New York's Excluded Workers Fund: Who Qualified and What It Paid

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-04-03.

New York's Excluded Workers Fund Proposal in April 2021

In April 2021 New York created a $2.1 billion Excluded Workers Fund, a one-time cash payment for people who lost income during the Covid-19 pandemic but could not get unemployment insurance or federal stimulus help. Many of them were undocumented immigrants. Early talk in Albany put the possible maximum at around $27,000 per person, but the rules that were finally adopted capped payments at $15,600, with a lower tier of $3,200 for people who could not document their work.

The fund was the first program of its kind in the United States, and it became one of the most argued-over parts of that year's state budget. Below is how it came about, who could apply, what the money actually looked like, and how quickly it ran out.

Why a group of workers was left out of pandemic aid

When the pandemic shut down restaurants, construction sites, salons and private homes in spring 2020, millions of Americans turned to unemployment insurance and the federal stimulus checks. Those programs had a basic requirement: a valid work authorisation or Social Security number, and a documented employment history.

That left out a large part of New York's workforce. Undocumented immigrants could not claim unemployment, and in most cases they were also outside the stimulus payments. Others fell through the cracks for different reasons: people paid in cash who had no paperwork to prove their earnings, and workers whose circumstances did not match what the benefit systems expected.

Many of these workers were in the very jobs that dried up first, such as delivery, cleaning, kitchen work, day labour and domestic care. Food bank queues in New York City grew long in 2020, and advocacy groups began pushing the state to fill the gap itself.

The negotiations in Albany

By late March 2021, Governor Andrew Cuomo and Democratic leaders in the state legislature were close to a deal. Politico reported on the talks at the time, and the early figures circulating were large: a weekly benefit modelled on unemployment pay, which some reports added up to roughly $27,000 for a person who qualified for the full period. Reports at the time also said the proposal could cover people recently released from prison who did not qualify for regular benefits; the final eligibility rules, described below, were based on residency, income and lost earnings.

The cause had well-organised support. A coalition called Fund Excluded Workers, which included immigrant groups and the Fiscal Policy Institute, held rallies, and some workers went on hunger strike to press lawmakers. Vanessa Agudelo of the New York Immigration Coalition told Politico, "This level of investment is absolutely historic for our communities."

Opponents saw it differently. Republicans argued that public money should not go to people living in the country illegally, and one unnamed Republican quoted in that coverage accused Democrats of political positioning: "They want to make this a political issue if it passes." The sponsor in the state Senate was Jessica Ramos, a Democrat from Queens.

The fund passed as part of the state budget on 8 April 2021, at $2.1 billion.

Who could apply

The final rules were narrower than the headlines suggested. According to a guide published by Documented, a New York newsroom covering immigration, applicants had to meet all of these conditions:

  • They lived in New York State before 27 March 2020 and still lived there.
  • They were not eligible for, and had not received, unemployment insurance or certain other Covid-19 income support.
  • They had earned less than $26,208 in the 12 months before April 2021.
  • They had lost at least half of their weekly work income or household income between 23 February 2020 and 1 April 2021 because of the pandemic, or had become the main earner after the head of the household died or became disabled.

Immigration status was not a condition either way. The point of the fund was that it did not ask for the documents that had shut these workers out of the federal programs.

What the payments really were

Instead of weekly checks, the fund paid one lump sum on a prepaid Visa card sent by post. There were two tiers:

  • Tier 1: up to $15,600, less $780 withheld for tax. This needed proof of New York residency plus tax filings from 2018, 2019 or 2020, or other proof of lost income. Spread over a year, it worked out at a little under $300 a week.
  • Tier 2: $3,200, less $160 for tax, for people who could not supply that paperwork.

So the widely shared figure of $27,000 per person was never paid. It came from proposals discussed before the deal, not from the program that New Yorkers applied to. Applicants also had to collect points from a list of accepted documents to prove identity, residency and work, and the Department of Labor said processing would take six to eight weeks.

How fast the money went

Applications opened in summer 2021, and demand far outran the forecasts. In April, the Fiscal Policy Institute had estimated that about 92,000 people would qualify for the higher tier and 199,000 for the lower one. Instead, almost everyone who was approved qualified for Tier 1.

By early October 2021, according to New York Focus, more than 335,000 people had applied and about 116,000 had been approved. Over 99 percent of the approved applicants received the higher amount, and roughly $1.8 billion had been paid out or promised. The Department of Labor stopped taking new applications on 8 October 2021, about two months after the fund opened. It guaranteed payment for applications filed before 24 September, but people who applied later had no such promise.

Critics, including a Daily News editorial, said officials had been too quick to approve the top tier. Advocates replied that the speed of the run-down showed how many people had been going without help, and they began campaigning for more money. Governor Kathy Hochul, who had replaced Cuomo in August 2021, praised the program's progress without committing to expand it.

The wider picture in 2021

The debate took place against a very hard year. By the time the fund was agreed, more than half a million people in the United States had died of Covid-19. In April 2020 the national unemployment rate had jumped to 14.7 percent. Some coverage at the time described this as worse than the Great Depression, but that is not accurate: it was the highest rate since the Depression era, while unemployment in the early 1930s is estimated to have been considerably higher.

The Excluded Workers Fund remains a useful case study for anyone looking at how relief programs are designed. It shows the gap between a headline number and a final rule, how documentation requirements shape who gets help, and how hard it is to estimate demand among people who are, almost by definition, missing from official records.

Quick answers

Did undocumented immigrants in New York get $27,000?

No. The adopted fund paid a one-time maximum of $15,600 before tax, or $3,200 in the lower tier.

Was the money only for immigrants?

No. It was for any New York resident who met the income, residency and income-loss tests and had been shut out of unemployment and other pandemic aid, whatever their immigration status.

Can people still apply?

No. The Department of Labor closed the fund to new applications on 8 October 2021.

Sources: New York Focus: The Excluded Workers Fund is running out (October 2021); Documented: How the Excluded Workers Fund will work; Politico, March 2021 (quotes); first reported to us via The Western Journal.

COMMENTS