Kepler-186f: The First Earth-Size Planet in a Habitable Zone

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Kepler-186f: The First Earth-Size Planet in a Star’s Habitable Zone

Kepler-186f is a planet about the size of Earth that circles a small red star in the constellation Cygnus, roughly 500 light-years away. When NASA announced it on 17 April 2014, it became the first Earth-size planet confirmed in the habitable zone of another star: the band of orbits where a rocky world could, in principle, keep liquid water on its surface. That makes it a real milestone, but it does not mean scientists found a second Earth. Nobody yet knows whether it has air, oceans or life.

Below is what the discovery actually showed, how astronomers found it, what "habitable zone" really means, and which popular claims about the planet go further than the evidence.

Kepler-186f at a glance

The planet was found with NASA's Kepler Space Telescope and described in a paper in the journal Science led by Elisa Quintana of the SETI Institute at NASA's Ames Research Center. The key numbers:

  • Size: a little larger than Earth. The discovery paper gave a radius of about 1.17 Earth radii.
  • Orbit: one trip around its star takes about 130 days, at a distance of roughly 0.4 astronomical units (one astronomical unit is the Earth–Sun distance).
  • Starlight: it receives about a third of the energy Earth gets from the Sun, which places it toward the cool, outer edge of its star's habitable zone.
  • Star: Kepler-186 is an M-type red dwarf with about half the Sun's mass and width, a surface temperature of about 3,750 kelvin (the Sun's is near 5,800) and an estimated age of around four billion years.
  • Neighbours: it is the outermost of five known planets in the system. The four inner ones, Kepler-186b to e, orbit much closer in and are far too hot for liquid water.
  • Mass: unknown. Estimates span from about a third of Earth's mass to almost four times it, depending on what the planet is made of.

The distance is usually quoted as about 500 light-years, the figure NASA used in 2014. More recent measurements of the star place it somewhat farther, closer to 580 light-years. Either way, the light we see from it left before the Renaissance.

Kepler-186f: The First Earth-Size Planet in a Star’s Habitable Zone

The pictures that accompany news about Kepler-186f, including the ones on this page, are artists' impressions. No telescope has photographed the planet's surface; it is far too small and distant.

How a planet nobody can see was found

Kepler, launched in 2009, stared at the same patch of sky in Cygnus and Lyra for years, measuring the brightness of more than 150,000 stars. When a planet passes in front of its star as seen from Earth, the star dims very slightly for a few hours. This is called a transit. If the dip repeats at regular intervals, astronomers can work out the planet's orbital period from the spacing and its size from how much light it blocks.

That method explains both the strength and the limits of the result. The transits gave a good measure of Kepler-186f's diameter and its 130-day year, which took about three years of data to pin down. What transits cannot reveal on their own is mass. Measuring mass usually requires detecting the tiny wobble a planet causes in its star, and the star is too faint for that to have been done well. Without mass, there is no density, and without density, no certainty that the planet is rocky rather than a world with a thick envelope of gas or a deep layer of ice.

Earlier research suggested that planets of this size are usually rocky, so the team considered a rocky composition likely. That is a reasonable inference, not a measurement.

What "habitable zone" means, and what it does not

The habitable zone, sometimes called the Goldilocks zone, is a range of distances from a star. Inside it, a planet with a suitable atmosphere could be warm enough for liquid water but not so warm that the water boils away. It is a property of the star's brightness, so every star has its own. It is not a region of the galaxy, a point that was often garbled in early coverage of this discovery.

Because Kepler-186 is dimmer and cooler than the Sun, its habitable zone sits much closer in. Kepler-186f orbits at about the same distance as Mercury does from the Sun, yet it receives less light than Mars does, because its star is so much fainter.

Being in the zone is only a starting condition. Whether liquid water exists depends heavily on the atmosphere. Without any greenhouse warming, the planet's calculated temperature would be around minus 85 °C. A thicker atmosphere rich in carbon dioxide could raise that above freezing; no atmosphere at all would leave it a frozen rock. Thomas Barclay, a co-author of the study, put the result in proportion with a memorable phrase:

"Kepler-186f can be thought of as an Earth-cousin rather than an Earth-twin."

Quintana described the significance more broadly: "Finding a habitable zone planet comparable to Earth in size is a major step forward." Before Kepler-186f, the habitable-zone planets found by Kepler were all at least 40 percent larger than Earth, which made them harder to compare with our own world.

Life around a red dwarf: the open questions

Red dwarfs are the most common type of star in the Milky Way, so whether their planets can be habitable is one of the biggest questions in the search for life. Kepler-186f is a useful test case, and it highlights several concerns scientists discuss:

  • Tidal locking. Planets close to their stars can end up with one side always facing the star, like the Moon facing Earth. Because Kepler-186f orbits relatively far out for a red-dwarf planet, it may have escaped this; estimates put the chances at roughly even. If it does rotate, its day could last weeks or months.
  • Stellar flares. Young red dwarfs can be very active, releasing flares that may strip atmospheres from nearby planets. Kepler-186 is thought to be several billion years old and therefore calmer, but its past activity is unknown.
  • Different light. A red dwarf emits much of its energy in red and infrared light. Any plants on such a world would need to photosynthesise under a dimmer, redder sky, which has led to speculation that they might look darker than Earth's greenery.

Later studies have added nuance. A 2018 analysis of the planet's possible axial tilt suggested its seasons could be stable, a factor that matters for climate. Other statistical work has looked again at whether the signal is truly a planet; most analyses still favour a planet, though they cannot rule out a small chance of a false positive.

Is anyone out there? What has been checked

Soon after the discovery, the SETI Institute pointed the Allen Telescope Array in California at the Kepler-186 system and listened for radio signals for about a month. Nothing that looked like technology was detected. That silence says little: the search covered a narrow range of frequencies and only a short time, and a civilisation 500 light-years away would need a powerful transmitter aimed our way for us to notice.

A visit is out of the question with current technology. Even Voyager 1, one of the fastest objects humans have sent beyond the planets, would take around nine to ten million years to cover that distance.

The next steps in this field rely on nearer, brighter targets. NASA's TESS satellite, launched in 2018, searches the closest and brightest stars for transiting planets, and the James Webb Space Telescope can analyse the starlight filtering through some of those planets' atmospheres. Kepler-186f itself is considered too far and too faint for that kind of detailed study, so it is likely to remain a planet we know mainly by its size and orbit.

Common myths about Kepler-186f

"Scientists discovered another Earth." They discovered a planet of similar size in a temperate orbit. Its mass, composition, atmosphere and surface conditions are unknown.

"A habitable-zone planet is a habitable planet." The zone only describes where liquid water is possible with the right atmosphere. Venus and Mars both sit near the edges of the Sun's habitable zone, and neither has surface water today.

"It orbits a star like the Sun." Kepler-186 is a red dwarf, cooler and smaller than the Sun. Kepler-186f gets only about a third of the energy Earth receives.

"Having four sibling planets raises the odds of life." The four inner planets show that planetary systems around red dwarfs can be crowded and compact. They are too hot for liquid water and do not change the odds for Kepler-186f either way.

Taken together, Kepler-186f is best understood as a proof of concept: Earth-size planets exist in temperate orbits around other stars, and they are probably common. Whether any of them is truly like home is a question the next generation of telescopes will start to answer with closer worlds.

Do you think life is likely on planets around red dwarfs? Share your view in the comments.

Sources: NASA: Kepler discovers first Earth-size planet in the habitable zone of another star (April 2014); Kepler-186f (Wikipedia, incl. Quintana et al., Science, 2014, and the Allen Telescope Array search). Earlier coverage by Gregg Prescott, In5D, via The Mind Unleashed. Images: artist's impressions of Kepler-186f.

Related:

COMMENTS