Did J.P. Morgan bury Nikola Tesla’s “free energy” so the world would keep paying for electricity? That is the claim made by a popular online documentary about Tesla, but the historical record tells a different story. Morgan did invest $150,000 in Tesla’s Wardenclyffe wireless station in 1901 and later refused to put in more. The project ran out of money, was never finished, and its tower was demolished for scrap in 1917 to pay Tesla’s debts. No device that produces endless free energy has ever been demonstrated, by Tesla or anyone else.
Tesla’s real achievements are remarkable enough without the myth. Here is what the films claim, what actually happened, and why the legend of suppressed free energy has proved so durable.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
Who Nikola Tesla really was
Tesla (1856–1943) was a Serbian-American engineer born in what is now Croatia. His most important contribution was the alternating-current induction motor and the polyphase AC system that went with it. Licensed to George Westinghouse in the late 1880s, those patents helped make it practical to generate electricity at large power stations and send it over long distances, which is how most of the world’s electricity still reaches homes today.
He also built the Tesla coil, worked on radio, remote control and lighting, and gave spectacular public demonstrations. Far from being unknown, he is one of the most widely celebrated inventors in history; the SI unit of magnetic flux density, the tesla, is named after him. What is true is that he died poor, in a New York hotel room on 7 January 1943, and that his reputation faded for decades before a revival late in the twentieth century.
Wardenclyffe and the Morgan money
In March 1901 J.P. Morgan agreed to pay Tesla $150,000 to build a wireless station, in return for a controlling share in the venture and its patents. Tesla built a laboratory and a 186-foot tower at Shoreham on Long Island. His main goal was transatlantic wireless communication: messages, telephone calls and even images sent to Europe and to ships at sea. He also hoped, eventually, to transmit power through the earth.
The project soon outgrew its budget. Tesla expanded his plans after Guglielmo Marconi’s rapid progress in radio, and Marconi sent a signal across the Atlantic in December 1901 using far cheaper equipment. Morgan declined to add more money, other investors held back, and a stock market slump in 1903 made fundraising harder. Work stopped by 1906. Tesla’s debts to the hotel owner George Boldt led to foreclosure, and the tower was dynamited and sold for scrap in 1917, raising $1,750.
So Morgan did withdraw his support, but the record points to business reasons: a ballooning budget, a competitor with a cheaper system, and an unproven technology. There is no evidence that a working free-energy machine existed to be destroyed.
The film with Orson Welles
The “rare film” often shared alongside these claims is The Secret of Nikola Tesla, a 1980 Yugoslav drama directed by Krsto Papić. Petar Božović plays Tesla, Orson Welles plays J.P. Morgan, Strother Martin plays George Westinghouse and Dennis Patrick plays Thomas Edison. It is a somewhat fictionalised biopic: scenes such as meetings between Tesla, Morgan and Edison are dramatisations, not documentary records.
The other film discussed here, The Missing Secrets of Nikola Tesla, and the longer “Unlimited Free Energy Forever” documentary go further. They feature inventors who claim machines that produce more energy than they use, along with anti-gravity and the transmutation of metals, and they present mainstream scepticism as suppression.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
Why “free energy” machines do not work
A machine that puts out more energy than goes into it would break the law of conservation of energy, one of the most thoroughly tested principles in physics. Such devices are known as perpetual motion machines, and patent offices around the world have long rejected them unless an inventor can produce a working model. None has ever passed independent testing.
Tesla’s actual idea was different. He wanted to transmit electricity without wires, drawing on power stations, and to use the earth and upper atmosphere as conductors. Wireless power transfer is real, as anyone with a wireless phone charger knows, but it works over short distances and loses energy quickly. Tesla’s grander plan to light cities through the earth was never scientifically tested, and electricity sent this way would still have to be generated, and paid for, somewhere.
Quotes in Tesla’s name: which are real
Tesla quotes spread widely online, and many cannot be traced to him. Some of the most shared ones are worth checking.
- Genuine: In an 1892 lecture published as Experiments with Alternate Currents of High Potential and High Frequency, Tesla wrote: “Ere many generations pass, our machinery will be driven by a power obtainable at any point of the universe.” It expresses hope for new energy sources, not a finished invention.
- Genuine: In a 1926 interview with Collier’s magazine, Tesla predicted that perfected wireless would turn the earth into a kind of huge brain and let people talk instantly across any distance. Many people see it as an early glimpse of mobile phones and the internet.
- Unconfirmed: The lines “My brain is only a receiver” and the advice to think “in terms of energy, frequency and vibration” come from the recollection of Ralph Bergstresser, who said Tesla spoke them in conversation. No written source by Tesla is known.
- Untraced: The claim that electric power is present everywhere in unlimited quantities and can replace all fuels has not been found in Tesla’s writings and appears to be a paraphrase.
- Not Tesla: A popular passage about alpha brain waves and the earth resonating at 6 to 8 hertz cannot be his. Hans Berger first published on alpha waves in 1929, they run at roughly 8 to 12 Hz, and the earth’s Schumann resonance (about 7.83 Hz) was predicted only in 1952, nine years after Tesla died.
The image above uses one of these unconfirmed lines. It is often attributed to Tesla, but there is no published source for it.
Why the suppression myth persists
The legend fits a satisfying story: a lonely genius with grand ideas, a powerful banker, a lost invention. Tesla made it easier to believe by announcing ambitious projects to the press that he never completed. His papers being taken into government custody after his death in wartime added to the mystery.
There is also a real grievance underneath. Tesla was treated poorly by investors, lost money on patents, and died poor while others profited from technology he helped create. Seeing him clearly means celebrating what he built, admitting what he did not, and judging modern free-energy promises by the same test any other invention must pass: a working machine that independent experts can measure.
Today the Wardenclyffe site is being restored as the Tesla Science Center, after a 2012 crowdfunding campaign led by the webcomic The Oatmeal helped buy the land.
Sources: Wikipedia: Wardenclyffe Tower; Wikipedia: The Secret of Nikola Tesla; Wikiquote: Nikola Tesla; Wikipedia: Nikola Tesla; Wikipedia: Alpha wave; Wikipedia: Schumann resonances; The Clio: Wardenclyffe Tower.
Related:
This made me cry. Love is where the heart and home are. Love is priceless.
ReplyDelete