Did Elon Musk Pay No Federal Income Tax in 2018? The IRS Leak

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published June 11, 2021.

ProPublica Reported Musk Paid No Federal Income Tax in 2018

Yes, according to leaked IRS records, Elon Musk owed no federal income tax for 2018. The figure comes from ProPublica, which in June 2021 published an analysis of tax data covering thousands of the wealthiest Americans. The same records showed that Jeff Bezos paid no federal income tax in 2007 and again in 2011. Nothing in the reporting suggested either man broke the law. The point of the story was the opposite: the system, as written, allows people whose fortunes grow by billions to report little or no taxable income in some years.

Below is what the leak actually showed, why a billionaire can legally owe nothing in a given year, how the much-quoted 3.4% "true tax rate" was calculated, and what changed afterwards.

What the leaked IRS records showed

ProPublica's article, written by Jesse Eisinger, Jeff Ernsthausen and Paul Kiel and published on 8 June 2021, was the first in a series called "The Secret IRS Files". The newsroom said it had received more than 15 years of tax information on the country's richest people from an anonymous source.

For Musk, the records listed modest tax bills in some years ($68,000 in 2015 and $65,000 in 2017) and zero in 2018. For Bezos, they showed zero in 2007 and 2011; in 2011 he reported a loss on paper, even though he was already a billionaire. Other names appeared too. Carl Icahn paid no federal income tax in 2016 or 2017, which he linked to interest on large loans. George Soros paid none for three years in a row, which his spokesman put down to investment losses. Michael Bloomberg also had zero years, although in 2018 he paid $70.7 million on reported income of $1.9 billion.

Several of those named, including Warren Buffett, Bloomberg and Icahn, said they had paid every dollar they owed. Musk and Bezos did not answer ProPublica's detailed questions.

How a billionaire can legally owe nothing

US federal income tax is charged on income, not on wealth. Salary, interest and profits from selling assets count as income. A rise in the value of shares you still own does not. Economists call that an "unrealized gain", and it is only taxed when you sell.

That rule goes back a long way. ProPublica traced it to a 1920 Supreme Court case, Eisner v. Macomber, which tied income to a sale or some other realisation event. For people whose fortunes are mostly shares in companies they founded, this matters enormously. Musk took almost no conventional salary from Tesla in those years, and his wealth sat largely in Tesla and SpaceX stock. If he sold little and earned little in cash, there was little taxable income to report. Losses, deductions and interest costs in a given year can then push a tax bill down to zero.

"Buy, borrow, die"

Tax lawyers sometimes sum up the strategy in three words. You buy assets that grow without being taxed. You borrow against them instead of selling, because a loan is not income. ProPublica noted that Musk had pledged about 92 million Tesla shares as collateral for personal loans. Then, when you die, a rule called "step-up in basis" resets the value of inherited assets, so the growth during your lifetime is never taxed as income at all. The estate tax exists, but the wealthiest families can often reduce it through trusts and foundations.

The 3.4% "true tax rate", explained

The headline number in the coverage was that the 25 richest Americans saw their combined wealth rise by $401 billion between 2014 and 2018, according to Forbes estimates, while paying $13.6 billion in federal income tax. ProPublica divided the second number by the first and called the result, 3.4%, a "true tax rate". For Musk alone, the same calculation gave 3.27%; for Bezos, over a longer period, 1.1%; for Buffett, 0.1%.

It helps to be precise about what this is. It is not the rate the tax code applies to their income. It compares taxes paid with growth in wealth, and most of that growth was never income under the law. ProPublica was open about this and argued that it is the more honest measure of what the very rich contribute. For contrast, it estimated that a typical household earning around $70,000 paid roughly 14% of its income in federal taxes, and that wage earners in their early forties paid almost as much in tax as their net worth grew over the same years.

Critics pointed out that the wealthy often pay large bills in the years they do sell assets, and that billionaire wealth estimates swing with share prices. Both points are fair. Neither changes the basic finding: in many years, a fortune can grow enormously while the owner's taxable income stays small.

Common misunderstandings about the leak

"Musk never pays tax." Not accurate. The records showed he paid federal income tax in several years; the zero applied to 2018. Musk later said publicly that he expected to pay more than $11 billion for 2021 after exercising stock options and selling shares, a figure that comes from his own posts rather than published IRS data.

"They must have cheated." ProPublica did not allege tax evasion. Its argument was that legal rules favour people whose wealth comes from rising asset values rather than wages.

"The rate shows what billionaires pay on income." As explained above, it is tax divided by wealth growth, a different and deliberately provocative comparison.

Washington's response and the leaker

The story landed while President Joe Biden was proposing tax increases on high earners and corporations. The Treasury's budget explanations released in 2021 included raising the top individual rate from 37% to 39.6%, taxing long-term capital gains as ordinary income for people with more than $1 million in income, taxing large unrealized gains at death above a $1 million exclusion, and lifting the corporate rate from 21% to 28%. Republicans opposed the package, and most of those individual proposals never became law.

What did pass, in August 2022, was the Inflation Reduction Act. It created a 15% minimum tax on the book profits of very large companies, a 1% excise tax on share buybacks and extra money for IRS enforcement. It did not change individual income tax rates, and it did not tax unrealized gains.

The source of the leak was eventually identified. Charles Littlejohn, a former IRS contractor, admitted giving ProPublica tax data on thousands of the wealthiest Americans and passing Donald Trump's returns to The New York Times. He pleaded guilty in October 2023 to unauthorised disclosure of tax returns and in January 2024 was sentenced to five years in prison, the maximum for that offence. The case sharpened a debate that still continues: the public value of the reporting on one side, and the privacy of taxpayer records on the other.

What to take from the story

The Musk and Bezos zero-tax years are real, but they are less about two individuals than about how income is defined. As long as rising share prices are not income until sold, and borrowing against them is not income at all, the gap between wealth and taxable income will remain widest at the very top. When you see a "true tax rate" quoted, check what is being divided by what. When you see "paid no tax", check the year and the type of tax. Those two habits make most claims about billionaire taxes much easier to judge.

Sources: ProPublica: The Secret IRS Files (8 June 2021); Kelley Drye: summary of the 2021 Treasury Green Book; Wikipedia: Inflation Reduction Act; Wikipedia: Charles E. Littlejohn; originally flagged by Futurism.

COMMENTS