Three Indian Soldiers Killed in Kashmir Border Firing, October 2020

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-02.

The Reported Deaths of Indian Soldiers in Kashmir in 2020

The Line of Control has divided Indian- and Pakistani-administered Kashmir since the late 1940s, and exchanges of fire across it were frequent in 2020.

On 1 October 2020 the Indian army said three of its soldiers had been killed by Pakistani fire across the Line of Control (LoC), the de facto border that splits Kashmir. Two died in the Nowgam sector and one in the Poonch sector, and four more were wounded. Pakistan rejected the Indian account, accused India of breaking the ceasefire and said a civilian on its side had been injured. It was one of thousands of reported ceasefire violations that year.

The incident was small by the standards of the conflict, but it came at a tense moment: India and Pakistan had been close to open war the year before, and India was also in a standoff with China in Ladakh. Here is what each side said, why Kashmir is contested, and what changed afterwards.

What happened on 1 October 2020

According to an Indian army spokesman, Pakistani troops opened fire early on Thursday 1 October in the Nowgam sector of north Kashmir, killing two Indian soldiers and wounding four. Overnight firing in Poonch, further south along the LoC, killed a third. The army said its troops "responded strongly", but gave no information about casualties on the Pakistani side, and none were independently confirmed.

India described the firing as unprovoked and as a breach of the ceasefire that both countries had formally agreed in 2003 but that had largely broken down by the late 2010s. Indian officials often add that Pakistani firing is used to give cover to militants trying to cross into Indian-administered Kashmir; Pakistan denies arming militants and says it gives only moral and diplomatic support to Kashmiris.

Pakistan's response

Pakistan told the story the other way round. Its Foreign Office said it had summoned a senior Indian diplomat in Islamabad to protest Indian ceasefire violations the previous day, in which a 65-year-old civilian was wounded in the Jandrot sector. Foreign ministry spokesman Zahid Hafeez Chaudhri accused New Delhi of stoking tension "to divert world attention from its human rights violations in Indian-occupied Kashmir".

Each side kept its own count of violations. Pakistan said India had committed 2,404 ceasefire violations in 2020 up to that point, killing 19 people and injuring 192 civilians. Early in 2021 India's defence minister told parliament that Pakistan had committed 5,133 violations during 2020, in which 46 Indian security personnel were killed. Neither tally can be checked independently, and the gap between them shows how hard it is to establish who fired first on any given night.

How Kashmir came to be divided

The dispute dates to August 1947, when British India was partitioned into two new states, India and Pakistan. (Older versions of this story sometimes say Pakistan "declared independence from India"; that is not accurate, as both countries were created at the same time.) The princely state of Jammu and Kashmir, with a Hindu ruler and a Muslim-majority population, was claimed by both.

War broke out almost immediately. The fighting of 1947–48 ended with a UN-mediated ceasefire line, which after the 1971 war became the Line of Control under the Simla Agreement. The two countries fought again over Kashmir in 1965, went to war in 1971 (mainly over what became Bangladesh), and clashed in the Kargil heights in 1999. China also controls part of the old state, including Aksai Chin, after its 1962 war with India.

Today India administers about 55 per cent of the land area of the wider Kashmir region and about 70 per cent of its population, Pakistan about 30 per cent of the land and China about 15 per cent. Earlier claims that India holds "two-thirds" and Pakistan "the other third" leave China out of the picture.

Who lives in Indian-administered Kashmir

Population figures are often quoted loosely. In India's 2011 census, the then state of Jammu and Kashmir had about 12.5 million people, of whom about 68 per cent were Muslim, about 28 per cent Hindu, nearly 2 per cent Sikh and about 1 per cent Buddhist. The picture varies sharply by area: the Kashmir Valley is overwhelmingly Muslim, the Jammu region has a Hindu majority, and Buddhists are concentrated in Ladakh.

Political preferences are even harder to summarise. Some Kashmiris favour union with Pakistan, some independence and some remain committed to India; there has been no free vote on the question, so any single percentage should be treated with caution.

Why 2019 raised the temperature

On 14 February 2019 a suicide car bomber attacked a convoy at Lethapora in Pulwama district, killing 40 personnel of India's Central Reserve Police Force. The Pakistan-based group Jaish-e-Mohammed claimed responsibility. On 26 February Indian jets struck a target near Balakot inside Pakistan; in the air battle that followed an Indian MiG-21 was shot down and its pilot captured, then released by Pakistan on 1 March.

Six months later, on 5 August 2019, India revoked the semi-autonomous status of Jammu and Kashmir and split it into two union territories run from Delhi, Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh. The move was followed by a long communications blackout and the detention of local politicians, and it deepened anger among many Kashmiri Muslims.

That same December, India passed the Citizenship (Amendment) Act. Because it is often misdescribed, the facts are worth stating clearly. The law offers a faster route to Indian citizenship for Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi and Christian migrants from Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan who arrived before a cut-off date. It excludes Muslims, which critics call discriminatory, but it does not by itself remove anyone's existing citizenship. The bigger fear among critics was the law's combination with a proposed nationwide citizens' register, which could leave people without documents at risk; the government said it had no such plans at the time. The rules putting the Act into effect were only notified on 11 March 2024.

From the 2021 ceasefire to 2025

Firing along the LoC continued through the winter of 2020–21. Then, after a rare hotline conversation between the two armies' directors general of military operations, India and Pakistan issued a joint statement on 25 February 2021. They agreed to strictly observe all existing agreements and the ceasefire along the LoC and other sectors from midnight on 24–25 February, and to use the hotline and flag meetings to settle any misunderstanding. The border was markedly quieter for the next four years.

That calm broke in 2025. On 22 April gunmen killed 26 civilians, most of them Hindu tourists, near Pahalgam in Indian-administered Kashmir. India launched missile strikes on what it called militant infrastructure in Pakistan and Pakistan-administered Kashmir on 7 May, and days of strikes and shelling followed before a ceasefire agreed through the same military hotline took effect on 10 May 2025.

Reading border-clash reports carefully

Reports like the one from October 2020 usually rely on a single military spokesperson on each side, in an area where independent journalists have limited access. A few habits help when reading them:

  • Note who is speaking. "India said" and "Pakistan said" are not the same as "it happened".
  • Keep the incident separate from the wider totals; annual tallies are compiled differently by each government.
  • Look for later confirmation, such as named soldiers, funerals or local reporting.
  • Remember the civilians. Families in border villages on both sides live with shelling, damaged homes and bunkers in their gardens.

Both India and Pakistan have nuclear weapons, which is why even small clashes on the LoC attract international attention. The 2021 agreement showed that a working military hotline can calm the border; the events of 2025 showed how quickly that calm can be lost.

Sources: Al Jazeera, 1 October 2020: India says Pakistani shelling kills three soldiers in Kashmir; Wikipedia: Kashmir conflict; Census 2011 data: Jammu and Kashmir; Wikipedia: 2019 Pulwama attack; Wikipedia: Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019; The Quint, 25 February 2021: India and Pakistan agree on strict observance of ceasefire; Wikipedia: 2025 India–Pakistan conflict.

COMMENTS