Cuttlefish Self-Control: The Science Behind the Snack Test

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
A cuttlefish seen against a dark background with arms gathered below its head

A cuttlefish illustrating the species group discussed. This portrait is not a photograph of the delayed-reward apparatus. Source.

Photo: Sepia officinalis. (Schafer & Hill/The Image Bank/Getty Images)

New research into the intelligence of cephalopods, a group of animals that includes squid, octopus and cuttlefish, has revealed specific learning and delayed-reward abilities. In a 2021 study, six common cuttlefish completed a delayed-reward task adapted for their species.

The cuttlefish was exposed to what is known as the 'marshmallow test', which involves examining reasoning and delayed gratification. In the human experiment, a marshmallow is placed in front of a child and told that if they don't eat it for 15 minutes, they will get two marshmallows.

Waiting can demonstrate delayed gratification under the test conditions; performance is not a stand-alone measure of a child’s intelligence or future success.

In the experiment, it was shown that a cuttlefish could be trained to learn that if it didn't eat the food straight away, a less-preferred food, it could obtain a preferred live shrimp after a delay. This supports delayed gratification in the task, rather than establishing human-like future planning.

Alexandra Schnell, the researcher who led the project at the University of Cambridge, said of the findings:

"Cuttlefish in the present study were all able to wait for the better reward and tolerated delays for up to 50-130 seconds, which is comparable to what we see in large-brained vertebrates such as chimpanzees, crows and parrots."

Another part of the experiment involved looking at how good cuttlefish were at learning and adapting. In this experiment, the animals were shown two different visual clues, a circle and a square. If the cuttlefish approached the 'correct' one then they would be rewarded with food. When the researchers switched the shape that would result in the cuttlefish being rewarded with food, the animal was able to soon learn that this change had taken place. This demonstrated reversal learning within the task: the animals could adjust when the rewarded visual cue changed.

Researchers are still investigating why the observed capacity for delayed gratification evolved; the proposed foraging explanation remains a hypothesis. Tool use and complex foraging have been proposed as contexts in which waiting can be useful in some animals; they are not a single established explanation for delayed gratification across species. As far as we are aware, cuttlefish do not use tools of any kind. It is suspected however, that it may be related to the foraging for food and hunting that the cuttlefish engages in.

Schnell added:

"Cuttlefish spend most of their time camouflaging, sitting and waiting, punctuated by brief periods of foraging. They break camouflage when they forage, so they are exposed to every predator in the ocean that wants to eat them. We speculate that delayed gratification may have evolved as a byproduct of this, so the cuttlefish can optimise foraging by waiting to choose better quality food."

The 2021 research was published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B.

[h/t: science alert]

How the choice worked

Researchers led by Alexandra Schnell offered common cuttlefish an immediate food reward and a delayed food they preferred. Transparent chambers let the animals see the alternatives. The preferred live shrimp became accessible only after a wait; taking the immediate option ended the opportunity.

As the delays increased, the animals differed in how long they held out, with the longest reaching 130 seconds. A separate learning task found an association between learning performance and the ability to wait. The University of Cambridge’s account explains the apparatus and the six participating animals.

What counts as evidence of self-control?

A delayed-reward task needs more than an animal ignoring food. Researchers must establish that the food is desirable, that the animal understands the options and that waiting is connected with an obtainable reward. Otherwise, apparent patience might be confusion or a lack of appetite.

The published study examined these conditions through its experimental design. Its conclusion concerns behavior under a particular task, not every decision the species makes in the wild.

The relationship with learning also deserves careful wording. An association in a small sample is not proof that waiting causes better learning—or that every cuttlefish would perform similarly.

A different route to a familiar ability

Cuttlefish are cephalopod mollusks, separated from humans by an enormous evolutionary distance. Finding delayed gratification in such a different animal broadens the questions scientists can ask about how this capacity evolves.

One suggestion is that waiting may fit the demands of their hunting behavior. That is a possible explanation to investigate, rather than something the snack experiment alone demonstrated.

Curious about other ways researchers study animal minds? Meet Alex the African grey parrot, whose work involved labels and concepts, or explore the crow that solved a sequence of tool problems. Each task reveals something specific. Together, they make intelligence a much richer subject than a single league table.

Additional source and image references: A cuttlefish seen against a dark background with arms gathered below its head

COMMENTS