eased in June 2016, when Erdoğan sent Putin a letter expressing sympathy and condolences to the pilot's family, and relations were restored within weeks. Moscow stopped repeating the oil accusations as the two governments became partners in Syria diplomacy and energy projects.

The episode is a useful reminder of how to read wartime claims. Accusations made by one government against another during a crisis can be true, false or partly true, and the timing alone does not tell you which. The test is evidence that can be checked independently. In this case, nearly a decade later, that evidence has never been produced.

Sources: Wikipedia: 2015 Russian Sukhoi Su-24 shootdown; Wikipedia: Bilal Erdoğan; OCCRP, December 2015: Russia reveals "proof" Turkey's Erdogan smuggled IS oil; Anadolu Agency, 8 December 2015: Turkish president's son dismisses Russia oil trade claims; earlier coverage by Sputnik (Lavrov call) and Zero Hedge, and the CNN report on Biden's apology.

Related: