Peter Nygård: Sex-Trafficking Arrest and Toronto Conviction

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-12-18.

Peter Nygård's Arrest on Sex-Trafficking Charges in 2020

Canadian fashion executive Peter Nygård was arrested in Winnipeg in mid-December 2020 at the request of the United States, where prosecutors in New York had charged him with sex trafficking and racketeering. He was 79 at the time and denied the allegations. His first criminal conviction came later, in Canada: in November 2023 a Toronto jury found him guilty of sexually assaulting four women, and in September 2024 he was sentenced to 11 years in prison.

This article sets out who Nygård is, what the US indictment alleged, how earlier accusations had surfaced over several decades, and where the cases stood at the latest reports we could verify. Allegations that have not been tested in court are described as allegations.

Who is Peter Nygård?

Nygård was born Pekka Juhani Nygård in Helsinki, Finland, in 1941. His family emigrated to Canada when he was a boy and settled in Manitoba. After studying at the University of North Dakota, he built a women's clothing business in Winnipeg from 1967 that grew into Nygård International, with stores, factories and offices in Canada and the United States.

He was known for a flamboyant lifestyle, including a large estate at Lyford Cay in the Bahamas, often called Nygård Cay. The property was the backdrop for many of the parties later described in court filings. His long legal fight with a billionaire neighbour in the Bahamas also brought him a 2019 contempt ruling there, which included a short jail sentence and a fine for breaching a court order.

The US charges

The New York indictment, unsealed after his arrest, charged Nygård with nine counts, including sex trafficking and racketeering conspiracy. Prosecutors alleged that over about 25 years he used his companies, employees and wealth to recruit and abuse dozens of women and girls in the United States, Canada and the Bahamas.

According to the charges, some victims were as young as 14 and many came from poor or vulnerable backgrounds. The indictment alleged that they were lured with promises of modelling work or financial help, that some were drugged, and that so-called "pamper parties" at his homes were used to recruit them. Prosecutors also alleged that he used intimidation, payments and lawsuits to silence accusers. Nygård has denied wrongdoing, and the US case has not been tried.

His arrest came about ten months after the FBI and police searched his company's New York headquarters in February 2020. Soon afterwards, Nygård announced he would step down, and several of his companies were placed into receivership in Canada.

Accusations over several decades

Before 2020, Nygård had never been convicted of a sexual offence, but allegations had followed him for years:

  • 1980: a young woman in Winnipeg accused him of rape. He was not convicted, and it has been reported that he later paid her compensation.
  • 2005: the Finnish tabloid Iltalehti published claims about parties at his Bahamas home, including brief comments from actress Jessica Alba, who reportedly said she left a party after being made uncomfortable by what she saw. Nygård sued the paper's owner for slander in Los Angeles and lost.
  • February 2020: ten women filed a class-action lawsuit in New York, alleging they had been assaulted as part of a trafficking scheme, some when they were 14 or 15. The number of plaintiffs later grew to 57. The civil case was paused at the US government's request while the criminal investigation continued.
  • August 2020: two of his sons filed a lawsuit alleging that he had arranged for them to be sexually assaulted when they were teenagers.

The day after his arrest, Global News in Winnipeg reported that his eldest son said he was relieved his father was in custody.

The Epstein comparisons

Coverage of the arrest often mentioned Jeffrey Epstein, the financier who died in a New York jail in August 2019 while awaiting trial on federal sex-trafficking charges. The two men moved in wealthy circles, and the accusations against both involved recruiting young women and girls through money, promises of opportunity and private island properties. Some reports described them as acquaintances or friends, but no court has linked Nygård's alleged crimes to Epstein's.

Epstein's death continues to fuel speculation, and polls show many Americans believe he was murdered. The official findings point the other way. New York City's chief medical examiner ruled the death a suicide by hanging. A June 2023 report by the Justice Department's inspector general sharply criticised jail staff for negligence and misconduct but found nothing to contradict the conclusion that he took his own life, and a 2025 Justice Department review reached the same view.

Extradition, the Toronto trial and the sentence

Nygård was refused bail in early 2021. In October 2021 he agreed to be extradited to the United States, but Canadian proceedings came first. On the same day, Toronto police charged him with sexual assault and forcible confinement involving several women.

The Toronto trial lasted about six weeks. In November 2023 the jury convicted him on four counts of sexual assault and acquitted him on a fifth count and on a charge of forcible confinement. Sentencing him in September 2024, Justice Robert Goldstein called him a "sexual predator" and imposed 11 years. After credit for time already spent in custody, the remaining term was just under seven years. Nygård, then 83, continued to deny all the allegations.

At the time of sentencing, he still faced the nine US counts in New York and a separate sexual assault case in Montreal. Reports also referred to charges in Winnipeg, although Winnipeg police had said in late 2021 that they would not lay charges after their own investigation. We could not verify later outcomes in these cases, so check current news reports for the latest status.

Why the case matters

The case followed a pattern familiar from other abuse scandals involving powerful men: complaints spread over decades, private settlements and lawsuits that discouraged accusers, and investigations that moved only when many people spoke out together. The 2020 class action, and the women who came forward through it, put pressure on authorities to act.

It also shows how slow cross-border justice can be. Allegations covered three countries, each with its own police, courts and extradition rules, and Canadian cases had to be resolved before any US trial could begin.

If you or someone you know has been affected by sexual violence, local support services and police can help. In Canada and the US, national hotlines offer confidential advice at any hour.

Sources: Global Winnipeg report, 16 December 2020; ABC News / Associated Press: Nygård sentenced to 11 years; Wikipedia: Peter Nygard; Wikipedia: Death of Jeffrey Epstein.

COMMENTS