Could a Dyson Sphere Power Digital Resurrection? The Idea Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-15.

Transhumanists Imagined Digital Resurrection Powered by a Dyson Sphere

Short answer: no machine like this exists, and nobody knows how to build one. In the late 2010s two Russian transhumanists, Alexey Turchin and Maxim Chernyakov, sketched a speculative route to "technological resurrection" in which a vast computer, fed with every scrap of data about a dead person, would rebuild that person as a digital copy. Because the computing job would be enormous, one branch of their plan imagined drawing power from a Dyson sphere, a hypothetical swarm of collectors wrapped around a star. In 2021 Popular Mechanics brought the idea to a wide audience, and scientists it spoke to were openly doubtful.

The proposal is worth understanding anyway, because it sits where real physics, real computing limits and a very old human question meet: if a perfect copy of you could be made, would it be you?

What Turchin and Chernyakov actually proposed

Their paper, "Classification of Approaches to Technological Resurrection", is less a blueprint than a catalogue. It tries to list every route to bringing back the dead that does not break known science, while admitting that none of them works today. The best-known item on the list is cryonics, the freezing of bodies or brains in the hope that future medicine can revive them. Further along the list come more exotic options, such as rebuilding a person from preserved information, or a future superintelligence simulating every possible human mind so that the dead are recreated along with everyone else.

The data-based route is the one that grabbed headlines. In outline, it would gather everything that survives of a person: writing, recordings, photographs, medical files, the memories of friends and relatives, even the historical context of the town they grew up in. Software would then try to infer the mind that could have produced all those traces and run it as a simulation. In some versions the copy relives its life; in others it wakes in a digital afterlife. Fans of television will recognise the setting of "San Junipero", the 2016 Black Mirror episode in which the elderly and the dead live on in a simulated beach town.

The authors also floated the idea that such a reconstruction might one day be paired with biotechnology, placing the recovered personality into a newly grown, younger body. That part is pure speculation layered on speculation.

Turchin has said his interest in defeating death goes back to his school years, reportedly after the death of an 11-year-old classmate. He has worked for years on so-called immortality roadmaps, which rank options from the plausible to the far-fetched; the Dyson sphere scheme sits at the far-fetched end, as a backup plan rather than a first choice.

Why a Dyson sphere comes into it

The physicist Freeman Dyson described the concept in a short 1960 paper in Science, "Search for Artificial Stellar Sources of Infra-Red Radiation". His point was mainly about astronomy: a civilisation that captured most of its star's light would have to shed the waste heat as infrared, so telescopes could look for stars that glow oddly in infrared as a sign of alien engineering. Dyson credited the British novelist Olaf Stapledon, whose 1937 book Star Maker described something similar, and later joked that "Stapledon sphere" would be the fairer name.

A common myth is that Dyson imagined a solid shell around the Sun. He did not. He later said a rigid shell was impossible and that he had in mind a loose swarm of separate objects, each on its own orbit. Engineers now usually call this a Dyson swarm.

The appeal for a resurrection project is raw energy. The Sun pours out more than ten trillion times the power that all of human civilisation uses today. If simulating a single human brain in detail turns out to need staggering amounts of computation, and simulating billions of possible brains even more, then a star-sized power plant is the kind of resource such a plan would assume.

What scientists said about the plan

The experts quoted in 2021 raised two very different objections: one about information, one about people.

Stephen Holler, a physicist at Fordham University in New York, pointed out that a life is shaped by countless small events that were never written down: a remark from a teacher, a bully in the playground, the mood of a particular afternoon. None of that survives in any archive, so any reconstruction would be filling gaps with guesses. He also noted that even a good copy would not stay identical to the original for long; once running, in his words, "it evolves into a different person."

Kelly Smith, a professor of philosophy and biological sciences at Clemson University in South Carolina, focused on the human side. A project on this scale would need the effort of much of humanity over generations, and the people building it would never benefit, nor would their children or grandchildren. Smith doubted that any society would sign up for that.

Stuart Armstrong, then a researcher at the University of Oxford, has addressed the engineering. A rigid sphere would need materials far stronger than anything known to stop it tearing itself apart, which is one reason serious proposals talk about swarms of independent collectors instead.

Has anyone found a Dyson sphere?

Not yet, although astronomers have taken Dyson's suggestion seriously. Searches of infrared survey data, including a Fermilab project, turned up a handful of stars with puzzling infrared excess but nothing confirmed. In 2015 citizen scientists noticed bizarre dimming in KIC 8462852, often called Tabby's Star, and for a while "alien megastructure" headlines were everywhere. Follow-up observations pointed to dust instead.

In 2024 a study known as Project Hephaistos reported seven candidate red dwarf stars within about 1,000 light-years whose light looked unusual in the infrared. The authors themselves were cautious, and other researchers suggested ordinary explanations, such as distant dusty galaxies sitting behind the stars in the images. As of now, there is no evidence that any civilisation has built one.

Would a digital copy really be you?

Even if the energy and data problems were solved, a deeper puzzle would remain. Imagine the simulation produced a being with your memories, your sense of humour and your fears. It would sincerely believe it was you. But you, the person who died, would not experience waking up in it any more than you experience the life of an identical twin.

Philosophers have argued about this for centuries using thought experiments about duplicates, teleporters and gradual brain replacement. Some conclude that psychological continuity is all that matters, so a faithful copy counts as survival. Others think a copy is just a new person who resembles the old one. Turchin's own writing leans towards the first view. Holler's comment about the copy drifting into someone else leans towards the second. Neither side can be settled by building a bigger computer.

There is also an ethical question. A simulated mind that can suffer would presumably deserve moral consideration. Recreating people without their consent, possibly in imperfect or distressing forms, raises issues that no current law anticipates.

More realistic routes to longer lives

Most researchers working on human longevity are not thinking about stars at all. Their work is on cells and bodies: why tissues age, how stem cells could repair damaged organs, and whether drugs can slow the biological processes behind age-related disease. Progress in these areas is real but gradual, and the main goal is usually more healthy years rather than endless life.

It helps to keep the numbers in proportion. The oldest verified human, Jeanne Calment of France, died in 1997 at 122. Some scientists speculate that lifespans of 120 to 150 years could become more common one day, while others argue the human body has a hard limit around where Calment ended up. Either way, that debate is happening in laboratories and clinical trials, not on the drawing board of a megastructure.

For anyone reading about immortality schemes online, a few simple questions help. Is the idea published somewhere it can be checked? Does it rely on technologies that do not exist yet? Who stands to gain from the attention? The Dyson sphere resurrection plan passes the first test only as a thought experiment, fails the second completely, and mostly earns its fame because it is a wonderful story about our oldest wish.

Sources: original reporting by Popular Mechanics; Interesting Engineering: Scientists claim space megastructures could resurrect the dead; Classification of Approaches to Technological Resurrection (PhilPapers record, archived); Wikipedia: Dyson sphere; video: YouTube.

COMMENTS