Originally published 2021-04-16.

Bruce's Beach is a stretch of oceanfront land in Manhattan Beach, California, that a Black couple, Charles and Willa Bruce, bought in 1912 and turned into a seaside resort for Black visitors. In the 1920s the city took it from them through eminent domain. In April 2021 Los Angeles County began the process of giving the land back to their descendants, the state changed the law to allow it, and in 2022 the deed was handed to two of the Bruces' great-grandsons. In January 2023 the family sold the property back to the county for $20 million.
Here is how the land was taken, how it came back, and why the case became a national reference point for restitution.
A Black-owned resort on the Strand
In 1912 the couple paid $1,225 for beachfront property on the Strand, and the holding eventually covered two parcels. At a time when Black Californians were turned away from many beaches, hotels and bathhouses, the Bruces built what is often described as the first West Coast beach resort for Black people. It grew from a simple stand into a lodge with a café, a dance hall and changing tents where visitors could rent bathing suits. Families came by train and car from across Los Angeles to spend a day at the ocean.
Other Black families bought nearby lots, and a small community began to form. The resort was a business as well as a home, and by the standards of the time it was a successful one.
Harassment, the Klan and condemnation
White neighbours and city officials did not want that community to grow. Visitors faced intimidation, and a nearby developer put up signs and barriers that forced Black beachgoers to walk an extra half mile to reach the water. According to Spectrum News, the Ku Klux Klan attacked the resort in 1920, and KQED reported that Klan members tried to burn the property down.
In 1924 the Manhattan Beach City Council moved to condemn the Bruces' land and the neighbouring Black-owned lots through eminent domain, saying the area was needed for a public park. The buildings were razed in 1927. The Bruces sued for $120,000; in 1929 they received a settlement of $14,500 and lost the land. They were unable to reopen their business elsewhere in town. The promised park did not appear for decades: the land sat largely unused until a park was built on part of it in 1960.
Charles and Willa Bruce. #BrucesBeach 🤬🤬🤬 pic.twitter.com/m507To6BtD
— Now Mr. Pretty Tony..... (@goodkounsel) March 29, 2021
The family's later story is one of loss. A family spokesperson said in 2021 that after being driven out, the Bruces lived in Los Angeles in poverty, far from the prosperity the resort had promised.
How the land changed hands
The parcels did not stay with the city. In 1948 they were transferred to the State of California, and in 1995 the state passed them to Los Angeles County for beach operations, with restrictions that limited any sale or transfer. The county built a lifeguard training headquarters on the site. In 2006 Manhattan Beach renamed the adjoining park Bruce's Beach and placed a plaque there, though many residents felt it told only part of the story.
Those restrictions explain why the return required a new state law. The county could not simply hand the deed back on its own.
The 2021 push to return it
In April 2021 County Supervisor Janice Hahn, whose district includes Manhattan Beach, announced that the county intended to return the property. On 20 April 2021 the Board of Supervisors voted unanimously to begin the process. Hahn put the injustice simply:
"The Bruces had their California dream stolen from them." (Janice Hahn, Los Angeles County Supervisor)
A Black family's beach property in California was taken during the Jim Crow era. Now, Los Angeles County officials say they are working with state lawmakers on legislation that would return the property — worth approximately $75 million — to the family. https://t.co/IgzIPU860r
— CNN (@CNN) April 13, 2021
Early coverage, including CNN's, put the land's value at around $75 million; KQED noted at the time that no formal assessment had been made. State Senator Steven Bradford introduced SB 796 to lift the 1995 restrictions. The bill passed the legislature and Governor Gavin Newsom signed it on 30 September 2021.
The Manhattan Beach City Council took a different route. It approved a statement acknowledging and condemning the city's role in the 1920s condemnation but declined to issue a formal apology, partly over concerns about legal liability. Members argued that today's residents were not responsible for what happened a century ago. In March 2022 the council approved new wording for the plaque.
The handover and the 2023 sale
On 28 June 2022 the Board of Supervisors approved the transfer of the two parcels to Marcus and Derrick Bruce, great-grandsons of Charles and Willa, and a deed ceremony followed that summer. The agreement gave the county a lease of about $413,000 a year to keep its lifeguard facilities there, and an option to buy the land back for up to $20 million.
In January 2023 the family chose to sell at that maximum price. Hahn called the return "what reparations look like", and Bradford said the family was exercising a right that should never have been taken from them.
Why Bruce's Beach matters beyond California
Bruce's Beach is often cited as one of the first cases in the United States of a government returning land taken from a Black family through discriminatory eminent domain. It shows several things at once. Eminent domain, a legal tool for public projects, was used across the country to clear Black neighbourhoods. Losses of that kind compound over generations, because property is how many American families build and pass on wealth. And repair is possible, but it takes specific legal steps: in this case a county vote, a state law and a negotiated transfer.
It also shows the limits. The family received the land almost a century after it was taken, and the figures involved, $1,225 in 1912, a $14,500 settlement in 1929, a rough $75 million estimate in 2021 and a $20 million sale in 2023, measure very different things. None of them captures what the Bruces and their descendants lost in income, opportunity and a family business that might have grown.
Other cities and states have since looked at Bruce's Beach as a model for addressing similar takings. Each case depends on records: deeds, council minutes and court files that prove who owned what and how it was taken.
Sources: Wikipedia: Bruce's Beach; KQED: A Black-owned beachfront was seized in the 1920s; Spectrum News 1: Family to sell Bruce's Beach property back to LA County for $20 million; first reported via Upworthy.

COMMENTS