Is Depression Linked to the Gut? What the Research Suggests

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Is Depression Linked to the Gut? What the Research Suggests

Is depression caused by your gut rather than your brain? The honest short answer is no, not in any simple sense. But scientists have found real two-way links between the digestive system, the bacteria living in it, inflammation and mood, and that research is one of the most interesting areas of mental health science today.

Depression has many causes that interact: genes, life events, stress, physical illness, sleep, substance use and more. The gut appears to be one more piece of that puzzle, not a hidden master switch. Below is what the gut–brain connection is, what studies in people have actually found, which popular diet claims hold up, and what sensible steps you can take. One point first: if you think you may be depressed, talk to a doctor. Food can support recovery, but it is not a substitute for care.

How the gut and the brain talk to each other

Your digestive tract has its own network of nerve cells, the enteric nervous system, sometimes nicknamed the “second brain”. It can run the basic work of digestion on its own and uses more than 30 different chemical messengers. It is also wired to the brain, most importantly through the vagus nerve, a long nerve that carries signals in both directions. That connection is one reason stress can upset your stomach, and why people talk about butterflies before a big moment.

Trillions of microbes in the gut, known together as the microbiota, take part in this conversation. They help digest fibre and produce substances such as short-chain fatty acids that influence inflammation and the gut lining. Some bacteria can stimulate the vagus nerve directly. Scientists call the whole system the gut–brain axis.

You may have read that “90 percent of serotonin is made in the gut.” That figure is broadly right, but it is often misunderstood. Serotonin made in the gut mostly controls gut movement and does not cross into the brain, which makes its own supply. The gut can still influence the brain’s chemistry indirectly, but it is not simply shipping happiness upstairs.

What the research has found so far

Much of the early evidence comes from animals. A classic 2004 study by Japanese researchers Nobuyuki Sudo and colleagues found that mice raised completely free of germs had an exaggerated hormonal response to stress, which partly normalised when certain bacteria were introduced. Many later mouse studies found that gut bacteria can affect anxiety-like and depression-like behaviour.

Studies in people are more cautious. Several have found that people with depression tend to have somewhat different gut bacteria from people without it. But as reviews of the field point out, these findings are mostly correlations. It remains unclear whether changes in gut bacteria help cause depression, result from it (depression changes appetite, diet, sleep and activity), or both. Gut bacteria also vary enormously from person to person, which makes consistent results hard to get.

Inflammation is the other strong thread. In 2015 researchers from Ohio State University and Rice University, including Janice Kiecolt-Glaser and Christopher Fagundes, reviewed around 200 studies for the American Journal of Psychiatry. They reported that people with depression often have raised blood markers of inflammation, such as CRP and IL-6, and that inflammation and depression appear to feed each other. Chronic inflammation is more common after long-term stress or childhood adversity and is linked to obesity and poor diet. That does not make depression “just inflammation”, but it does suggest that, for some people, physical health and mood are tightly linked.

Popular diet claims, checked

Articles about the gut and depression often come with confident nutrition rules. Here is how the common ones hold up.

“Processed food raises your risk of depression by 60 percent”

This number appears to come from a 2009 study of British civil servants in the long-running Whitehall II project, in which people whose diets were highest in processed food had noticeably higher odds of depression symptoms five years later than those eating mostly whole foods. It is a real finding, but it shows an association, not proof that processed food causes depression. People who eat well also tend to differ in income, stress, exercise and sleep. It does not mean your personal risk jumps by 60 percent.

“Supplements are useless; get everything from food”

Food is the best starting point for most nutrients, and fibre in particular feeds gut bacteria in ways a pill cannot copy. But supplements are sometimes medically needed, for example for diagnosed deficiencies, in pregnancy, or for people on restricted diets. Do not stop a prescribed supplement without asking your doctor.

“Vitamin D is the happy vitamin”

Low vitamin D levels are linked with depression in observational studies. Trials, however, have been disappointing. According to the US National Institutes of Health, the large VITAL trial gave more than 18,000 adults aged 50 and over either vitamin D or a placebo for about five years and found no difference in rates of depression or in mood scores. Sunlight on the skin does produce vitamin D, but it varies with season, latitude, age and skin tone, and it does not pass through window glass. Fortified milk, some fortified juices and oily fish are dietary sources.

“Cut out sugar, dairy and gluten”

Cutting back on added sugar is good general advice. Dairy and gluten are a different matter. People with coeliac disease must avoid gluten, and people with lactose intolerance feel better limiting dairy, but there is no good evidence that everyone should drop these foods to protect their mood. Removing whole food groups without reason can make a diet less varied, which is the opposite of what gut bacteria seem to like.

Can changing your diet treat depression?

The most-cited human trial is SMILES, a small Australian study published in 2017. Adults with moderate to severe depression who received coaching toward a Mediterranean-style diet improved more over 12 weeks than a comparison group who received social support. The study was small and participants knew which group they were in, so it is a promising signal rather than a final answer, and diet was added to existing treatment, not used instead of it.

Probiotic and “psychobiotic” supplements are being studied too, but results in people have so far been small and inconsistent, and it is hard to get added bacteria to settle in the gut for long. It is too early to recommend any particular strain for mood.

Sensible steps for your gut and your mood

None of the following will cure depression, but all of them are good for your body and none carry real risk:

  • Eat more plants and fibre: vegetables, fruit, beans, lentils, whole grains, nuts and seeds feed a more varied gut microbiota.
  • Include fermented foods if you enjoy them: yoghurt with live cultures, kefir, sauerkraut or kimchi.
  • Choose oily fish and healthy fats: olive oil and fish such as salmon or sardines are staples of Mediterranean-style eating.
  • Limit ultra-processed snacks and sugary drinks rather than banning them, which is easier to sustain.
  • Move, sleep and get daylight: exercise is a recommended treatment for mild depression in the UK, and sleep and routine support mood and digestion alike.

When to talk to a doctor

If low mood, loss of interest, exhaustion or hopelessness last for more than a couple of weeks, or make it hard to cope with daily life, talk to a doctor. Depression is common and treatable. The UK’s NHS describes a range of proven options, from guided self-help and exercise for milder depression to talking therapies such as cognitive behavioural therapy, and antidepressants for moderate to severe depression, often combined. Never stop prescribed medication suddenly without medical advice.

If you are having thoughts of harming yourself, seek help now. In the US you can call or text 988; elsewhere, contact your local emergency number or a crisis line.

The gut–brain axis is a genuine and exciting field, and the next decade may bring better treatments from it. For now, the best way to use what scientists have learned is simple: look after your gut as part of looking after yourself, and get proper help for your mind at the same time.

Sources: Wikipedia: Gut–brain axis; Rice University: Inflammation can fan the flames of depression; NIH Office of Dietary Supplements: Vitamin D; NHS: Treatment for depression; NIMH: Depression. First shared on this site via Learning Mind.

Related:

COMMENTS