Eric Trump's 'I'm Part of That Community' LGBT Remark Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-01.

On 29 September 2020, Eric Trump told Fox & Friends that LGBT supporters of his father were "incredible" and added, "I'm part of that community, and we love the man." The line set off a wave of jokes and speculation online about whether the president's son was coming out. In context, he was almost certainly voicing the words of an LGBT Trump supporter, not describing himself. Eric Trump, who has been married to Lara Trump since 2014, has never said he is gay. Here is what he actually said, why it was misread and what it revealed about the Trump campaign's outreach to LGBT voters.

Eric Trump's 2020 Remarks About the LGBT Community

Left: Eric Trump. Right: Donald Trump holds a rainbow flag reading "LGBTs for Trump", handed to him by supporter Max Nowak at a rally in Greeley, Colorado, in October 2016. Photos: Getty Images/Spencer Platt; Getty Images/Chip Somodevilla.

What Eric Trump said on Fox & Friends

The interview took place on the morning of the first presidential debate between Donald Trump and Joe Biden. Host Ainsley Earhardt raised the idea of "secret" Trump voters and mentioned a New York Times story about a gay woman in Manhattan who quietly supported the president. Eric Trump replied that LGBT supporters turn out for his father every day, then delivered the sentence that went viral, followed by thanks for "protecting our neighborhoods" and "our cities".

Read on the page, the switch from "they" to "I" and "we" is jarring. Heard as a quick, unscripted answer, it sounds like a speaker slipping into the voice of the people he is describing, something many of us do in casual conversation.

The most likely explanation

Journalists who watched the clip quickly pointed out the obvious reading. Dave Weigel, then a political reporter at the Washington Post, wrote that Eric was plainly quoting a hypothetical supporter he had spoken to. Writers at Refinery29 and the Advocate reached the same conclusion, describing the remark as a clumsy attempt to speak on behalf of LGBT voters rather than any kind of announcement.

It is also worth saying plainly: nobody's sexual orientation can be read from one garbled sentence on breakfast television, and speculating about it is rarely kind or useful. The fair question is not whether Eric Trump is gay, but whether his campaign's claims about LGBT support matched its record.

How the internet reacted

Social media treated the moment as a gift. Within minutes, users were posting coming-out jokes, rainbow GIFs and mock welcome messages. Many LGBT users joked the other way round, saying the community was not keen to claim him. Others focused on the odd thanks for "protecting our neighborhoods", as if LGBT people were a police force. Several of the original posts have since been deleted.

pic.twitter.com/NdI2kfW1tL

— Shelley Johnson (@shelleyj89) September 29, 2020

(This post is no longer available on X.)

pic.twitter.com/Lq0WzLhPAI

— 🇺🇸WEAR MASKS SAVE LIVES🇺🇸 (@overrhypocrissy) September 29, 2020

(This post is no longer available on X.)

“Thank you for protecting our neighborhoods, thank you for protecting our cities”... Does he think LGBT is some kind of law enforcement agency?

— Lorne (@LornestoToledo) September 29, 2020

(This post is no longer available on X.)

Sarah Kate Ellis, president of the media advocacy group GLAAD, also responded online, using the moment to criticise the administration's policies rather than Eric Trump's phrasing.

Donald Trump and LGBT voters

Trump presented himself in 2016 as friendlier to gay voters than earlier Republican nominees. He mentioned LGBTQ Americans in his convention speech and, at a rally in Greeley, Colorado, on 30 October 2016, briefly held up a rainbow flag that a supporter had handed him. In 2020 his campaign ran a "Trump Pride" outreach effort, and his administration pointed to Richard Grenell, an openly gay ambassador who briefly served as acting Director of National Intelligence, and to a US initiative urging countries to decriminalise homosexuality.

Critics, including GLAAD and the Advocate, pointed to a very different list:

  • a ban on most transgender people serving in the military;
  • withdrawal of federal guidance protecting transgender students in schools;
  • a rule narrowing health care non-discrimination protections under the Affordable Care Act;
  • religious-exemption policies affecting adoption, foster care and shelters;
  • the appointment of many judges with records hostile to LGBT rights.

So while Trump himself rarely attacked gay people directly, unlike his frequent attacks on immigrants, women and political opponents, his administration's policies were widely seen by LGBT advocacy groups as a step backwards, especially for transgender Americans.

How LGBT Americans actually vote

Gallup's large 2020 survey found that 5.6% of US adults identified as LGBT, up from 4.5% in 2017, with much higher rates among younger generations. The same data showed a strong political lean: 8.8% of Democrats identified as LGBT, compared with 1.7% of Republicans. Exit polls in 2020 likewise showed most LGBT voters backing Joe Biden.

That said, there have always been gay and lesbian conservatives, including groups such as the Log Cabin Republicans, which endorsed Trump in 2020. One of his loudest online cheerleaders in 2016 was the British provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos, who is openly gay. Yiannopoulos lost much of his standing on the right in 2017, when he resigned from Breitbart News after widely condemned remarks about sexual relationships between adults and teenage boys.

Why the slip still gets searched

The clip lives on because it captures something familiar about political television: rushed answers, campaign talking points and a speaker trying to sound inclusive without quite finding the words. Eric Trump never followed up with any statement about his own identity, and nothing in his public life suggests the remark was meant literally. The lasting lesson is a simple one for anyone watching a viral clip: check the full context before deciding what someone meant.

Sources: The Advocate, 29 September 2020; Refinery29, September 2020; Gallup: LGBT Identification Rises to 5.6% in Latest U.S. Estimate. Photos: Getty Images/Spencer Platt and Getty Images/Chip Somodevilla.

COMMENTS