Boy Left Alone Near Texas Border Asked an Agent for Help in 2021

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-04-07.

Video Showed a Child Seeking Help From a US Border Patrol Officer in 2021

In early April 2021 a short phone video from south Texas spread around the world. It showed a boy, alone and crying beside a rural road, walking up to a US Border Patrol agent and asking for help. He explained that the group of migrants he had been travelling with had left him behind and that he was afraid of being robbed or kidnapped. US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) confirmed the footage was genuine and said the boy was a 10-year-old from Nicaragua. Some early reports described him as about five, but the agency's figure was 10.

The clip became a symbol of a wider moment at the border, when record numbers of children were arriving without a parent. This article explains what happened to the boy, why so many children were crossing alone in 2021, and what the numbers really showed.

What the video showed

The encounter took place near La Grulla, a small community close to Rio Grande City in Starr County, Texas, on a wet day in the Rio Grande Valley. The agent had stopped his vehicle when he saw the boy on the road. Speaking in Spanish, the boy said he had been with a group that abandoned him and he did not know where they had gone. Asked whether they had left him alone, he answered that he had come to the agent because he had nowhere else to go. In the words reported by ABC News:

"I was with a group of people and they dumped me and I don't know where they are."

A friend of the agent posted the video on Facebook, and it was quickly picked up by television networks. CBP said the boy had been part of a group of roughly 80 people, which agents later apprehended; the original Facebook post put the number higher.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

What happened to him afterwards

According to CBP, agents took the boy to a Border Patrol processing facility, where he was fed and given a medical screening. As with other unaccompanied children, he was then due to be transferred to the care of the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR), part of the Department of Health and Human Services. The Facebook post that first shared the clip said his family had been contacted.

That is the standard path. Children who arrive without a parent or legal guardian are not kept by the Border Patrol beyond a short period; ORR houses them in shelters and tries to place them with a sponsor, usually a parent or close relative already living in the United States, while their immigration case goes before a judge.

Why children were crossing alone in 2021

Several factors came together. Poverty, gang violence, political repression and the economic damage of the pandemic pushed many families in Central America to leave, and two major hurricanes struck the region in November 2020. Nicaragua, the boy's home country, was also going through a deepening political crisis.

US policy shaped how people crossed. Since March 2020 a public-health order known as Title 42 allowed border officials to expel most adults and many families quickly, without hearing asylum claims. In early 2021 the Biden administration stopped applying those expulsions to unaccompanied children. Under a 2008 anti-trafficking law, children from countries other than Mexico and Canada who arrive alone cannot simply be turned back; they must be handed to ORR and allowed to present their case. US officials and media reported that, as a result, some parents sent children across on their own, hoping they could join relatives in the United States.

Smugglers were part of the picture too. CBP repeatedly warned that people smugglers were abandoning children in remote areas, sometimes deliberately, once they were near the border.

The scale in numbers

March 2021 was one of the busiest months at the southwest border in two decades. CBP recorded roughly 172,000 encounters with migrants that month, including close to 19,000 unaccompanied children, a monthly record at the time, and about 53,000 people travelling as families. Those figures count encounters, not individual people: because many adults were expelled under Title 42 and tried again, some people were counted more than once. Children travelling alone, however, were not expelled, so their numbers reflect actual arrivals more closely.

A few days before the boy's video appeared, CBP released night-time camera footage from near Santa Teresa, New Mexico, showing two small girls, aged three and five, being lowered over the top of the roughly 14-foot border barrier by smugglers and left on the US side. Agents found the sisters, who were from Ecuador, and took them into care. Our separate report covers the footage of the two girls left at the border.

Crowded facilities and political pressure

The surge overwhelmed Border Patrol stations that were designed to hold adults for hours, not children for days. In March 2021 Texas congressman Henry Cuellar released photos from a temporary facility in Donna, Texas, showing children packed together on mats under foil blankets. The images drew criticism from both the left and the right and put pressure on the new administration.

The government responded by opening emergency intake sites for children at convention centres and military bases so they could be moved out of Border Patrol custody faster, and by speeding up placement with sponsors. On 24 March 2021 President Joe Biden asked Vice President Kamala Harris to lead diplomatic efforts with Mexico and the Northern Triangle countries of Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador, focused on the reasons people were leaving, rather than on managing the border itself.

Border policy had been a defining issue of the previous administration as well. Donald Trump campaigned in 2016 on building a wall along the southern border. Congress never provided the full funding he requested, and most of the barrier built during his term replaced older, smaller fencing rather than covering new ground.

Common misunderstandings

"Children who arrive alone automatically get to stay"

They do not. Being released to a sponsor is not a legal status. Each child is placed in immigration court proceedings and must qualify for something like asylum or special immigrant juvenile status to remain; many cases take years and some end in removal orders.

"A crying child proves what the parents intended"

A single clip shows a frightened child in a dangerous situation. It cannot tell us why the adults around him made the decisions they did, whether he was separated by accident, or what pressures his family faced at home. Those details usually only emerge, if at all, through the case process.

"The numbers were all new people"

As explained above, encounter statistics include repeat attempts by adults. The rise was real, but the totals overstate the number of different individuals.

Why the video struck a chord

The clip lasted barely a minute, yet it captured something statistics could not: a child who had travelled thousands of kilometres from Nicaragua, alone at the end, choosing to walk towards a uniformed stranger because he judged that safer than staying on the road. Whatever one's view of immigration policy, the episode was a reminder that the people at the centre of the debate are often children, and that the most dangerous stretch of the journey is frequently the last one, where smugglers abandon those who slow them down.

Sources: ABC13 / ABC News report on the boy found near La Grulla; US Customs and Border Protection: Southwest land border encounters; Daily Mail (original report).

COMMENTS