Originally published 2022-06-09.

On 9 June 2022, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan publicly called on Greece to remove its military forces from islands in the eastern Aegean Sea, arguing that treaties signed in the last century require them to stay unarmed. Greece rejected the demand, saying the islands are Greek territory and that it has every right to defend them, especially given the large Turkish forces stationed across the water.
The exchange was not a one-off outburst. It was the latest round in a decades-old dispute over who may do what in the Aegean, and it came at a tense moment for the region: Russia had invaded Ukraine months earlier, Turkey was threatening a new military operation in northern Syria, and its economy was in serious trouble. Here is what was said, what the treaties actually contain, and why the argument matters.
What Erdoğan said near Izmir
Erdoğan spoke while watching the annual EFES-2022 military exercise near Izmir, on Turkey's Aegean coast. He urged Athens to stop arming islands that Turkey regards as having non-military status and to respect international agreements. He also told Greece to "avoid dreams, acts and statements that will result in regret", and insisted that Turkey would not give up what it calls its rights in the Aegean. To underline the point, he added: "I'm not joking, I'm speaking seriously."
His foreign minister at the time, Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu, went further in the same period, suggesting that Turkey could question Greek sovereignty over the islands if Greece kept them armed. That linkage is what alarmed Athens most. Greece's foreign ministry responded by publishing a set of 16 maps that, it said, documented Turkey's unilateral and illegal actions, including repeated violations of Greek airspace.
What the treaties actually say
Turkey's case rests mainly on two treaties:
- The Treaty of Lausanne (1923), which set the borders of modern Turkey after the Greco-Turkish War. It confirmed Greek sovereignty over the large eastern Aegean islands, including Lesbos, Chios, Samos and Ikaria, while limiting the military installations Greece could place there. A separate convention signed at Lausanne demilitarised Lemnos and Samothrace, near the Dardanelles.
- The Treaty of Paris (1947), under which Italy, defeated in the Second World War, ceded the Dodecanese islands, including Rhodes and Kos, to Greece on condition that they remain demilitarised. Turkey was not a signatory to this treaty.
Greece answers on several grounds. It argues that the 1936 Montreux Convention, which Turkey itself sought and which let Turkey re-militarise the Straits, replaced the earlier Lausanne rules for Lemnos and Samothrace. It points out that Turkey cannot claim rights under the 1947 treaty because it never signed it. Above all, Greece invokes the right of self-defence in Article 51 of the United Nations Charter, which it says overrides any older restriction when a neighbour poses a direct threat.
Why Greece says it must defend the islands
Greek governments of every political colour have pointed to the same facts. In 1974 Turkey invaded Cyprus and has occupied its northern third ever since, a reality that shaped Greek threat perceptions for a generation. In 1975 Turkey created its Fourth Army, often called the Army of the Aegean, based along the coast facing the Greek islands, with landing craft and amphibious units that Greece sees as aimed directly at them.
In 1995 the Turkish parliament also declared that it would treat any Greek extension of territorial waters in the Aegean to 12 nautical miles, a limit allowed under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, as a cause for war. Greece regards that resolution as a standing threat. Seen from Athens, an island like Lesbos or Kos lies only a few kilometres from a large foreign army, and leaving it undefended would be reckless.
Greek government spokesman Giannis Oikonomou summed up the response in June 2022 by saying Greece "has upgraded its geostrategic and geopolitical footprint as well as its deterrent capacity."
The deeper quarrel over seas and airspace
The demilitarisation row sits inside a wider set of disagreements. Turkey argues that islands lying close to its coast should not receive a full Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) or continental shelf, which would give Greece rights over large stretches of sea and any gas found beneath it. Greece relies on the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, which grants islands maritime zones; Turkey has not signed that convention.
The two countries also disagree about the width of Greek airspace, flight information rules and search-and-rescue areas. In 2019 Turkey signed a maritime boundary memorandum with Libya's then government that ignored the island of Crete, and in 2020 a Turkish survey ship's mission in disputed waters led to a tense naval stand-off. Each episode feeds suspicion on both sides.
Critics in Greece and elsewhere linked the 2022 rhetoric to Turkish domestic politics. Erdoğan's governing coalition relied on the far-right Nationalist Movement Party (MHP), and nationalist themes such as the "Blue Homeland" doctrine of expansive maritime claims had grown more prominent.
Syria, human rights and the domestic backdrop
At the same time as the Aegean warnings, Erdoğan was promising a fresh cross-border operation in northern Syria against the Kurdish-led forces that control much of the region. He told audiences that Turkey would "never allow the establishment of terror corridors" along its borders. Turkey considers the main Kurdish militia there, the YPG, an extension of the PKK, which Turkey, the EU and the US list as a terrorist group, although the US had relied on the YPG-led Syrian Democratic Forces to fight ISIS.
Earlier Turkish offensives, such as the 2018 operation in Afrin and the 2019 operation east of the Euphrates, displaced large numbers of civilians. Amnesty International and other human rights groups documented killings, looting and property seizures by Turkish-backed Syrian armed groups and accused Turkish forces of serious violations. Many governments criticised the operations as contrary to international law.
At home, Turkey's democratic record had drawn sustained criticism. After the failed coup attempt of 2016, tens of thousands of people were detained, many media outlets were shut, and Turkey ranked among the world's leading jailers of journalists in press-freedom surveys. A 2020 law tightened state control over social media platforms. The economy added to the pressure: official annual inflation passed 70 percent in May 2022 and the lira lost much of its value, and polls showed support for Erdoğan falling.
What happened next
Tension stayed high through the rest of 2022, with frequent airspace incidents and sharp statements from both capitals. Relations then shifted sharply after the devastating earthquakes in southern Turkey in February 2023, when Greece sent rescue teams and aid. Later that year the two governments agreed to a more positive agenda of dialogue, and in December 2023 Erdoğan visited Athens and signed a declaration on friendly relations. The underlying legal disputes over the islands, seas and airspace, however, remain unresolved.
For readers trying to make sense of the 2022 headlines, the key point is simple: Greek sovereignty over the eastern Aegean islands is established by treaty and recognised internationally. The argument was about military status, but Turkish officials tying that argument to sovereignty is what turned a legal disagreement into a serious diplomatic crisis.
Sources: Associated Press, 9 June 2022: Turkey's Erdogan warns Greece to demilitarize Aegean islands; Al Jazeera, 9 June 2022; Cyprus Mail (Reuters), 9 June 2022: Turkey’s Erdogan tells Greece not to arm demilitarised islands; Wikipedia: Treaty of Lausanne; Wikipedia: Paris Peace Treaties, 1947; Wikipedia: Aegean dispute; Wikipedia: Aegean Army; Amnesty International. See also our earlier reports on Erdoğan's "contemporary Byzantines" remarks and Turkey's 2020 social media law.

COMMENTS