Originally published 2021-03-06.
On 3 March 2021, in Pandeytara village in the Hardoi district of Uttar Pradesh, about 110 km from Lucknow, a man named Sarvesh Kumar killed his 17-year-old daughter with a sharp-edged tool and cut off her head. He then left the village carrying it. Police were alerted and arrested him on the road; some local reports said he was walking to the police station to give himself up. He admitted the killing and told officers he had done it because he objected to her relationship with a young man from the area.
The case drew international attention because a video of his arrest spread online. It is also a stark example of what is often called an “honour killing”, a term that describes the killer’s motive, not any honour in the act.
What police and reporters confirmed
According to The Week, the girl was the eldest of four children. Her father had reportedly seen her with the young man a few days earlier and disapproved of him. The killing took place at the family home in the afternoon, under the jurisdiction of the Majhila police station. The girl’s mother confirmed what had happened, and the body was sent for a post-mortem examination.
Hardoi’s Superintendent of Police, Anurag Vats, confirmed to reporters that Kumar had killed his teenage daughter with a sharp-edged object and had been arrested. CBS News, citing a police video of the confession reported by the BBC, said Kumar described locking the room before attacking her.
A second scandal followed. A photograph circulated showing a policeman inside the station holding the girl’s head by the hair. The superintendent called the officer’s behaviour against humanity and said action had been taken against him immediately; he was removed from duty.
STUPIDITY
— MCGW (@MombasaCGW) March 4, 2021
INDIA-A father calmly carries his daughter’s severed head along streets after beheading her in a so-called “honour killing”. Sarvesh Kumar admitted on video to decapitating the 17-year-old with a sharp tool, as he was very angry about her dating a man he didn't approve. pic.twitter.com/75iepAYFqc
(This post is no longer available on X.)
What an “honour killing” means
An honour killing is the murder of a family member, usually a woman or girl, because relatives believe she has brought shame on the family or community. Human Rights Watch describes these crimes as violence by male relatives against female relatives who are seen to have dishonoured the family, and stresses that the mere perception of dishonour can be enough to trigger an attack.
Amnesty International lists typical “offences” that have cost women their lives: speaking to an unrelated man, refusing a marriage chosen by the family, a pregnancy outside marriage, divorce, accusations of adultery, dressing in a way considered immodest, and even being raped. Men can be victims too, particularly partners of the women involved, but women and girls make up the great majority.
Many journalists and campaigners now put the phrase in quotation marks or write “so-called honour killing”. That is deliberate. Repeating the perpetrator’s justification without comment can make a murder sound like a cultural tradition rather than a crime.
How common are these killings?
The most quoted global figure is that around 5,000 women and girls are killed each year in honour killings. It comes from a United Nations estimate made around 2000 and is still repeated by Amnesty International, but researchers agree it is very rough. Many killings are recorded as suicides, accidents or ordinary murders, and families rarely report a crime committed by their own members.
India illustrates the problem. The National Crime Records Bureau recorded 251 honour killings in 2015 but only 24 in 2019, a drop that activists say reflects how cases are classified rather than a real decline. The Week, citing NCRB data, reported 385 murders in Uttar Pradesh in 2019 linked to love affairs or “honour”, roughly a quarter of the national total in that category. Surveys by women’s groups have found western Uttar Pradesh to be one of the worst-affected areas.
Why they happen
There is no single cause, but some patterns repeat across countries:
- Control of women’s choices. Most cases involve a woman choosing a partner, especially across caste, religion or clan lines, or refusing an arranged marriage.
- Collective pressure. In some rural areas, caste councils known as khap panchayats have been accused of encouraging violence against couples, although scholars disagree about how many killings they directly order.
- Impunity. Where relatives expect sympathy from neighbours or lenient treatment from police, the deterrent is weak.
- Silence inside families. Mothers and siblings may be witnesses but fear the same violence if they speak.
It is important not to blame whole religions or nations. Honour-based violence has been documented in South Asia, the Middle East, North Africa, parts of Europe and in migrant communities worldwide, among people of many faiths and none.
What the law says in India
India has no separate offence of honour killing; such cases are prosecuted as murder under the general criminal law. In 2018, in the case Shakti Vahini v. Union of India, the Supreme Court ruled that adults have the right to choose whom they marry and ordered state governments to take preventive steps, including special cells and safe houses for threatened couples, and to act against village councils that issue threats. Implementation has been uneven, and campaigners continue to call for a dedicated law.
How people at risk can get help
If you or someone you know is threatened by relatives over a relationship or marriage, it is a matter for the police, not a private family matter. In India, the national emergency number 112 and women’s helpline 181 can connect callers with police and support services, and couples can ask courts for protection orders. In the UK, the Forced Marriage Unit and specialist charities offer confidential advice. Friends, teachers and colleagues can help most by taking warning signs seriously and helping the person reach professionals.
The girl in Pandeytara was 17. Her name was largely left out of the reports, but her death belongs to a long list of young women killed for exercising a choice the law already gave them.
Sources: The Week (4 March 2021); CBS News (4 March 2021); Wikipedia: Honor killing; Wikipedia: Honour killing in India.

COMMENTS