
Joanna Palani is a Danish woman of Kurdish descent who left her political science studies in Copenhagen to fight the so-called Islamic State with Kurdish forces in Syria and Iraq. When she returned to Denmark, she was prosecuted for breaking a travel ban that barred her from going back to the war zone, and was later sentenced to nine months in prison. Her story became international news in early 2017 because of two dramatic claims: that she had killed around 100 ISIS fighters, and that the group had put a $1 million bounty on her head. Neither figure has been independently verified.
Here is what is known about who she is, what she did, why Denmark treated her as a lawbreaker, and why her case still divides opinion.
Who is Joanna Palani?
Palani was born in 1993 in a refugee camp near Ramadi in Iraq. Her family's roots are in the Kermanshah region of Iranian Kurdistan, and she has said both her father and grandfather were Peshmerga fighters. The family received asylum in Denmark when she was a small child, and she grew up there. By her own account she first fired a gun at the age of nine.
In interviews and on social media she framed her decision to fight as a defence of the values she associated with her Danish upbringing. In one widely quoted post she said she went to the front
“to fight for women's rights, for democracy – for the European values I learned as a Danish girl.”

Asger Ladefoged
Fighting with the YPJ and the Peshmerga
Many early reports, including the one this site first shared, said she joined the Peshmerga, the armed forces of the Kurdistan Region of Iraq. That is only part of the picture. Later accounts, including a 2018 interview with The New Arab, describe her mainly as a former sniper with the YPJ, the all-women Kurdish units that fought alongside the YPG in northern Syria. She also fought with Peshmerga units in Iraq after ISIS swept across the region in 2014.
By most accounts, she first joined Kurdish forces as a teenager, and in 2014 she left her university studies in Copenhagen to return to the front. She was reportedly wounded in the fighting around Kobani that year. Among the operations she described were raids to free Yazidi women and girls held as slaves by ISIS, a crime the United Nations and many governments have recognised as part of a genocide against the Yazidi people.

Asger Ladefoged
In a long interview with the British press in early 2017, she described life as a sniper in detail: stretches of up to nine days on the front line, early starts before dawn, and long hours lying still in a concealed position with a Russian-designed SVD rifle. She said her unit spent daylight hours defending positions and went on the offensive after dark.

Asger Ladefoged

Asger Ladefoged
Why Denmark prosecuted her
After returning home in 2015, Palani was served with a travel ban. Denmark, like several European countries, had passed laws making it a crime to travel to certain conflict zones in Syria and Iraq without permission. The laws were written mainly to stop people joining ISIS, but they apply regardless of which side a traveller intends to support.
Palani went back anyway. She has said she returned to Syria in 2016, for several months between June and October, because she could not abandon the women she had trained. When the authorities learned of the trip, she was arrested and held for about three weeks in Vestre Fængsel, Copenhagen's largest prison, then released. Her passport was taken away.

Asger Ladefoged
She was later convicted of breaching the ban and sentenced to nine months in jail, according to The New Arab. She has said she accepts the choice was hers to make, while arguing that she was punished more harshly than others who returned from the region. In her own words:
“I cannot deny the decision was completely made by myself.”

Asger Ladefoged

Asger Ladefoged
The bounty and the 100 kills: what can be confirmed
The headline figures that made her famous come from her own interviews and from press reports based on them. Reports in 2016 and 2017 said ISIS had offered $1 million for her, and she told journalists she had killed about 100 militants. No independent source has confirmed either number, and front-line kill counts are notoriously hard to verify. They are best read as her account rather than established fact.
What is well documented is that she has received many threats since returning to Denmark, both online and offline, and that she said she moved frequently to avoid being found. She told interviewers she feared being captured and enslaved by ISIS, but said her love of freedom outweighed that fear, and that many of the women freed in rescue raids went on to train as fighters themselves.

Asger Ladefoged

Sarah Buthmann
Hero or lawbreaker? The wider debate
Palani's case sits on an uncomfortable line. Many people in Europe saw Kurdish fighters, and especially women's units like the YPJ, as the front line against ISIS, and found it absurd that a volunteer on that side could be jailed. Her supporters argued that she risked her life against a group that also carried out attacks in Europe.
Governments see it differently. A travel ban is easier to enforce if it applies to everyone, and courts generally do not judge which armed group a citizen chose. Some Kurdish groups are also politically sensitive in Europe and Turkey, which complicates how volunteers are treated. Denmark was not unique: other Western volunteers who fought ISIS have faced investigations at home.
Palani has said she poses no threat to Denmark and has called on governments to show measurable results from their anti-radicalisation programmes. She summed up her sense of betrayal simply:
“I am seen as a terrorist by my own country.”

Asger Ladefoged
Her memoir and later life
Palani told her story at length in a memoir, Freedom Fighter: My War Against ISIS on the Frontlines of Syria. In it and in interviews she talks about the fighting, the women she served with, and what she calls a sexual revolution in the Middle East, in which women taking up arms challenged traditional roles. She has continued to speak publicly while living under threat.
Whatever one thinks of her decision to break the law, her story is a reminder of how many ordinary people, including students and refugees' children raised in Europe, were drawn into the war against ISIS, and how hard it has been for European legal systems to decide what to do with them when they came home.
The photographs here are credited to Asger Ladefoged, with one portrait credited to Sarah Buthmann, as published alongside the 2017 interviews.
Sources: The New Arab: From sniper to writer, Joanna Palani (12 December 2018); Wikipedia: Joanna Palani; original 2017 report via True Activist, based on her interview with the Daily Mail. Photos: Asger Ladefoged and Sarah Buthmann.
Related:- 30 Before & After Pics Of Aleppo Reveal What War Did To Syria’s Largest City
- Photographs of Syrian Heritage Sites Damaged by ISIS
- This Teen Is Re-Creating Sculptures That Were Destroyed By Daesh (ISIS)
- Meet The Activist Who Stayed In Syria To Feed Hundreds Of Abandoned Cats
- IKEA's Recreated Syrian Home in 2016
- Syrian Crisis: Five Years In 60 Seconds
- One Syrian boy's plea - Just Stop the War in Syria!
- Syrian Girl "Surrenders" In Front Of The Camera Mistaking It For A Gun!
- Save the Children’s 2014 Second-a-Day Syria Campaign
- Greek American World War II Refugee Leaves $600 Million Fortune to Charity
- 95-Year-Old Holocaust Survivor Funds Rescue Of 2,000 ISIS Victims
- Captured, sold, raped: ISIS turns thousands of Christian women and children into sex slaves - Demolishing Syria’s ancient Palmyra temple
- Christians, Turkmen, Shiites and Yazidis Are Facing Real Genocide By ISIS
- Triple terror: Up to 60 killed, 80 wounded, 3 car bombs explode in Syrian Christian town
- Her War: Women vs. ISIS (RT Documentary)
- Khaled al-Asaad, The Martyr Of Palmyra - Khaled al-Asaad Stood for the Future of Syria and the World Heritage
- ISIS thugs take a hammer to civilisation: Priceless 3,000-year-old artworks smashed to pieces in minutes as militants destroy Mosul museum
- One Year After Murder Of Journalist Who Had Revealed ISIS-Turkey-US Link, MSM, WH Silent [Video]
- Russian military reveals details of ISIS-Turkey oil smuggling - ISIS oil business involves Erdogan & his family
- Meet The Man Who Funds ISIS: Bilal Erdogan, The Son Of Turkey's President
- ‘They know how it’s done’: Turkey violated Greek airspace 2,244 times in 2014 alone
- ISIS survives largely because Turkey allows it to: the evidence
- Genocide Recognition and the Pursuit of Justice
- Banksy's Steve Jobs Mural at Calais in 2015
- Edward Norton's Fundraiser Inspired by a Syrian Scientist's Story
- Photographer Reveals The Heartbreaking Places Syrian Refugee Children Sleep
- Saudi Arabia Has Enough Tents With A/C To House 3 Million People, Yet Has Taken In ZERO Refugees
- Artists' Responses to Alan Kurdi's Death in 2015
- Greek Vacationers Rescue Syrian Refugee Stranded at Sea for 13 Hours Wearing Only a Life Vest
- Turkish couple drops wedding banquet to feed 4,000 Syrian refugees

That is one kickass women. A real life definition on a femme fatale. Respect.
ReplyDeleteI think that this is blasphemy.... I have the utmost respect to anyone who puts their life on the line for the freedom of others and for the country where she is born and resides to treat her as one of the terrorist she is fighting against really makes you ponder the fact of what we are fighting for and to read about something like this is disturbing to point where if I had the opportunity I would set down my freedom for the woman....she has more guts then some of the men i know and to degrade her for that is ridiculous!
ReplyDeleteSo,you publish her photo so everyone in the world can see it and help ISIS hunt her down. You should be ashamed of yourselves,treating a real life hero like that!
ReplyDeleteAlways stand your ground for you beliefs. When we allow others whose sole purpose is to hurt and kill to cause us to be frozen by fear, they win. ISIS should be hunted down and killed. Every last one of them. Anyone who provides shelter or help to ISIS militants should also be put to death. It is time to end this useless war.
ReplyDeleteDear Joanna Palani,
ReplyDeleteSome of us will give you friendship, our home, food, clothing, and safety (myself included).
Now I am living in the USA, but in 2018 or 2019 I will return to Germany. Keep in touch.