Originally published 2021-03-07.

Photo: Splash News
In late February 2021, some of Venice's canals were left almost empty. The water level in the lagoon fell to about 48 centimetres below normal on Friday, February 26, according to WION and other reports, leaving gondolas and small boats resting on mud and exposing the canal beds in quieter parts of the city. It was a striking sight for a place better known for floods, and it came only 15 months after Venice suffered one of the worst high tides in its recorded history.
Both extremes have the same root: Venice sits in a shallow lagoon where water rises and falls with tides, weather and the slow sinking of the land. Here is what happened, why, and what it does and does not tell us about the city's future.
What happened in February 2021
Venetians have a name for very low water: acqua bassa, the opposite of the better-known acqua alta. During the February 2021 episode the narrower canals, which are only a metre or two deep at the best of times, emptied enough for residents to photograph boats tilted on the bottom. Delivery boats and water taxis had to work around the shallows, and some side canals became impassable for a while.
Low-water episodes of this kind are typically linked to a combination of factors: a naturally low point in the tidal cycle, high atmospheric pressure pressing on the sea surface, and winds that push water out of the lagoon towards the Adriatic. They tend to last hours or days rather than weeks, and normal levels return once the weather pattern shifts.
The flood that came before
The contrast with November 2019 explains why the images spread so widely. On November 12, 2019 the tide in Venice reached 187 centimetres, the highest level in more than five decades and second only to the great flood of 1966. About 85 percent of the city ended up underwater. Shops, hotels and homes were damaged, boats were thrown onto the pavements, and Venetians spent days pumping water out of ground floors.
St Mark's Basilica, the city's most famous church, was flooded again. Basilica officials said at the time that it had been inundated only six times in roughly 1,200 years, with several of those events in recent decades. Salt water is especially harmful to its marble, mosaics and crypt.
Mayor Luigi Brugnaro asked Rome for emergency help during that 2019 flood and blamed the warming climate. "This is the result of climate change," he said. Note that this comment referred to the 2019 floods, not to the later low-water event, a mix-up that appeared in some reports.
Why Venice floods and drains
Venice is built on more than a hundred small islands in a saltwater lagoon, connected to the sea by three inlets at Lido, Malamocco and Chioggia. Water moves in and out through those gaps twice a day. Two long-term trends make extremes harder to live with:
- Subsidence. The ground beneath the city has sunk over the past century, partly because groundwater was pumped out for industry until the practice was stopped.
- Sea-level rise. The Adriatic, like the world's oceans, is slowly rising as the planet warms.
Together, these mean towns in the lagoon sit on average about 23 centimetres lower relative to the water than in the early 1900s. A tide that once wetted St Mark's Square only occasionally now does so far more often.
The MOSE flood barrier
Venice's main defence is MOSE, a system of 78 mobile gates set into the seabed at the three lagoon inlets. Normally the gates lie flat and full of water. When a high tide is forecast, compressed air pushes the water out and the gates swing up, sealing the lagoon off from the sea for several hours.
Construction began in 2003, far earlier than some reports suggest, and the project has cost around 5.5 billion euros. It was hit by delays and by a 2014 corruption scandal that led to dozens of arrests, including the then mayor. The gates were raised against a real high tide for the first time on October 3, 2020, and they kept the city dry that day.
MOSE is not a permanent fix. It was designed for about 60 centimetres of sea-level rise, and the IPCC's higher-emission projections go beyond that by 2100. Critics also worry that closing the lagoon very often could harm its water quality and ecology.
Does a dry canal disprove sea-level rise?
No. A few days of very low water show how much short-term weather can move the lagoon, but they say nothing about the long-term average. Sea level is measured over years and decades, and that average has been climbing. A useful comparison always notes the date, the tide reference and the weather conditions behind each reading.
The fair conclusion is that Venice lives with a wide and growing range of water levels. Floods and dry spells are both part of the same fragile system, and managing it will take barriers, careful lagoon management and global action on emissions.
If you are visiting Venice
- Check the city's tide forecasts before your trip; high-water warnings are issued in advance.
- Raised walkways go up on the busiest routes during acqua alta, and many shops sell temporary boots.
- Low water can disrupt some boat routes for a few hours, so allow extra time for transfers.
Sources: WION (February 27, 2021); Wikipedia: MOSE; photo by Splash News.

COMMENTS