Originally published 2020-05-27.
Yes: in the spring of 2020 Pakistan put people who had lost their incomes in the coronavirus lockdown to work planting trees. The jobs were part of the 10 Billion Tree Tsunami, Prime Minister Imran Khan's national reforestation drive, and officials said the expanded programme would employ more than 63,600 people, paying daily wages to labourers who otherwise had nothing coming in.
The idea drew praise around the world as a rare example of a pandemic relief scheme that also helped the climate. Here is how it worked, who it helped, what it could and could not achieve, and what it shows about so-called green stimulus.

How the scheme worked
Pakistan entered a nationwide lockdown on 23 March 2020. Construction sites, markets and workshops closed almost overnight, and the planting campaign itself was paused under the new social-distancing rules. The prime minister then granted the forestry programme an exemption so it could restart, on the condition that it absorb workers who had been thrown out of other jobs.
The new recruits were nicknamed "jungle workers". Their tasks included raising seedlings in nurseries, planting saplings, and serving as forest guards and firefighters. Hiring focused on unemployed day labourers, women, and young people, many of whom had returned to their home villages after city work dried up. Workers were required to wear masks and stay two metres apart.
Al Jazeera reported that the programme had roughly tripled its workforce compared with its first year, that pay ranged from 500 to 800 rupees a day (about $3 to $5), and that the government had set aside 7.5 billion rupees, around $46 million, for the work. Planting was concentrated on state-owned forest land, including about 6,000 hectares around Islamabad.
The workers behind the headlines
For people living day to day, even a modest wage mattered. One of them, construction worker Abdul Rahman, explained the situation to Reuters, saying the job meant "all of us now have a way of earning daily wages again to feed our families."
His forestry pay of 500 rupees was about half of what he could earn on a good day on a building site. In a country with a large informal economy, little unemployment insurance and millions of households without savings, half a wage was still far better than none.
The scale of the shock was enormous. The Pakistan Institute of Development Economics estimated that up to 19 million people could lose their jobs because of the lockdown, most of them in Punjab. Measured against that, 63,600 forestry posts were a small cushion, and supporters of the scheme never claimed otherwise. Its value lay in showing that relief money could also build something lasting.
What the 10 Billion Tree Tsunami is
Imran Khan launched the national drive, also called Plant for Pakistan, on 2 September 2018, a few weeks after taking office. Around 1.5 million saplings went into the ground on the first day. The goal was 10 billion trees over five years, until 2023, restoring forests and planting on degraded land.
The plan grew out of an earlier provincial project. In 2014 the government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, then run by Khan's party, began the Billion Tree Tsunami, aiming to restore forest on about 35,000 hectares of degraded and barren land. That effort was praised by the Bonn Challenge, the World Bank and the IUCN, and it became the model for the national version.
The ambition reflects real need. WWF describes Pakistan as "forest poor", with trees covering less than 6% of its land. The country is also highly exposed to climate change: the think tank Germanwatch ranked it fifth among nations most affected by extreme weather over two decades, with more than 150 events between 1999 and 2018 causing an estimated $3.8 billion in losses.
Great idea!
— Erik Solheim (@ErikSolheim) May 10, 2020
Pakistan 🇵🇰 is paying people out of work in the pandemic for planting trees 🌳. Triple win - good for climate, good for nature, good for jobs!
pic.twitter.com/j4VX3oCCXq
The scheme quickly caught international attention. Erik Solheim, the Norwegian diplomat who previously led the UN Environment Programme, shared it on Twitter in May 2020 as a "triple win" for climate, nature and jobs.
The 2020 planting season
For 2020 the target was 50 million trees. By late April about 30 million native saplings, among them mulberry, acacia and moringa, had reportedly been planted in Punjab. Because so much time had been lost to the shutdown, organisers planned to stretch the planting season, which normally ends in May, through to the end of June.
Malik Amin Aslam, the prime minister's climate change adviser, framed the decision as making the best of a disaster: "This tragic crisis provided an opportunity and we grabbed it." He added that nurturing nature had "come to the economic rescue of thousands of people", and argued that the work let people recover with dignity rather than depending on handouts.
Do mass tree-planting drives work?
Planting trees is one of the most popular climate actions in the world, and also one of the most misunderstood. Trees absorb carbon dioxide as they grow, provide shade, reduce soil erosion, help hold water in the landscape and give habitat to wildlife. But a sapling only delivers those benefits if it survives and grows for decades.
That is why foresters warn against judging a project by the number of seedlings planted. The questions that matter are different:
- Survival. How many trees are still alive after three, five and ten years? Drought, grazing animals, fire and poor planting can wipe out large shares of a new forest.
- Species choice. Native species suited to local soil and rainfall usually survive better and support more wildlife than fast-growing imports.
- Right place. Planting on natural grassland or wetland can harm ecosystems, while restoring degraded forest land tends to bring the most benefit.
- Local ownership. Projects last longer when nearby communities gain from the trees and help protect them.
Even supporters added caution in 2020. Rab Nawaz of WWF-Pakistan called the green jobs plan a good idea but stressed that planting trees is just one tool against climate change, and urged the government to spend carefully and focus on resilience. Independent figures on long-term survival rates for the national programme are limited, so headline totals should be read as planting counts rather than measures of mature forest.
Myths about planting trees for the climate
"Planting trees can offset all our emissions." Forests are a valuable carbon sink, but scientists agree that cutting fossil fuel use remains essential. Trees complement emission cuts; they cannot replace them.
"More trees always means better." The wrong tree in the wrong place can drain scarce water or crowd out native plants. Quality and location matter as much as quantity.
"Trees supply the oxygen we breathe." Land plants do release oxygen, but a large share of Earth's oxygen comes from ocean plankton, and the atmosphere's oxygen supply is not at risk from deforestation in the short term. The strongest reasons to protect forests are carbon storage, biodiversity, water and livelihoods.
Lessons from Pakistan's green jobs experiment
The 2020 scheme showed that emergency employment does not have to mean digging holes and filling them in. When a crisis leaves millions idle, governments can direct wages towards work with long-term public value: restoring land, protecting forests, cleaning rivers or retrofitting buildings.
It also showed the limits. A few dollars a day for tens of thousands of workers could not replace the incomes of millions, and planting is only the first step in growing a forest. The real test of Pakistan's tree tsunami is whether the saplings planted by people like Abdul Rahman are still standing years from now.
For readers elsewhere, the takeaway is practical: when you see a tree-planting pledge, from a government or a company, ask how many trees survive, which species are used and who looks after them. Those answers say far more than the headline number.
Sources: Al Jazeera, 29 April 2020: Pakistan's virus-idled workers hired to plant trees; Wikipedia: 10 Billion Tree Tsunami; original reporting and Abdul Rahman quote: Reuters.

COMMENTS