Smugglers Dropped Two Young Sisters From the Border Wall in 2021

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-04-03.

Border Patrol Footage Shows Smugglers Abandoning 5-Year-Old And 3-Year-Old Girl At The US-Mexico Border

Late on the night of 30 March 2021, a surveillance camera near Santa Teresa, New Mexico, just west of El Paso, recorded two smugglers sitting on top of the 14-foot steel border barrier. One by one they lowered two small girls over the US side and let them fall, threw down a few belongings and climbed back down into Mexico. The children, sisters aged 3 and 5 from Ecuador, were left alone in the desert in the dark.

US Border Patrol agents watching the camera feed reached them quickly. Both girls were taken to hospital for a check-up and were reported to be in good health. The next day the agency released the footage, and it spread around the world as a stark picture of what the smuggling business does to children. This article explains what the video showed, what happened to the sisters, and the law and border conditions that lay behind the scene.

What the video showed

The clip is short and grainy, filmed by a night-vision camera. It shows the two adults straddling the top of the bollard fence, each holding a child by the arms. They lean over, let go, and the girls drop the full height of the barrier onto sandy, uneven ground. The smugglers then throw down some of the girls' belongings and disappear back to the Mexican side.

The person who made it public was Gloria Chavez, then chief patrol agent of the Border Patrol's El Paso Sector. She posted it on Twitter on 31 March, thanking the agents who found the children and saying the girls had been left miles from the nearest home. In a statement reported by Fox News she said the smugglers had acted viciously and that Border Patrol was working with Mexican law enforcement to identify them.

Agents were able to respond so fast because this stretch of the border is covered by fixed cameras, mobile surveillance trucks, sensors and patrols. Without that, two toddlers could have spent hours alone in the desert, where nights in spring are cold and the terrain is rough.

Who the girls were and what happened to them

The sisters came from Ecuador. Their grandfather told reporters that the girls' parents, who were already living in the United States, had arranged for them to travel from the family's home area in Ecuador. Border Patrol located their mother in the US, and the girls stayed briefly in federal custody while the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) prepared to release them to family.

That is the normal route for children who arrive without a parent: HHS's Office of Refugee Resettlement looks after them in shelters and then releases them to a vetted sponsor, usually a parent or close relative already in the country. HHS declined to share details of the sisters' case, citing their age. Their story is a reminder that many of these journeys are organised by families who feel they have no other option, and who hand their children to criminal networks with little control over how they will be treated.

Why children are sent across alone: the 2008 law

A common claim at the time was that US law simply forbids sending unaccompanied children back. The real picture is more specific. The William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act, signed in 2008, set different rules depending on where a child comes from:

  • Children from Mexico or Canada (countries that border the US) can be returned quickly, if officers screen them and find they are not trafficking victims, have no credible fear of persecution, and can decide for themselves to withdraw their request to enter.
  • Children from all other countries, such as Ecuador, Guatemala or Honduras, must be transferred to HHS custody, normally within 72 hours, and can then pursue their case in immigration court while living with a sponsor.

The law was written to protect children from traffickers and from being sent back into danger without a hearing. Smugglers have learned to exploit it. Because a child from outside Mexico is likely to be placed with relatives in the US rather than turned back at once, some families pay to send children on their own, and some smugglers abandon them at the line once they are on US soil.

The spring 2021 surge in unaccompanied children

The New Mexico video came at a moment of intense pressure on the system. At the end of March 2021, Customs and Border Protection was holding more than 5,000 unaccompanied children in its own facilities, which are designed for short stays, while HHS had more than 11,000 in its shelters. Photographs of children crowded into a processing tent in south Texas drew wide criticism and pushed the new Biden administration to open emergency shelters and speed up placement with sponsors.

A public-health order known as Title 42, introduced during the pandemic, was then being used to expel many single adults and some families quickly. The Biden administration did not apply it to unaccompanied children, which critics said gave families another reason to send children alone, and which supporters said was the only humane choice.

The wall, its height and its limits

Donald Trump made a border wall the signature promise of his 2016 campaign and insisted Mexico would pay for it. By January 2021 roughly 450 miles of barrier had been built during his term, but most of it replaced older, lower fencing; only about 47 miles stood where there had been no barrier before. Mexico did not pay. Congress provided around a third of the money and the rest was diverted from the defence budget. President Biden paused construction on his first day in office.

The New Mexico footage shows one problem with a tall steel barrier: it does not stop people who are willing to climb it, and when children are involved, height becomes a danger in itself. Falls from border fencing are a known cause of serious injuries among adults who climb it, so dropping a toddler from the top was an especially reckless act.

Keeping the focus on the children

It is easy to treat a video like this as ammunition in a political argument. The facts are simpler: two very young children were put at risk by people paid to move them, and they survived because agents saw them in time. The incident does not by itself prove which border policy is right. It does show why child-protection rules, fast rescue capacity and action against smuggling networks all matter.

If you want to follow these issues further, the most reliable figures come from the agencies themselves: CBP publishes monthly encounter statistics, and HHS reports how many children are in its care and how long they stay. Reports from humanitarian groups working in shelters on both sides of the border add the human detail that numbers leave out.

Sources: Fox News, 31 March 2021; Yahoo News: young sisters dropped over 14-foot border fence; Gloria Chavez on Twitter (video); 8 U.S. Code § 1232 (Cornell LII); Wikipedia: Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2008; HHS Office of Refugee Resettlement: Unaccompanied Children Program; Wikipedia: Trump wall.

COMMENTS