Why the US and Ukraine Opposed Russia's UN Resolution on Nazism

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-12-18.

The 2020 UN Vote on Russia's Anti-Nazism Resolution

Photo: Members of the Azov unit, which was founded by far-right nationalists in 2014, at Independence Day events in Kyiv, Ukraine, 24 August 2020 © Reuters / Gleb Garanich

On 16 December 2020 the UN General Assembly adopted resolution A/RES/75/169, a Russian-sponsored text on combating the glorification of Nazism and neo-Nazism, by 130 votes to 2, with 51 abstentions. The two votes against came from the United States and Ukraine. Every member state of the European Union, including Germany, Italy and France, abstained, and reports at the time said the United Kingdom did too.

Headlines that "the US and Ukraine voted against condemning Nazism" spread quickly. The real story is more complicated: both countries said they condemn Nazism, but objected to how Russia had written and used the resolution. This article sets out what the text said, the reasons given for each vote, and the facts behind the claims about the far right in Ukraine.

What the resolution asked for

Russia has tabled a version of this resolution every year for well over a decade. The 2020 text urged states to fight the glorification of the Nazi movement, neo-Nazism and former members of the Waffen-SS, including through memorials and public demonstrations, and to counter what it called revisionism about the Second World War. It also linked these practices to racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, and called on states to work towards eliminating all forms of racial discrimination.

On its face, the goal is hard to argue with. That is precisely why the votes against it attracted so much attention, and why the reasons behind them matter.

How the vote broke down

The text first passed the General Assembly's Third Committee, which handles human rights, on 18 November 2020 by 122 votes to 2 with 53 abstentions. The full Assembly then adopted it in December. In both votes the US and Ukraine were the only countries voting no.

The large bloc of abstentions is easy to overlook. More than 50 countries, mostly European democracies with strict laws against Holocaust denial and hate speech, chose not to support the text. The EU has explained in earlier years that it abstains because Russia uses the resolution to push its own version of history and to attack neighbours, including by presenting its actions in Ukraine as a fight against Nazism.

Why the United States voted no

The US has voted against this resolution for years and gives two main reasons.

The first is free speech. The First Amendment of the US Constitution protects even offensive and hateful speech, including Nazi symbols and ideas, unless it amounts to incitement or true threats. Washington argues that the resolution's calls to restrict speech and demonstrations go further than it can accept, and it said its proposed changes to protect free expression were ignored.

The second is politics. At the Third Committee in November 2020, the US delegate described the resolution as an attempt to legitimise long-standing Russian disinformation narratives that smear neighbouring nations. In other words, the US objected less to the stated aim than to its use as a diplomatic weapon.

Why Ukraine voted no

Ukraine's delegate told the same meeting that his country condemns Nazism but saw the text as an attempt by its main sponsor to manipulate history. Ukraine objected in particular to language about Soviet-era monuments and the 1939 Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact, the agreement between Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union that divided Eastern Europe, which it argued had nothing to do with combating Nazism.

The context was the conflict that began in 2014. That year Russia annexed Crimea, and Russian-backed separatists took control of parts of Donetsk and Luhansk in the Donbas. Ukraine and Western governments said Russian troops were directly involved, which Moscow denied at the time. Russian officials had for years described Ukraine's government as dominated by "neo-Nazis", a claim Kyiv saw as propaganda, and one Russia later used to justify its full-scale invasion in February 2022.

The far right in Ukraine: what the facts show

Russia argued that Ukraine voted no because it tolerates neo-Nazi groups. There is a real issue here, but it is often exaggerated.

The Azov Battalion was formed in May 2014 as a volunteer militia led by Andriy Biletsky, growing out of far-right and ultra-nationalist circles, and it has been criticised for neo-Nazi ideology and symbols. In November 2014 it was absorbed into Ukraine's National Guard. Some experts say it was later vetted and largely depoliticised; others argue it kept links to the far-right Azov political movement. Claims that it received US weapons and training were contested for years, and the US Congress repeatedly debated restrictions on aid to the unit.

At the ballot box, the far right is small. In the 2019 parliamentary election a joint nationalist list led by Svoboda won about 2.2 per cent of the national vote, below the 5 per cent threshold, and Svoboda ended up with a single seat out of 450, won in a constituency. The same election gave President Volodymyr Zelensky's Servant of the People party an outright majority. Zelensky himself is Jewish.

Far-right volunteers also fought on the separatist side in the Donbas, including Russian nationalist groups, so extremism was not confined to one side of the conflict.

The Second World War history behind the dispute

History explains why the subject is so charged. During the German occupation of Ukraine some nationalists collaborated with the Nazis. The Ukrainian Auxiliary Police, set up by the Germans in 1941 and numbering more than 35,000 men, took part in rounding up Jews, guarding ghettos and in massacres such as Babi Yar near Kyiv. Members of the Organisation of Ukrainian Nationalists were prominent in its ranks in some regions.

At the same time, millions of Ukrainians fought in the Soviet Red Army against Germany, and Ukraine suffered some of the heaviest civilian losses of the war. The Soviet Union, which included both Russia and Ukraine until 1991, often used the record of collaborators to brand Ukrainian national identity as a whole as fascist, a tactic modern Russian rhetoric echoes.

How to read votes like this

UN resolutions often carry titles that almost no one could oppose. A vote against one does not automatically mean support for the opposite. To understand it, check the full text, the explanation of vote each country gives, and who abstained and why. In this case, the record shows two governments that say they reject Nazism, a large group of democracies unwilling to back the text, and a sponsor whose own later use of "denazification" as a war aim gave their objections new weight.

Sources: UN Digital Library: A/RES/75/169 and voting record; UN Third Committee summary record A/C.3/75/SR.12, 18 November 2020; Lithuanian mission to the UN on the EU's abstention; Azov Brigade (Wikipedia); 2019 Ukrainian parliamentary election (Wikipedia); Ukrainian Auxiliary Police (Wikipedia).

COMMENTS