The Crow That Solved a Tool Puzzle: What to Watch For

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

The reward is out of reach, and the first tool is not enough. A crow has to solve smaller problems before it can solve the one it actually cares about. Watching the sequence unfold is part puzzle, part lesson in paying attention.

A crow manipulates a small object during a staged tool-use task
The crow 007 faces the apparatus in the BBC demonstration. The green arrow highlights part of the scene for viewers; the sticks, stones and food reward belong to the task itself. Source.

The bird, nicknamed 007, appeared in a demonstration with researcher Alex Taylor for the BBC’s Inside the Animal Mind. The original BBC clip presents a task commonly described as an eight-step puzzle, involving objects that help the bird obtain other useful objects before reaching food.

The interesting part is the intermediate goal

A tool can have value even when it does not immediately deliver a snack. If it helps obtain a longer tool, for example, its usefulness depends on a relationship between two stages of the problem.

That is what makes a multi-step demonstration worth watching slowly. Follow what each action makes possible next. The impressive feature is not simply speed; it is the connection between an action now and an opportunity later.

The route to the reward involves stones and sticks: intermediate objects help the bird obtain a tool capable of reaching the food. BBC Earth’s account identifies 007’s successful sequence as eight separate stages. The individual tasks and their combination test different things. Familiarity with an object can help a bird use it, while bringing several actions together requires those familiar pieces to work in a new sequence. The bird’s previous experience therefore matters when interpreting its performance.

Ben Tracy’s 2015 CBS report discussed American crows and gave a U.S. population estimate of more than 30 million. That provides background on a different crow population: 007 is a New Caledonian crow, the species shown solving the tool puzzle. A large population count says little about an individual animal’s ability to solve this particular task. CBS News: crow intelligence A thumb-sized-brain analogy is also no substitute for a defined cognitive test, and a successful tool task does not establish a single intelligence ranking shared by birds and primates.

Prior experience belongs in the story

A filmed demonstration is not evidence that a wild bird encountered every component for the first time. Familiarity with individual objects or actions can be important even when the complete sequence presents a new challenge.

Rather than treating “trained” and “intelligent” as opposites, ask what was learned beforehand and what had to be combined during the task. Learning is itself part of animal cognition. The research question is which explanation best accounts for the observed behavior.

Try a careful viewing

  1. Identify the final reward and why the crow cannot reach it directly.
  2. Pause after each action and name the new possibility it creates.
  3. Separate what the video shows from what commentary tells you about earlier experience.
  4. Look for the researcher’s explanation before drawing a conclusion about planning or insight.

New Caledonian crows are important subjects in the study of tool use. That does not make one successful clip a universal test of intelligence, nor does it assign the species a human mental age.

The enjoyment survives a careful explanation. A small black bird manipulating a difficult arrangement of objects is already a remarkable sight.

Compare this task with Alex the parrot’s work with labels and concepts or the delayed-reward choice offered to cuttlefish. The animals face different problems, and the evidence becomes clearer when those differences stay visible.

Video and posts

Earlier sources and credits: Simple Capacity.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1
  1. Black birds are awesome. We had a few near my employer. They would scavenge around flipping over leafs, and rocks, looking for bugs. A few grasshoppers caught their eyes. they would catch one in their beaks, hop on over to a small pond, and dip the grasshoppers in the water, and then eat them. They are fun to watch ...

    ReplyDelete