Originally published 2020-10-27.
A still from hidden-camera footage released by the activist group then known as Aussie Farms, showing young goats in a trailer on a dairy goat farm at Trafalgar, Victoria.
Hidden-camera footage published by the Australian animal rights group Aussie Farms showed a worker on a dairy goat farm in Victoria shooting newborn male goats, reportedly around ten of them, and discarding their bodies. The farm was in Trafalgar, in Gippsland, and the investigation was filmed in 2019. Killing unwanted male kids is a routine and lawful part of dairy farming in Australia, provided it is done humanely, which is why no prosecution followed. The video was released to show consumers a side of goat milk production most of them never see.
This page explains why dairy farms end up with male kids they do not want, what Australian rules say about killing them, how the activist group behind the footage operates, and what the political response in Victoria actually was.
Why dairy farms have surplus male kids
Goats, like cows and humans, only produce milk after giving birth. To keep a dairy herd in milk, does are bred regularly, and roughly half of the kids born are male. Females can be raised to join the milking herd. Males cannot produce milk, and a farm needs only a handful of breeding bucks.
That leaves the farmer with a choice for every male kid: raise it for meat, sell it to someone who will, or kill it soon after birth. Raising kids takes milk, feed, labour and shelter, and on many farms the meat price has not covered those costs. Where that is the case, male kids are often killed within days of birth. The same economic pressure exists in the dairy cattle industry, where unwanted calves are known as "bobby calves".
Chris Delforce, who ran Aussie Farms, summed up the activists' view bluntly when he spoke to Truth Theory: "The baby males are considered a waste product." His argument was that the practice is built into dairy production, not an exception on one farm.
Is it legal? What the rules say
Yes, within limits. In Australia, animal welfare is regulated by each state. In Victoria the main law is the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1986, together with codes of practice. Killing farm animals is lawful when it is done in a way that causes a quick death without unnecessary pain. A correctly placed gunshot from a suitable firearm, at close range, is one of the accepted methods for young livestock.
The industry-developed Australian Animal Welfare Standards and Guidelines for Goats describe expected practice for goat farms, including how unwanted animals should be humanely killed. These national standards are meant to replace a model code from 1991, but they have not yet been endorsed into law, so for now they are guidance rather than enforceable rules in most states.
In short, describing the killings as "perfectly legal", as many headlines did, is broadly accurate if each animal was killed quickly and humanely. Whether that happened in every case on the footage is the question critics raised, and it is one the video alone cannot fully settle.
Who made the footage
Aussie Farms was founded by Chris Delforce, who also made the 2018 documentary Dominion about Australian animal agriculture. The group specialises in collecting and publishing footage from farms, abattoirs and similar sites, often filmed with hidden cameras.
In early 2019 the group published an online map of thousands of Australian farms and animal facilities. Farmers and governments condemned it, saying it exposed families to trespass and harassment. In November 2019 the group's charity status was revoked. It later renamed itself the Farm Transparency Project, keeping the same leadership and aims. The video embedded below is now published on the Farm Transparency Project's Vimeo channel.
Cibus Goats, Trafalgar VIC 2019 (full investigation) from Farm Transparency Project on Vimeo
The full investigation, titled "Cibus Goats, Trafalgar VIC 2019", is published by the Farm Transparency Project. It contains footage of animals being killed.
What the Victorian inquiry actually examined
Some reports linked this video to Victoria's inquiry into animal activism, as if the inquiry had been set up in response to it. The timeline does not support that. The Victorian Legislative Council referred its Inquiry into the Impact of Animal Rights Activism on Victorian Agriculture to its Economy and Infrastructure Committee on 1 May 2019. The background was a wave of farm trespasses and protests across Australia, the farm map, and incidents at a Gippsland goat dairy and café, not this specific film.
The committee's report, published in February 2020, made 15 recommendations. It found that trespass caused real distress to farming families and posed biosecurity risks, and recommended new offences and on-the-spot fines for people who ignore farm biosecurity plans. It also concluded that trespassing to gather information could not be considered whistleblowing.
The report was not only about activists, though. It recommended modernising the 1986 animal cruelty law as a priority, supporting a national Australian Commission for Animal Welfare, considering mandatory CCTV in Victorian abattoirs, and reviewing practices such as blunt force trauma for killing young animals. Farm groups gave it a mixed reception, and opposition MPs said it did too little to protect farmers.
Andy Meddick, then the Animal Justice Party's member in Victoria's upper house, criticised the direction of the inquiry. Treating activists as the problem, he argued, was "the thin edge of the wedge" for whistleblowers in other industries, and he pointed to royal commissions into aged care and banking that relied on insiders speaking out.
How the industry is responding
Goat dairy is a small sector in Australia compared with cattle dairy, but it faces the same questions about surplus young animals. Approaches that some farms and countries use include raising male kids for meat (sold as capretto or kid goat), contract rearing, and selling kids to hobby farmers.
For consumers, the practical takeaway is that milk from any mammal involves births, and the fate of the male offspring is part of the real cost. Some brands now state on their packaging or websites what happens to male kids, and asking a producer directly is a reasonable step if this matters to you.
Why footage like this keeps surfacing
Undercover video is the main tool animal rights groups use to put farm practices in front of the public, and governments in several Australian states have responded with tougher trespass penalties. The federal Criminal Code Amendment (Agricultural Protection) Act 2019 also created offences for using a carriage service, such as a website, to incite trespass on agricultural land.
That leaves two arguments running side by side. Farmers say they have a right to privacy and safety on their own land, and that most of what activists film is lawful. Activists answer that lawful does not mean acceptable, and that the public would never see these practices without hidden cameras. Both sides agree on one thing: most people buying goat cheese or milk have never thought about the male kids.
Sources: Parliament of Victoria, Inquiry into the Impact of Animal Activism on Victorian Agriculture (2020); Animal Welfare Standards and Guidelines: Goats; Stock & Land: Aussie Farms renames itself; video and still: Farm Transparency Project.


COMMENTS