Grandma and Her Cat Gabby Died Four Hours Apart: Their Story

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-16.

A Grandmother and Her Cat Gabby: A Family Remembers

Grandma and Gabby at home. Photo: Judy Caponigro, via The Dodo

A grandmother and her elderly cat, Gabby, died on the same day, roughly four hours apart. Gabby, who was about 15 and failing, was put to sleep at the vet while Grandma held her. Grandma then went home, lay down on the couch for a nap and did not wake up. Her granddaughter, the writer Jill Layton, later shared the story with The Dodo, and the family buried the two of them together.

Nobody can say for certain why the timing lined up so closely. What the family could say, and what made the story travel around the world, was how deeply the two had depended on each other for well over a decade.

What happened on their last day

By the end, both of them had slowed down at the same pace. Gabby had stopped seeking company and spent most of her days alone. Grandma was eating very little and had lost a worrying amount of weight. Jill described them as two old ladies coming to the end of the road together.

Grandma made the decision with her vet that it was kinder to let Gabby go. She stayed with her cat through the injection, holding her until it was over. Back at home that afternoon she settled down to rest, and she died a few hours later. Jill wrote that she does not think it was a coincidence, while also allowing that it may simply have been Grandma's time.

A Grandmother and Her Cat Gabby: A Family Remembers

The family says this photo was taken on Grandma and Gabby's final day together. Photo: Judy Caponigro, via The Dodo

More than a decade of quiet companionship

Gabby joined the household as a two-year-old. According to Love Meow's account of the story, shelter volunteers brought three cats to the house to meet the couple, and Gabby was the only one who seemed at home right away. She walked in, found a bed upstairs and curled up as if she had always lived there.

Not long afterwards Grandpa died. A large house became too much to manage, so Grandma and Gabby moved into a seniors' apartment complex where help was available but residents still lived on their own terms. From then on it was just the two of them: daytime company on the sofa, and, as Jill remembered fondly, a cat who liked to stroll across Grandma's head at night.

As a child, Jill watched that relationship closely and decided she wanted the same thing for herself one day. Her memory of Grandma's apartment is less about a pet and an owner than about two housemates who looked after each other.

"My grandma and her cat were inseparable – in life and in death."

— Jill Layton, writing in The Dodo

Can grief really affect the heart?

The phrase people reach for with stories like this is "a broken heart". There is a real medical condition behind the expression, although nobody can say whether it played any part here. The family never described a cause of death, and it would be wrong to guess.

Takotsubo cardiomyopathy, often called broken heart syndrome, is a temporary weakening of the heart muscle that is not caused by blocked arteries. It was first described in Japan in 1990. Most cases follow a sudden emotional or physical stress, and bereavement is one of the best-known triggers. Around nine in ten patients are women, most often after menopause, with an average age in the late sixties.

Symptoms such as chest pain and breathlessness can look like a heart attack, which is why doctors usually run tests to tell the two apart. For most people heart function recovers within weeks to months, and the long-term outlook is generally good, though a minority have serious complications.

So the honest answer is that grief can strain the body, and there is a recognised syndrome linked to loss. An elderly woman who was already frail and not eating may also simply have reached the end of her life on the same day by chance. Both explanations can sit side by side with the family's own belief that the two were meant to go together. Anyone who notices chest pain or breathlessness after a shock or a loss should talk to a doctor straight away.

Why a pet can mean so much in later life

For an older person living alone, a cat or dog is often the main source of routine and touch in the day. There is food to put out, a lap to share, someone to talk to. Gabby arrived just before Grandpa's death and stayed through the move, the new apartment and the long years of widowhood. That is a great deal of shared history for any relationship.

Research on pet loss reflects this. Grief over an animal can be as intense as grief over a person, and it tends to be stronger when the owner relied on the pet emotionally. In one University of Michigan study of 174 adults who had lost a pet, about 86 percent reported at least one grief symptom at first; about one in five still did a year later. The closer the attachment, the longer and harder the grief tended to be.

Choosing euthanasia can add another layer. Even when it is plainly the kind decision, owners often carry guilt or replay the moment. Grandma faced that choice on what turned out to be her own last day.

Coping when an old pet dies

Most families will never see a story end the way this one did, but many will lose an older pet that has been part of a parent's or grandparent's daily life. A few things tend to help:

  • Take the grief seriously. Pet loss is sometimes brushed aside by others, which can make people hide how much it hurts. Saying it out loud matters.
  • Check in on older relatives. If a widowed parent or grandparent loses a long-time pet, visit more often for a while and keep an eye on eating and sleeping.
  • Plan ahead where possible. Talking with a vet about quality of life before a crisis makes the final decision less of a shock.
  • Keep the memories visible. Photos, a collar on a shelf or a short written tribute, like the one Jill published, help many people.
  • Use support that exists. Several veterinary schools and charities run pet-loss helplines, and grief counsellors increasingly work with bereaved pet owners.

Buried side by side

The family laid Grandma and Gabby to rest together. Jill's tribute ends with the idea that whatever caused the timing, the bond itself was the point: two companions who had seen each other through loss and old age, and who left within hours of each other.

The story first spread in 2016 and has resurfaced many times since, largely because it puts into words something many pet owners feel but rarely say. An animal that shares the ordinary days of a life can become one of the most important relationships in it.

Sources: Jill Layton, The Dodo; Love Meow; Wikipedia: Takotsubo cardiomyopathy; Wikipedia: Pet loss. Photos: Judy Caponigro.

COMMENTS