Why Greece Wrote to the UN Over Turkey's Aegean Island Claims

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-06-10.

Greece's 2022 UN Correspondence on Aegean Island Sovereignty

In June 2022 Greece sent two letters to the United Nations Secretary-General rejecting a Turkish argument that Greek sovereignty over the islands of the eastern Aegean depends on keeping them demilitarised. Athens called the Turkish position legally unfounded and revisionist. The letters came as senior Turkish officials stepped up their rhetoric, with the foreign minister warning that the islands' sovereignty could be "questioned". This article explains what each side said, what the treaties actually provide, and how the dispute developed afterwards.

What happened in June 2022

Several things came together in the first week of June 2022. The Greek newspaper To Vima reported that Ankara was now arguing that Aegean islands not named individually in international treaties belong to Turkey as the successor of the Ottoman Empire. At a defence ministry briefing in Izmir, Turkish officials listed more than a dozen small Greek islands and islets, among them Agathonisi, Farmakonisi, Pserimos and Oinousses, and claimed Greece had committed 953 violations of Turkish airspace and waters that year. To Vima also reported that Turkish Defence Minister Hulusi Akar wanted to bar Greece's deputy defence minister, Nikos Hardalias, from visiting the eastern Aegean islands without Ankara's permission.

At about the same time, Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu, speaking after talks with North Macedonia's foreign minister Bujar Osmani, said the sovereignty of the islands would "come into question" if Greece did not stop what he called violations of international treaties. He was referring to Ankara's long-standing demand that Greece remove its military forces from the islands, a demand President Erdoğan had also been repeating in public.

What Greece told the UN

Greece's permanent representative to the United Nations responded with two letters to Secretary-General António Guterres. According to Greek government sources quoted by Greek City Times, the letters rejected the Turkish arguments as legally unsustainable, described them as revisionist, and warned that such claims only feed instability in the region.

Letters of this kind are a standard diplomatic tool. They do not ask the UN to rule on anything; they place a country's position formally on the record, so that silence cannot later be read as acceptance.

What the treaties actually say

The argument turns on three agreements from the twentieth century.

The Treaty of Lausanne (1923)

Signed on 24 July 1923 between Turkey and the Allied powers including Greece, Lausanne confirmed Greek sovereignty over the Aegean islands beyond three miles of the Turkish coast, with the exception of Imbros (Gökçeada), Tenedos (Bozcaada) and the small Rabbit Islands, which went to Turkey. A separate article placed limits on military installations on Lesbos, Chios, Samos and Ikaria: no naval bases or fortifications, while allowing normal military service and police forces.

The Montreux Convention (1936)

Lemnos and Samothrace, near the entrance to the Dardanelles, were demilitarised under the Lausanne convention on the Turkish Straits. That convention was replaced in 1936 by the Montreux Convention, which restored Turkey's right to fortify the Straits. Greece's position is that Montreux also ended the restrictions on Lemnos and Samothrace.

The Paris Peace Treaty (1947)

The Dodecanese, including Rhodes and Kos, were Italian until the Second World War. Italy ceded them to Greece under the 1947 Paris Peace Treaty, which required them to remain demilitarised. Turkey was not a party to that treaty, and Greece argues that Turkey therefore has no standing to invoke it.

The two positions, side by side

Turkey's argument is that the demilitarisation clauses were a condition of handing the islands to Greece, so that arming them breaks the bargain and reopens the question of sovereignty. It also points to small islets it considers "grey zones" whose ownership it says was never settled.

Greece's argument is that sovereignty was transferred outright and is not conditional on anything. No treaty contains a clause that returns an island if its terms are breached. Greece also invokes the right of self-defence recognised in Article 51 of the UN Charter, pointing out that Turkey created its Fourth Army, the "Army of the Aegean", in 1975 and keeps a large landing fleet on the coast facing the islands. A neighbour that keeps amphibious forces aimed at your territory, Athens argues, cannot demand that you leave it undefended.

Greece's major allies, including the United States, the European Union and the United Kingdom, rejected the idea that Greek sovereignty over Lesbos, Chios or Rhodes could be called into question when Turkey first linked the two issues in late 2021.

A long-running dispute

The islands question is one part of a wider set of Aegean disagreements that have shaped Greek–Turkish relations since the 1970s. The others include the width of territorial waters (Greece reserves the right to extend them from six to twelve nautical miles under the UN Law of the Sea convention, which Turkey has not signed), the continental shelf and exclusive economic zones, the ten-mile Greek airspace and responsibility for air-traffic control. Crises in 1987 and over the Imia islets in 1996 brought the two countries close to armed conflict.

The rhetoric escalated further after June 2022. In July Turkish officials displayed a map presenting the eastern Aegean islands and Crete as Turkish, prompting objections from the United States and Germany. In September and December President Erdoğan issued threats directed at Greece, which Athens answered by citing its right to self-defence and its mutual-assistance agreement with France.

Where things stand

Tensions eased somewhat after the devastating February 2023 earthquakes in Turkey, when Greece quickly sent rescue teams to help, and in December 2023 the two governments signed a declaration on friendly relations. But none of the underlying legal disagreements has been resolved. For readers following the issue, the key point from June 2022 remains simple: Greek sovereignty over the eastern Aegean islands rests on treaties that transferred them unconditionally, and Greece has formally placed that position on record at the United Nations.

Sources: To Vima: Ankara says Greek officials need permission to visit eastern Aegean islands (June 2022); Greek City Times: Turkey wants Greek officials to ask for permission to visit Greek islands (June 2022); Wikipedia: Aegean dispute; Wikipedia: Treaty of Lausanne; Wikipedia: Dodecanese.

COMMENTS