Biden's 2021 Pledge to Pull All US Troops Out of Afghanistan

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-04-16.

Biden Announces That All US Troops Will Be Withdrawn From Afghanistan By Sept. 11th, 20 Years After The War Began

On 14 April 2021 President Joe Biden announced that all US troops would leave Afghanistan before 11 September 2021, the 20th anniversary of the attacks that started the war. Speaking from the White House Treaty Room, he said it was "time to end America's longest war". The deadline was later brought forward to 31 August, and the last American soldiers flew out of Kabul just before midnight on 30 August, two weeks after the Taliban had taken the capital.

This article explains why Biden made the decision, how it was received in Washington, and how the withdrawal actually unfolded.

What Biden announced

News of the plan broke the day before, on 13 April, through reporting in The Washington Post and other outlets that quoted senior administration officials. The formal speech followed on 14 April.

Biden made several points. The original mission in 2001 had been to make sure Afghanistan could not be used again as a base to attack the United States, and he argued that this goal had been met, especially after Osama bin Laden was killed in 2011. Terrorist threats had since spread to many other regions, so keeping thousands of troops in one country no longer made sense. He described himself as the fourth US president to oversee American troops in Afghanistan and said he would not pass the war on to a fifth.

Under the plan, the drawdown would begin on 1 May 2021 and finish before the September anniversary. NATO allies, who had their own forces in the country, agreed to leave on the same timetable.

The deal Biden inherited

The timing was shaped by an agreement signed by the Trump administration. On 29 February 2020 the United States and the Taliban signed the Doha Agreement in Qatar. Washington agreed to withdraw all US and allied forces by 1 May 2021. In return the Taliban promised not to let groups such as al-Qaeda use Afghan territory to threaten the US, and to enter talks with the Afghan government. The elected government in Kabul was not a party to the deal.

By the time Biden took office in January 2021, US troop numbers had already been cut to about 2,500. The Taliban warned that foreign forces staying beyond 1 May would be treated as a breach of the agreement. Officials explained that missing the deadline without a clear plan to leave would put the US back at war with the Taliban, and that a withdrawal tied to conditions on the ground would in practice mean staying indefinitely. That is why the White House chose a fixed date rather than a conditions-based exit.

Twenty years of war in brief

The war began on 7 October 2001, less than a month after the 11 September attacks, which killed nearly 3,000 people in the United States. Al-Qaeda, led by Osama bin Laden, carried out the attacks, and the Taliban government in Kabul had given the group a base. A US-led coalition, supported by Afghan opposition forces, removed the Taliban from power within weeks.

Bin Laden escaped. He was eventually found hiding in Abbottabad, Pakistan, and killed by US Navy SEALs on 2 May 2011. The Taliban regrouped, much of it from bases across the border in Pakistan, and fought an insurgency that never ended. At the peak in 2010–11 there were about 98,000 American troops in Afghanistan.

The human cost was immense. In his April speech Biden cited 2,448 US troops and personnel killed and more than 20,000 wounded. Estimates for the whole war put total deaths at between about 176,000 and more than 212,000 people, including over 46,000 Afghan civilians and between 66,000 and 92,000 members of the Afghan security forces. Some early reports gave a figure of around $1 trillion for the war's cost to the US; independent academic estimates that include long-term costs such as veterans' care and interest go well above $2 trillion.

How Washington reacted

The decision split opinion in both parties, though most Democrats welcomed it.

Senator Bernie Sanders praised what he called a brave and right decision. Senator Elizabeth Warren also backed the withdrawal, saying it had come years late and that the open-ended military approach had no clear endgame. Others who supported it included Representatives Barbara Lee and Ro Khanna and Republican Senator Rand Paul.

The strongest criticism came from Republicans. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell called a rushed pull-out "a grave mistake" and described it as a retreat from an enemy that had not been defeated. Senators Lindsey Graham, Jim Inhofe, Mitt Romney and Joni Ernst also opposed the plan, as did Democratic Senator Jeanne Shaheen, who worried about the fate of Afghan women and girls.

How the withdrawal unfolded

The Taliban launched a major offensive as US forces began leaving on 1 May. On 8 July Biden moved the end date to 31 August. Through July and early August, provincial capitals fell one after another, often with little resistance from Afghan government forces.

On 15 August 2021 President Ashraf Ghani fled the country and the Taliban entered Kabul. The US rushed thousands of troops back to the city's airport to run an evacuation. Chaotic scenes followed as crowds tried to reach flights.

On 26 August a suicide bomber struck near the airport's Abbey Gate. The attack, claimed by the Islamic State affiliate ISIS-K, killed 13 US service members and around 170 Afghans. It was the deadliest day for American forces in Afghanistan in a decade.

About 123,000 people were flown out in total. The final US C-17 left Kabul at 11:59 pm local time on 30 August. General Kenneth McKenzie, head of US Central Command, admitted that not everyone they had hoped to evacuate had been brought out. The final count of US service members killed in Afghanistan stood at 2,461.

The legacy of the decision

The April 2021 announcement did what it set out to do: it ended the United States' longest war, close to its 20th anniversary. But the speed of the government's collapse, the scenes at Kabul airport and the airport bombing made the exit one of the most debated episodes of Biden's presidency.

Supporters argue that the US could not have stayed without returning to full-scale war and that no exit would have been painless. Critics say the planning underestimated the Taliban and left many Afghans who had worked with Western forces behind. In Afghanistan itself, the Taliban have ruled since August 2021, with sharp restrictions on women's education and work.

Sources: The White House, 14 April 2021: Remarks by President Biden on the way forward in Afghanistan; Wikipedia: Withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan (2020–2021); Wikipedia: War in Afghanistan (2001–2021); Military.com, 30 August 2021; story first shared via Upworthy.

COMMENTS