Originally published 2022-03-13.
On 13 March 2022, in the third week of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Russian negotiator Leonid Slutsky told reporters, as quoted by Sky News, that talks with Ukraine had made "substantial progress" and that, in his personal view, the two delegations might soon reach a joint position and documents ready for signing. A Ukrainian negotiator, presidential adviser Mykhailo Podolyak, also predicted results within days.
No peace agreement followed. The talks produced a draft framework in Istanbul at the end of March, then stalled in April after the killings of civilians in Bucha came to light. This article explains who said what, what each side was demanding, and why the optimism of mid-March did not turn into a treaty.
What the negotiators said on 13 March
Slutsky was speaking as a member of Russia's official delegation. At the time he chaired the State Duma's international affairs committee, and in May 2022 he became leader of the nationalist Liberal Democratic Party of Russia. He had been under US, EU and Canadian sanctions since 2014 over the annexation of Crimea.
His comment was carefully hedged. He framed it as his own expectation, not an agreement already reached, saying the progress could grow "into documents for signing" within days.
Podolyak, speaking for Kyiv, sounded upbeat too, but stressed that Ukraine would not give ground on its core positions. He suggested Russia had started talking constructively and that a meeting of leaders could follow once a text was worked out. Shortly afterwards he became Ukraine's chief negotiator.
Statements like these are part of wartime diplomacy. They can signal real movement, prepare domestic audiences for compromise, or simply buy time. Treating them as a promise of peace was always risky.
How the 2022 talks unfolded
- 28 February: first round of talks on the Belarus border, four days after the invasion began. No agreement.
- 3 March: second round in Belarus. Both sides agreed in principle on humanitarian corridors for civilians.
- 7 March: third round. The Kremlin said it would halt operations if Ukraine accepted its conditions, including constitutional neutrality.
- 10 March: the foreign ministers, Sergei Lavrov and Dmytro Kuleba, met in Antalya, Turkey, without agreeing even a 24-hour ceasefire.
- 14–16 March: talks continued by video link, and a 15-point plan was discussed.
- 29 March: face-to-face talks in Istanbul produced the "Istanbul Communiqué", a framework for a possible treaty.
What Russia demanded and what Ukraine refused
Russia's public conditions in early March were sweeping. It wanted Ukraine to:
- recognise Crimea, annexed by Russia in 2014, as Russian territory;
- recognise the self-declared "republics" of Donetsk and Luhansk, together known as the Donbas, as independent;
- write neutrality into its constitution and give up plans to join NATO;
- accept "demilitarisation" and "denazification", terms Moscow used to justify the invasion and which Kyiv and Western governments rejected as false pretexts.
President Volodymyr Zelensky had said repeatedly that Ukraine would not surrender territory or accept ultimatums. He was, however, open to discussing neutrality if Ukraine received binding security guarantees from other countries.
Some early reports also listed a pledge never to join the European Union among Russia's demands. The framework later discussed in Istanbul, however, centred on NATO and military alliances rather than the EU.
The Istanbul framework of 29 March
The Istanbul round came closest to a deal. Under the draft framework, Ukraine would become permanently neutral and drop its NATO bid. In return it would receive security guarantees from a group of states. The status of Crimea would be set aside for 15 years of consultations.
Major gaps remained. Russia wanted a say over whether guarantor countries could intervene, and the two sides were far apart on the size of Ukraine's future army: reports put Russia's figure at about 85,000 troops against Ukraine's proposal of 250,000. Moscow also pushed for changes to Ukrainian laws on language and history.
Why no deal was signed
At the end of March Russian forces withdrew from the area around Kyiv. When Ukrainian troops entered the town of Bucha on 1 April, they found streets and yards with the bodies of civilians. Local authorities later recovered 458 bodies, and the UN human rights office documented unlawful killings, including summary executions, of at least 73 civilians there. Russia denied responsibility, but satellite images and investigations by major news organisations contradicted its claims.
The atrocities hardened opinion in Ukraine and abroad. On 7 April Moscow called Kyiv's latest draft unacceptable, and the talks lost momentum. Contacts on prisoner exchanges and grain exports continued, but by late spring the political negotiations had effectively stopped.
Why the Istanbul process failed is still debated. A Ukrainian newspaper reported that British Prime Minister Boris Johnson, visiting Kyiv on 9 April, said the West was not ready to sign security guarantees with Putin. Russian officials later used that report to argue the West sabotaged peace. Zelensky and Ukraine's lead negotiator David Arakhamia have denied that outside pressure stopped a deal, pointing instead to Bucha and to Russia's terms.
The military picture in mid-March 2022
When Slutsky spoke, Russian columns were stalled north of Kyiv, hampered by fierce resistance, fuel and supply problems and heavy losses. Cities such as Mariupol, Kharkiv and Chernihiv were under bombardment or siege, and millions of Ukrainians had fled abroad. It was already the largest war in Europe since the Second World War.
Many observers expected a major assault on Kyiv. Instead, Russia pulled back from the capital at the end of March and shifted its focus to the east and south. Its larger aims, and how much of Ukraine it intended to control, were unclear at the time and remained the core obstacle to any settlement.
Reading wartime peace claims
The March 2022 episode offers a simple lesson for following any conflict. A negotiator's prediction is not a signed document, and a signed framework is not a working peace. Useful questions are: who is speaking and in what role, what has actually been agreed on paper, and do the core demands of both sides still clash? In this case, they did.
Sources: Wikipedia: Peace negotiations in the Russo-Ukrainian war; Wikipedia: Leonid Slutsky; Wikipedia: Bucha massacre.

COMMENTS