Originally published 2020-10-02.

In August 2020 a video from Pakistan's Khyber district showed a crowd of men and boys running across a hillside and tearing up young saplings that had just been planted for the government's Ten Billion Tree Tsunami. Online, the clip was quickly framed as religious extremists attacking a green project. The real cause was more ordinary and more instructive: a dispute over who owned the land. Local officials said one tribe had agreed to the planting while a rival group, which claimed the same ground, had not. After mediation the trees were planted again.
Here is what happened, why the first interpretations were wrong, and what the episode says about large tree-planting campaigns.
What happened in Khyber
On 9 August 2020 Prime Minister Imran Khan launched a nationwide planting day under the Ten Billion Tree programme, with a target of about 3.5 million saplings in a single day. Volunteers from the ruling party's Tiger Force youth wing and local officials took part across the country.
In the Mandi Kas area of Khyber district, close to the historic Khyber Pass on the road to Afghanistan, a planting had been organised by a local Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) politician, Iqbal Afridi. Shortly afterwards, a large group of local men arrived and pulled the saplings out of the ground. Reports said some district officials and volunteers were also confronted. The footage spread rapidly on social media.
The real reason: a land dispute
Within a day, local officials explained what lay behind the scene. Two tribes disputed ownership of the land. One side had attended the launch and given its consent; the other had not been consulted and saw the planting as a government move to take over its property. Khyber's deputy commissioner, Mahmood Aslam, summed it up for The News:
"One of the groups gave permission for the plantation drive; the other uprooted them."
Afridi himself acknowledged that the trees had been planted on private land, and Pakistani media described the anger as a reaction to what locals called forceful planting on land they owned. In the former tribal areas, where land is often held collectively by clans and boundaries are not always recorded in official registers, such disputes are common and can turn violent quickly.
How it was resolved
The provincial government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa took notice, and the district administration mediated between the parties. Under the settlement, those involved agreed to replant the trees and to plant more on the same land. Videos soon circulated of local elders putting saplings back into the ground, and some posts said the residents had apologised.
Plantation in District Khyber that was earlier destroyed, has been restored by the District Administration. pic.twitter.com/eLaM8bhvEW
— Amjad khan (@Amjid17HED) August 9, 2020
The restoration tweet is dated 9 August, a day before the post below that brought the uprooting clip to many international viewers, which shows how quickly the local story moved while the viral version was still spreading.
How the clip was misread online
Outside Pakistan the video was shared with very different explanations. British environmentalist Ben Goldsmith posted it on 10 August, saying the reason was unclear but apparently religious extremism, and others went much further, claiming the men opposed trees as un-Islamic or attaching hostile captions about Pakistanis and Muslims. Some posts pointed to flags and religious books visible in the crowd as proof.
Angry men ripping out baby trees planted by volunteers yesterday under Pakistan’s inspired Ten Billion Tree Tsunami initiative. Unclear why. Desperately misguided religious extremism apparently. I am sure God wishes us to heal rather than destroy nature. pic.twitter.com/l3YW7aHNKo
— Ben Goldsmith (@BenGoldsmith) August 10, 2020
Fact-checkers in India, including Alt News and BOOM, examined the claims and found that the anger was about unauthorised planting on disputed private land, not about trees or religion. The lesson is a familiar one: a short clip with no context invites viewers to supply their own story, and that story often says more about the viewer's assumptions than about the people on screen.
The Ten Billion Tree Tsunami in brief
The programme grew out of the Billion Tree Tsunami, launched in 2014 by the PTI-led provincial government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, which set out to plant a billion trees on degraded forest and barren land. After Imran Khan became prime minister, the national Ten Billion Tree Tsunami began on 2 September 2018, when around 1.5 million trees were planted on the first day. It was planned as a five-year effort to 2023 and aimed to restore forests and fight erosion, flooding and rising temperatures in one of the countries most exposed to climate change. More than a billion trees were reported planted in the first years, though the full target was always acknowledged as a major challenge.
Green jobs during the pandemic
When COVID-19 lockdowns hit Pakistan in spring 2020, planting was briefly paused. It restarted with distancing rules, and the government used it as a jobs scheme: the workforce roughly tripled to about 63,600 people, many of them daily-wage labourers who had lost their work. Pay was about 500 to 800 rupees a day, roughly US$3 to $5, and the plan received some 7.5 billion rupees (around $46 million) in funding. Jobs ranged from raising seedlings in nurseries to planting and guarding young forests.
Reuters interviewed one of those workers, a man named Rahman from Rawalpindi district in Punjab, who had been left without income when cities shut down. He told the agency the scheme meant that "all of us now have a way of earning daily wages again to feed our families." His new wage was around half of what he had earned before, but enough to get his household through the crisis.
What the episode teaches about mass tree planting
Large-scale planting drives are now common around the world, from India's state planting days and China's long-running shelterbelt programmes to Africa's Great Green Wall. Researchers who study them stress that the number of saplings in the ground matters far less than how many survive and grow into healthy forest. The Khyber incident highlights several conditions that decide that outcome:
- Clear consent and tenure. Trees planted on land whose owners did not agree are unlikely to be protected, and may be removed, as happened here.
- Local benefit. Communities look after trees that give them fruit, fodder, shade, firewood or income, and neglect those that seem to belong to someone else.
- Right species, right place. Native or well-suited species have better survival rates than whatever is easiest to grow in bulk.
- Aftercare. Watering, guarding and replacing losses over several years is where much of the real work and cost lies.
Seen that way, the story from Mandi Kas is less about destruction than about how conservation succeeds. The trees went back in once the people who owned and used the land had a say, which is exactly the kind of agreement that gives a young forest a chance to last. For more on the debate over planting as a climate tool, see our article on what scientists said about tree restoration and climate, and our earlier report on Pakistan's plan to hire laid-off workers to plant trees.
Sources: Alt News fact-check, 10 August 2020; Gulf News; Wikipedia: Plant for Pakistan; reporting by The News (Pakistan) and Reuters; video by Ben Goldsmith and Amjad Khan on Twitter/X.

COMMENTS