Originally published 2020-10-27.
In October 2020 Turkey switched on and test-fired the Russian S-400 air defence system it had bought for about $2.5 billion, ignoring repeated warnings from Washington and NATO allies. The Pentagon said it condemned the 16 October test in the strongest possible terms
, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan replied that US objections did not concern Ankara, and on 14 December 2020 the United States imposed sanctions on Turkey's defence procurement agency.

An S-400 launcher on display at Patriot Park in Kubinka, outside Moscow (photo credit: Alexander Nemenov / AFP / Getty Images).
Below we explain what the S-400 is, why a NATO member buying it caused such alarm, how the dispute escalated, and where it left Turkey's place in the alliance.
What the S-400 is
The S-400 Triumf is a mobile, long-range surface-to-air missile system built by Russia's Almaz-Antey group. It entered Russian service in 2007 and is designed to shoot down aircraft, cruise missiles and some ballistic missiles. Its radars can reportedly detect targets up to about 600 km away, and its longest-range interceptor, the 40N6, has a claimed reach of around 400 km.
For a country worried about air attacks, those are attractive numbers. For NATO, the problem is not the missiles themselves but the system's radars and data links, and what they could learn about allied aircraft.
From deal to delivery
Turkey and Russia signed the agreement in late 2017. Turkish officials said they turned to Moscow after years of failing to secure an acceptable deal for the American Patriot system, including on technology transfer. Washington, for its part, offered Patriots as an alternative and urged Ankara to walk away from the Russian purchase.
The first components arrived at an air base near Ankara on 12 July 2019. By 2020, according to published estimates, four batteries had been delivered. Turkey insisted the purchase was a sovereign decision, and that it was entitled to buy whatever it judged best for its security.
Why the US and NATO objected
Turkey has been a NATO member since 1952 and hosts important allied facilities, including Incirlik Air Base. Allies feared that operating a Russian system alongside NATO equipment could expose sensitive data, in particular about the F-35 stealth fighter, which Turkey had helped build and planned to fly. US officials summed up the concern by saying the F-35 could not coexist with a Russian intelligence collection platform.
The other worry was interoperability. NATO air defence relies on shared networks. A Russian system cannot simply be plugged into them, and allowing it to operate near allied aircraft raised questions about who might gain access to its data.
The October 2020 test and Erdoğan's defiance
Within days of the first deliveries in July 2019, the United States suspended Turkey from the F-35 programme, cutting it out of both purchases and the supply chain. Congress later wrote into law that F-35s could not be transferred to Turkey while it possessed the S-400.
Turkey nevertheless went ahead with live testing. The firing on 16 October 2020 was reportedly carried out near Sinop on the Black Sea coast. Pentagon spokesman Jonathan Hoffman warned that it risked serious consequences for the security relationship.
Erdoğan confirmed the test on 23 October and struck a defiant tone, telling Washington to go ahead with sanctions if it wanted. He complained that Turkey had paid for F-35 jets that were never delivered and said Ankara would not consult the US on testing weapons it already owned. The exchange came at a tense moment, with Turkey also at odds with Greece and France in the eastern Mediterranean and backing Azerbaijan in the war over Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) with Armenia.
The CAATSA sanctions
On 14 December 2020 the Trump administration imposed sanctions under the Countering America's Adversaries Through Sanctions Act (CAATSA), a 2017 law aimed at countries doing major arms business with Russia. It was the first time CAATSA had been used against a NATO ally.
The penalties targeted the Presidency of Defence Industries, known as SSB, rather than the Turkish economy as a whole. According to the Congressional Research Service, they banned specific US export licences to the agency, limited US bank loans to it, barred US Export-Import Bank help and imposed asset freezes and visa bans on four SSB officials. Congress had also been preparing its own requirement for sanctions in that year's defence budget bill.
Turkey's long balancing act
The S-400 row did not come out of nowhere. Turkey has often pursued its own path inside NATO. In 1974 it invaded Cyprus after a coup backed by the military junta then ruling Greece, and Turkish troops have occupied the northern third of the island ever since. Cyprus is not a NATO member, but the invasion set Turkey against its NATO neighbour Greece for decades. Ankara also launched a military operation in north-eastern Syria in 2019 and was under an informal Saudi boycott of Turkish goods when the S-400 test happened, as we covered in our report on the Saudi embargo on Turkish goods.
At the same time, Turkey remains a valuable ally with NATO's second-largest army and control of the straits linking the Black Sea to the Mediterranean. That leverage became clear again in 2022, when it used its veto power over Finland's and Sweden's NATO bids to extract concessions, a story covered in the related reading below.
Relations did thaw in other areas. After Turkey ratified Sweden's NATO membership in early 2024, the United States approved the sale of new F-16 fighters and upgrade kits to Ankara, a sign that both sides wanted to limit the damage even while the S-400 question stayed unresolved.
The S-400 systems have stayed in Turkish hands, Turkey remains outside the F-35 programme, and the dispute continues to shape its relations with Washington. It is a reminder that alliance membership does not guarantee alliance unity.
Sources: Wikipedia: S-400 missile system; VOA, 23 October 2020; Congressional Research Service, December 2020; Sputnik, 25 October 2020 (Erdoğan remarks). Photo: Alexander Nemenov / AFP / Getty Images.

COMMENTS