Do Humans Have Venom Genes? What the 2021 PNAS Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published April 4, 2021.

Shared Gene Networks and Research Into the Origins of Venom

Do humans have the genes for venom? In a limited sense, yes, but not in the way the headlines suggested. A study published in PNAS in March 2021 found that a large network of genes working alongside venom genes in a snake's venom gland is also active in the salivary glands of mammals, including humans. That is strong evidence that venom glands evolved from ordinary salivary glands. It is not evidence that people are about to grow a toxic bite.

The paper, "An ancient, conserved gene regulatory network led to the rise of oral venom systems," was written by Agneesh Barua, then a PhD student at the Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology (OIST), and evolutionary biologist Alexander Mikheyev, who works at OIST and the Australian National University. Here is what they did, what they found and how far the findings really go.

The question the study tried to answer

Venom is surprisingly common in nature. It has evolved independently at least 104 times across eight animal phyla, in creatures as different as jellyfish, cone snails, spiders, scorpions, snakes and a handful of mammals. Biologists know a great deal about individual toxins, but less about the cellular machinery that allows a gland to make large amounts of toxic protein in the first place.

Most research had focused on the toxin genes themselves. Barua and Mikheyev asked a different question: which other genes have to be switched on, alongside the toxins, for a venom gland to work? If that supporting system turned out to be shared with ordinary salivary glands, it would point to a common origin.

What the researchers did

The team worked with venom glands from the Taiwan habu (Protobothrops mucrosquamatus), a pit viper that has become established in Okinawa. They looked for genes whose activity rose and fell together with the venom genes, then sorted out which of these were not toxins themselves but supporting players.

They identified roughly 3,000 cooperating genes, which the authors describe as a "metavenom network." Many of them help cells cope with the stress of producing huge quantities of protein, and others regulate how proteins are folded and modified so they work properly once secreted. These are often called housekeeping-type genes: they keep cells running rather than producing the venom's active ingredients.

The researchers then compared this network with genomes and tissues from other animals, including mammals such as dogs, chimpanzees and humans.

What they found in mammals, including us

Versions of these supporting genes turned up across mammals, and mammalian salivary gland tissue showed a pattern of gene activity similar to the snake's venom gland. The authors interpret this as an ancient functional core that snakes and mammals have shared since their lineages split hundreds of millions of years ago.

OIST's summary of the work quoted Barua calling it "the first real solid evidence for the theory that venom glands evolved from early salivary glands." In other words, the study is mainly about the origin of venom glands, not about human biology.

Could humans or mice become venomous?

This is where many headlines went too far, suggesting that humans could easily evolve a poisonous bite. The researchers did not say that. OIST's write-up says that, in theory, any mammal with the right ecological pressures could move in that direction, but for humans it describes this as very unlikely.

Barua used mice as a thought experiment. He pointed to experiments from the 1980s showing that male mice produce saliva compounds that are highly toxic when injected into rats. If, under some environment, mice with more toxic saliva left more offspring, he suggested that "in a few thousand years, we might encounter venomous mice." That is a hypothetical about natural selection, not a prediction, and the OIST summary adds that further research would be needed.

Humans are a poor candidate for this kind of change. We do not hunt with our mouths, we have no fangs or grooves to inject saliva, and our survival has depended on tools and cooperation rather than a bite. Evolution only builds a venom system when it pays off over many generations.

What about kallikreins in human saliva?

Older coverage also highlighted kallikreins, a family of enzymes. They are real and relevant: kallikrein-like enzymes appear in some snake venoms, and the venoms of solenodons and the northern short-tailed shrew are built from multiple copies of a kallikrein called KLK1. In these venoms the enzymes lower blood pressure in the victim.

Humans also make kallikreins, including in saliva, where they play normal roles such as helping regulate blood flow and inflammation. Having a protein in common with venom is not the same as having venom. Toxicity depends on how much is made, how it is modified and, crucially, how it gets into another animal. Most venoms are cocktails of many proteins, often from gene families that have been copied and changed many times over.

Mammals that really are venomous

Venomous mammals exist, which shows the route described in the study is real. Examples include:

  • Solenodons, shrew-like animals from Cuba and Hispaniola that deliver venomous saliva through grooved teeth;
  • Some shrews, such as the northern short-tailed shrew, whose saliva can subdue prey;
  • Male platypuses, which have venomous spurs on their hind legs;
  • Slow lorises, primates with a toxic secretion from glands on their arms;
  • Vampire bats, whose saliva contains compounds that keep blood flowing.

The salivary venoms of shrews and solenodons fit the study neatly: they look like modified saliva.

Myths to set aside

"Humans secretly carry venom." No. We share supporting genes with venomous animals; we do not make venom.

"Venom and poison are the same." Venom is injected through a bite or sting. Poison is passive, harmful when eaten, touched or inhaled.

"A human bite is dangerous because of toxins." Human bites can cause serious infections because of bacteria in the mouth, not venom. Anyone with a bite that breaks the skin should talk to a doctor.

The real takeaway is more interesting than a scary headline: one of nature's most potent weapons appears to have grown out of the same glands that help every mammal, including us, digest food.

Sources: Barua A. & Mikheyev A.S., "An ancient, conserved gene regulatory network led to the rise of oral venom systems," PNAS 118 (2021), doi:10.1073/pnas.2021311118; OIST news release; Wikipedia: Venom; Wikipedia: Kallikrein. Story first reported via IFLScience.

COMMENTS