Trump's $750 Tax Bill: What the New York Times Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-28.

The New York Times' 2020 Report on Trump's Federal Income Taxes

On 27 September 2020, The New York Times published an investigation based on more than two decades of Donald Trump's tax records. Its headline findings: Trump paid just $750 in federal income tax in 2016, the year he won the presidency, and another $750 in 2017, his first year in office. He paid no federal income tax at all in 10 of the 15 years before 2016, largely because he reported losing more money than he made.

The report landed five weeks before the 2020 election and two days before the first Biden–Trump debate. Trump called it fake news but did not dispute the specific figures, and when Congress released his returns two years later, the $750 payments were confirmed. Here is what the Times found, how the deductions worked, and what happened next.

The key numbers in the Times report

  • $750 in federal income tax paid in 2016 and again in 2017.
  • No federal income tax in 10 of the previous 15 years; across the full 18 years of data, he paid no net federal income tax in 11.
  • $72.9 million: a federal tax refund Trump received around 2010, which the IRS had been auditing since 2011. If the audit went against him, the Times calculated he could owe more than $100 million including interest.
  • $421 million in loans and other debts he had personally guaranteed, much of it coming due within a few years.
  • At least $70,000 in hairstyling deducted as a business expense, connected to his television work on The Apprentice.

The figures refer to federal income tax only. Trump and his businesses also paid other taxes, such as payroll, property and state taxes, which the report treated separately.

How a wealthy businessman can pay so little

None of this requires anything exotic. US tax law lets business owners subtract losses from their income, and in many cases carry those losses forward to reduce tax in later years. The Times found that Trump's golf courses, hotels and other ventures reported large losses year after year, which offset income from The Apprentice, licensing deals and other sources.

The report also described deductions that critics saw as personal spending: residences classified as business or investment property, aircraft, consulting fees, and the hair and make-up costs. One example was the Seven Springs estate north of New York City, classed as an investment property, which allowed millions of dollars in property taxes to be written off.

The large refund came from a different mechanism. According to the Times, after the 2008 financial crisis a temporary change in the law allowed businesses to apply new losses against taxes already paid in earlier years. Trump used it to claim back most of the federal income tax he had paid in the mid-2000s, which is why that refund was under audit.

Whether any of this was improper is a separate question from whether it was legal. Aggressive but lawful tax planning is common among property developers. The Times did not show fraud; it showed a pattern of losses and deductions that contrasted sharply with Trump's public image as a hugely successful businessman.

Breaking with a presidential tradition

Since Richard Nixon, every US president had voluntarily released tax returns, and every major-party nominee from 1976 onward did so during the campaign. Trump was the first in decades to refuse. He repeatedly said he could not release them while under audit, a claim the IRS has rejected: taxpayers are free to publish their own returns at any time.

His reaction to the Times story followed the same line. At a White House press conference he called it "totally fake news," insisted he had paid tax, and said the returns would be released once the audit was finished. They never were released by him.

In July 2020, months before the Times story, the Supreme Court had ruled in Trump v. Vance that a sitting president had no absolute immunity from a state criminal subpoena for his financial records, and in Trump v. Mazars it sent a related congressional fight back to the lower courts.

What happened when the returns came out

The fight over the records ran for two more years. In November 2022 the Supreme Court cleared the way for the IRS to give six years of Trump's returns to the House Ways and Means Committee, and the committee published redacted versions on 30 December 2022.

The released returns confirmed $750 in federal income tax in 2016 and in 2017, about $1 million in 2018, about $133,000 in 2019 and nothing in 2020. They also showed that the IRS, which is supposed to audit every sitting president's return under its own long-standing policy, did not begin auditing Trump's 2017 return until 2019 and completed none of the mandatory audits while he was in office.

The leak itself had consequences. In 2023 a former IRS contractor, Charles Littlejohn, pleaded guilty to taking Trump's tax information and passing it to journalists, and in January 2024 he was sentenced to five years in federal prison, the maximum for the offence. In January 2026 Trump and the Trump Organization sued the IRS over the leaks; reports of a later settlement have been disputed.

Did it change the election?

Political journalists sometimes call a late campaign revelation an "October surprise." The tax story arrived a few days early, and Joe Biden raised it during the first debate on 29 September. Polls moved somewhat toward Biden that autumn, but many factors were in play, including the pandemic and Trump's own Covid-19 diagnosis in early October, so it is impossible to isolate the effect of one story.

What the report clearly did was settle a long-running question with documents rather than claims, and it fuelled a wider debate about how the US taxes wealthy business owners.

Key takeaways

  • Be precise about which tax. The $750 figure is federal income tax for two specific years, not all taxes Trump or his companies paid.
  • Legal is not the same as fair. Loss carry-forwards and business deductions are legal, which is exactly why the story turned into a debate about tax rules rather than a criminal case.
  • Documents outlast denials. The 2022 release confirmed the central numbers in the 2020 report.
  • Leaking tax data is a crime. The source of the records was prosecuted and imprisoned, even though the reporting itself was lawful.

Sources: The New York Times, 27 September 2020 (header photo: The New York Times); Wikipedia: Tax returns of Donald Trump; MPR News / NPR, 30 December 2022: House Democrats release Trump's tax returns; press-conference remarks reported by The Guardian.

COMMENTS