Originally published 2020-12-18.

At his annual end-of-year press conference on 17 December 2020, Russian President Vladimir Putin told reporters that "multiculturalism has failed" in the West. He was answering a question from an RT correspondent about the wave of violence in France that autumn, and he framed the problem as a clash between free expression and respect for religious believers.
Putin did not, as many headlines claimed at the time, say in so many words that militant Islam was an existential threat to the West. That phrase came from commentary around the remarks, not from his own answer. What he did say was narrower, and more revealing about how the Kremlin likes to present itself abroad.
What Putin actually said
Asked about the killings in France, Putin talked about where one person's freedom ends and another's begins. People who mock the faith of others, he argued, should expect that there will be "an inevitable backlash", though he added that this reaction should not be an aggressive one. He then pointed to the French attacks as evidence that the Western model of living side by side without a shared culture had not worked.
The answer fitted a wider push. About a week earlier, he had instructed Russia's Foreign Ministry to raise, through international organisations, the question of insults to religious belief and the stirring up of hatred between faiths. According to RT's report of the press conference, officials were told to come back with their plans by early March 2021.
So the core message was not a security warning. It was a political argument: liberal Western societies, in Putin's telling, protect offensive speech too much and pay the price in social conflict.
The French attacks behind the question
The question came two months after one of the most shocking crimes in recent French history. On 16 October 2020, history and geography teacher Samuel Paty was murdered and beheaded near his school in Éragny, outside Paris. In a civics class on freedom of expression, he had shown cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad that had been published by Charlie Hebdo, after offering pupils who might be offended the chance to look away.
His killer, 18-year-old Abdoullakh Anzorov, was born in Moscow to a Chechen family and had come to France as a child; the family had been granted refugee status (source). Police shot him dead minutes after the attack. An online campaign against the teacher, partly based on a pupil's account of a lesson she had not actually attended, preceded the murder.
On 29 October 2020, a 21-year-old Tunisian man who had recently arrived in Europe through the Italian island of Lampedusa killed three people inside the Notre-Dame basilica in Nice. Some early reports spoke of two victims outside the church; in fact all three died in or at the basilica.
The Chechen link gave the story an extra dimension in Russia. Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov condemned the murder but also urged people not to provoke believers, an argument close to the one Putin went on to make.
Macron, Mahathir and the global backlash
French President Emmanuel Macron called the Paty killing a typical Islamist terrorist attack and said the teacher had been killed for teaching children about free speech. He defended the right to publish caricatures and pressed ahead with plans against what he called Islamist separatism, describing communities living apart from the secular values of the Republic. Our earlier report looked at a poll on the views of young French Muslims that fed into that debate.
His stance triggered protests and calls to boycott French goods in several Muslim-majority countries. The most extreme reaction from a political figure came from Mahathir Mohamad, the former prime minister of Malaysia. On the day of the Nice attack he wrote that "Muslims have a right to be angry and to kill millions of French people for the massacres of the past." Twitter removed the post for glorifying violence, according to Al Arabiya. Mahathir later said his words had been taken out of context; in the same thread he said he did not approve of the beheading.
Putin is not the first leader to say it
The phrase "multiculturalism has failed" was not new in European politics. In October 2010 German Chancellor Angela Merkel told young members of her party that the attempt to build a multicultural society in Germany had utterly failed, adding that simply living side by side was not enough. In February 2011 British Prime Minister David Cameron said in a speech in Munich that state multiculturalism had failed, and French President Nicolas Sarkozy voiced similar doubts the same year (source).
Those leaders, though, were talking about their own integration policies: language, schooling, shared civic values. They argued for more integration, not for limits on speech. Putin's version took the same slogan and used it to argue that Western freedoms themselves were the problem, a very different claim.
It is also worth separating two meanings of the word. Multiculturalism as a fact simply means that a society contains many cultures, which describes Russia, a federation of more than a hundred ethnic groups, as much as France. Multiculturalism as a policy means the state actively supports separate community identities. Critics who say it "failed" usually mean the policy, not the fact of diversity.
Russia's own record on speech and religion
Many in the West dismissed Putin's sudden concern for religious feelings and minority rights as hypocritical. Russia passed a law in 2013 making it a crime to insult the religious feelings of believers, introduced after a protest that drew worldwide attention.
In February 2012 members of the feminist punk group Pussy Riot staged a brief performance against Putin inside Moscow's Cathedral of Christ the Saviour. Three were convicted of hooliganism motivated by religious hatred and sentenced to two years; one was freed on appeal, while Maria Alyokhina and Nadezhda Tolokonnikova served most of their terms before an amnesty in December 2013 (source).
Western governments and international observers have also repeatedly criticised Russian elections as unfair, and accused the Kremlin of jailing opponents and shutting down independent media. Against that background, a call for global rules on "insulting believers" looked to critics less like a defence of minorities and more like a way to export Russia's restrictions on speech.
How to read remarks like these
Comments like Putin's are best read as political messaging rather than analysis. A few points help put them in proportion:
- Check the exact words. The viral version of this story attributed to Putin a line about an existential threat from militant Islam that he did not say at the press conference.
- Separate the crime from the community. The Paty and Nice attacks were carried out by individuals. They do not show that a religious group as a whole is a danger, and major French Muslim organisations condemned them.
- Ask who benefits. Presenting Western democracies as chaotic and divided is a long-running theme in Russian state media, aimed at audiences at home and abroad.
- Look at the policy debate itself. Integration, free speech and religious respect are genuine questions that democracies argue about openly. That open argument is part of what distinguishes them from systems where criticising the leader or the church can land you in prison.
The underlying tension Putin pointed to is real: open societies have to decide how to protect both free expression and the safety of religious minorities. But the answer European democracies have mostly reached is to defend the right to offend while prosecuting violence, not to make insult a crime.
Sources: RT, 17 December 2020: report of Putin's press conference remarks; Wikipedia: Murder of Samuel Paty; Wikipedia: 2020 Nice stabbing; Al Arabiya, 30 October 2020: Twitter removes Mahathir's tweet; Wikipedia: Multiculturalism; Wikipedia: Pussy Riot.

COMMENTS