Saudi Arabia’s Empty Hajj Tents and the 2015 Refugee Claim

Saudi Arabia’s Empty Hajj Tents and the 2015 Refugee Debate

Photo: Akram Abahre

In late 2015, as hundreds of thousands of Syrians crossed into Europe, a viral story claimed that Saudi Arabia had 100,000 air-conditioned tents able to hold 3 million people standing empty, while accepting no refugees at all. The short answer: the tents are real, and so was the criticism of Gulf refugee policy, but the idea of turning the Hajj tent city of Mina into a refugee camp was more of a debating point than a practical plan.

Here is what Mina actually is, what the numbers showed at the time, and which parts of the viral version did not hold up.

The viral claim in brief

The story spread through InfoWars, in a piece by Paul Joseph Watson, and was republished by sites such as True Activist. Its argument was simple and emotive: Europe was being told it was not doing enough, while one of the richest countries in the Muslim world kept a vast, comfortable tent city idle for most of the year.

Fact-checkers at Snopes looked at the claim in November 2015. They found that the core numbers about Mina were broadly accurate, and that rights groups had indeed criticised the Gulf states for offering no formal resettlement places. What they questioned was the link between the two: a pilgrimage site is not automatically a solution to a refugee crisis.

Photo: Akram Abahre

Seen from the surrounding hills, the valley floor is almost entirely covered by identical white roofs, split into blocks by roads and footpaths. It is one of the most recognisable aerial views connected with the Hajj.

What Mina is and how the tents are used

Mina is a valley about 8 kilometres south-east of Mecca. It covers roughly 20 square kilometres and is often called the largest tent city in the world. More than 100,000 tents, each about 8 by 8 metres, stand in permanent rows, and together they can shelter up to around 3 million pilgrims.

Photo: Akram Abahre

Wide roads and raised walkways cut through the camp so that huge crowds can move between Mina, Arafat and Muzdalifah on a tight ritual timetable. In this view the main road is packed with pilgrims on foot.

The tents are tied to the Hajj calendar. Pilgrims arrive in Mina on the 8th day of the Islamic month of Dhu al-Hijjah, go on to Arafat and Muzdalifah, then return to Mina from the 10th to the 12th or 13th to perform the stoning of the Jamarat pillars. Outside those few days, most of the valley is quiet.

Photo: Akram Abahre

The cone-shaped roofs are the modern design. Each block of tents is organised as a camp, usually assigned to pilgrims from a particular country or tour operator.

The current tents exist because of a disaster. Earlier pilgrims used their own tents, and later cotton tents supplied by the government proved highly flammable. After the 1997 Mina fire killed more than 340 pilgrims, the authorities replaced them with fibreglass tents coated in Teflon for fire resistance, and fitted them with air conditioning.

Photo: Akram Abahre

At night the camp is lit by thousands of lamps, and the glow can be seen across the valley. Pilgrims sleep in Mina on several nights of the Hajj, so lighting and crowd control are central to safety.

What the numbers said about the Gulf and Syrian refugees

The criticism of the Gulf states had a real basis. Amnesty International reported in 2015 that Saudi Arabia, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, Kuwait and Bahrain had offered zero resettlement places to Syrian refugees. None of these states has signed the 1951 UN Refugee Convention, so Syrians living there are not classed as refugees at all.

Photo: Akram Abahre

Pilgrims in white ihram garments fill the lanes between the tents. During the Hajj, the density of people in Mina is one of the biggest challenges for the organisers.

Saudi officials answered that the kingdom had taken in large numbers of Syrians, with figures ranging from hundreds of thousands to a later claim of 2.5 million. Those people generally arrived as visitors, workers or relatives of residents, not under any refugee status, and the claims are hard to check independently. Saudi Arabia also pointed to around $280 million in aid for Syrian refugees in neighbouring countries.

Photo: Akram Abahre

Inside, a tent is a simple shared space: carpets, mattresses and personal bags, with dozens of pilgrims resting side by side between rituals.

The weight of the crisis fell mostly on Syria's neighbours. By 2015 Lebanon was hosting well over a million Syrians, roughly a quarter of its own population, while Jordan's own census counted about 1.4 million and Turkey hosted the largest number of all. Germany received around 158,000 asylum requests from Syrians in 2015 alone. Against that background, an empty tent city made a powerful image.

Why the tents were never a realistic refugee camp

Photo: Akram Abahre

Narrow paved lanes run between the fabric walls, lined with water coolers. The camp is designed for a short, highly organised stay, not for families living there through the year.

Several practical problems sit behind the striking photos:

Purpose. Mina is a religious site needed every year for one of the largest gatherings on Earth. Housing people there long term would collide with the pilgrimage itself.
Design. The tents provide shade, cooling and shared washrooms for a few nights. Year-round living needs schools, clinics, jobs, privacy and family space.
Climate. Summer temperatures around Mecca are extreme. The tents are air-conditioned, but running cooling for millions of residents all year would be a very different undertaking.
Policy. The real obstacle was legal, not physical. Without refugee status or easier visas, the question was never where people would sleep but whether they would be admitted.

Photo: Akram Abahre

The boxy units beside each tent are air coolers, the feature that made the viral story so memorable. They are what let pilgrims rest in Mina's intense heat.

Claims that need more care

Some lines in the original viral story went further than the evidence. A widely shared report said Saudi Arabia had offered to build 200 mosques in Germany for newly arrived migrants. That offer was never officially confirmed, so it is best treated as unverified. The story also blamed the war partly on Saudi Arabia arming jihadist groups; Saudi support for armed opposition groups in Syria was widely reported, but the war had many causes and many foreign backers.

The Muslim idea of the ummah, the worldwide community of believers, was used in the piece to argue that Gulf states had a special duty. That is a moral argument people can weigh for themselves, but it does not change the logistics of Mina.

What the debate still shows

Photo: Akram Abahre

Tents stretch to the edge of the city, with a mosque minaret rising above them. Mina is busy for only a few days a year, which is exactly why its empty rows caught the public imagination.

The Mina photos endure because they turn an abstract policy question into a picture anyone can understand. The fair reading is narrower than the viral headline: the Gulf states offered no formal refugee resettlement, which rights groups criticised strongly, but the tent city itself was never a ready-made answer. When a striking image is paired with a striking number, it is worth asking both whether the facts are right and whether they actually connect.

Sources: Snopes: Present tents (November 2015); Wikipedia: Mina, Saudi Arabia; Wikipedia: Hajj; Wikipedia: Syrian refugee crisis. Original viral story by Paul Joseph Watson, InfoWars, via True Activist. Photos credited to Akram Abahre.

Related: