Originally published 2021-04-17.
In April 2021 an international team led by Juan Carlos Izpisua Belmonte of the Salk Institute in California reported that it had grown macaque monkey embryos containing human cells in the lab for up to 20 days. The study, published in the journal Cell on 15 April 2021, was the first to show human stem cells surviving and integrating in early primate embryos. No animal was born, and the embryos were never placed in a womb. Still, the work set off one of the biggest bioethics debates of that year. Here is what the scientists actually did, why they did it and what critics feared.
What the experiment involved
The research was a collaboration between the Salk Institute and Kunming University of Science and Technology in Yunnan, China, with Tao Tan of the State Key Laboratory of Primate Biomedical Research as a lead author. The Chinese team had developed a technique for keeping monkey embryos alive in a dish for longer than was previously possible, which made the experiment feasible.
Researchers took macaque embryos six days after fertilisation and injected each one with 25 human extended pluripotent stem cells. These are cells that can, in principle, develop into almost any tissue in the body. One day later, human cells were detected in 132 embryos. By day 10, 103 of them were still developing. By day 19 only three were alive, and all were destroyed by day 20.
On average, only around 3 to 4 percent of the cells in each embryo were human, with up to about 7 percent in one case. In other words, these were overwhelmingly monkey embryos with a small population of human cells mixed in. Such mixed organisms are called chimeras, after the fire-breathing creature of Greek myth made of a lion, goat and serpent.
Chimera or hybrid? An important difference
Headlines often called these embryos "hybrids", but that is not accurate. In a hybrid, every cell carries genetic material from both species, as in a mule, which comes from a horse and a donkey. In a chimera, each cell belongs to one species or the other; the two populations simply live side by side in the same body.
The difference matters for the ethics. Nobody created a being with mixed human and monkey DNA in its cells. The question critics raised was instead what happens if human cells end up in sensitive tissues, such as the brain or the cells that later form eggs and sperm, in an animal that is closely related to us.
Why scientists want human-animal chimeras
Belmonte's group had worked on chimeras for years. In 2017 his team reported pig embryos containing human cells, but the human contribution was extremely small. Pigs and humans are separated by tens of millions of years of evolution, and human cells struggled to survive. Monkeys are far closer relatives, so the 2021 study was partly a way to understand which molecular signals help or block human cells from integrating, lessons that might later be applied to pigs.
The long-term goals the researchers described include:
- Organs for transplant. Thousands of people die every year waiting for a donor organ. One distant hope is to grow human organs in animals such as pigs.
- Better disease models. Mouse studies often fail to predict how human cells behave. Chimeras could let scientists watch human cells develop in a living system.
- Early development and ageing. Belmonte told reporters the approach could help research at both the earliest and latest stages of life, from embryo development to age-related disease.
He also stressed that historically such chimeras had suffered from very low efficiency, which is why understanding how the two cell types communicate was a central aim of the study.
The ethical objections
Critics did not all argue the same thing. Some objected in principle to mixing human and animal cells. Others were worried less about this experiment than about where the field could go next.
Dr Anna Smajdor, a biomedical ethicist then at the University of East Anglia, told the BBC that the moral status of such embryos is unclear: "whether these embryos are human or not is open to question." If scientists justify chimeras because certain experiments cannot be done on humans, she argued, it becomes hard to say exactly what these embryos are.
Prof. Julian Savulescu of the Oxford Uehiro Centre for Practical Ethics pointed out that although these embryos were destroyed at 20 days, the long-term aim is to bring chimeras further along, perhaps as a source of human organs. He warned that the research "opens Pandora's box to human-nonhuman chimeras."
Others focused on oversight. Stem cell scientist Paul Knoepfler told STAT that leaving the rules to individual institutions "seems to me like a recipe for big trouble." Duke University's Nita Farahany described it as a first-of-its-kind experiment that needed public discussion.
The main worries in plain terms
- Brain development: could human cells change the cognitive abilities or awareness of an animal?
- Reproduction: could human cells contribute to eggs or sperm, raising the prospect of a human embryo developing inside an animal?
- Animal welfare: primates are intelligent, social animals, and many people object to using them in research at all.
- Regulation gaps: international rules on chimeras were patchy, and work in one country can be done under very different oversight than in another.
Myths and facts
Myth: scientists created a half-human, half-monkey creature. No animal was born or even implanted. These were embryos in a dish, studied for less than three weeks.
Myth: the embryos were mostly human. Human cells made up only a few percent of each embryo on average.
Myth: the work broke international rules. The study received ethical review at the institutions involved. A widely used limit, often called the 14-day rule, applies to growing human embryos in the lab, not to animal embryos with some human cells, though the study did push critics to ask whether new limits were needed. A month later, in May 2021, the International Society for Stem Cell Research updated its guidelines and included guidance on chimeric embryo research.
Where the debate stands
The 2021 study showed that human cells can live and communicate with cells of a close relative in very early development, which is a genuine scientific step. It did not bring human organs grown in animals any closer to the clinic in a direct way; that work still depends on pigs, and on solving immune rejection, infection risks and much more.
What it did do was make the public question unavoidable. As human-animal chimera research advances, societies will need to decide which experiments are acceptable, how far embryos can be developed and who checks the work. Those are not only questions for scientists, and the debate this study triggered is one reason they are being discussed openly today.
Sources: STAT News: International team creates first chimeric human-monkey embryos; Drug Target Review: Scientists generate human-monkey chimeric embryos; Wikipedia: Juan Carlos Izpisua Belmonte; Wikipedia: Chimera (genetics). Comments by Anna Smajdor and Julian Savulescu were given to BBC News.

COMMENTS