Originally published 2020-07-15.

New York Sen. Alessandra Biaggi, D-Bronx. Photo: Hans Pennink/AP
In July 2020 New York State Senator Alessandra Biaggi introduced a bill that would have required every police officer in the state to carry professional liability insurance covering claims of misconduct on the job. The idea was that officers with repeated complaints would face rising premiums, creating a financial reason to change behaviour or leave policing. It was a proposal, not a law, and it drew strong support from reform advocates and fierce opposition from police unions.
The bill arrived weeks after the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis set off protests across the United States, at a moment when lawmakers everywhere were looking for new ways to hold officers accountable. Here is what the proposal said, how police misconduct is paid for today, and the arguments on both sides.
What the bill proposed
The bill, numbered S8676 and introduced on 6 July 2020, would have added a new section to New York’s General Municipal Law. Its main points were:
- Police officers employed by any city, county, town, village, authority or agency in the state would have to obtain liability insurance covering acts or omissions within the scope of their employment.
- Officers would have to show proof of coverage and keep it in place for as long as they served.
- The employing government would pay the base rate of each policy.
- Police officers would be removed from the state law that normally requires public employers to defend and indemnify their employees.
Coverage of the bill often said officers would pay for the insurance themselves. That is not quite right. Under the text, the employer covers the base premium. As reporting at the time explained, officers would be responsible for any increase in their premium caused by their own record of misconduct.
Personal liability insurance isn't a novel idea. Nurses and hairdressers carry personal liability insurance too.https://t.co/ISetoGXsMf
— Alessandra Biaggi (@SenatorBiaggi) July 13, 2020
Who pays for police misconduct now?
When an officer is sued over conduct on duty, the officer is usually defended by the employer’s lawyers, and any settlement or judgment is almost always paid by the city or county. In practice that means taxpayers foot the bill, while the officer’s own finances are rarely touched.
The sums are large. New York City paid about $220 million in 2019 to settle civil claims against its police department, more than for any other city agency, according to Claims Journal. Because those costs are spread across the city budget, critics argue they send no clear signal to the individual officers involved or to the department about who is driving the risk.
Officers are also often protected by qualified immunity, a legal doctrine that shields government officials from personal liability unless they violated a clearly established right. The insurance idea is designed to work alongside, or around, that system by attaching a cost to repeated misconduct.
How insurance could change behaviour
The model borrows from other professions. Doctors carry malpractice insurance, and many nurses, accountants and hairdressers carry liability cover. Drivers with repeated accidents or convictions pay higher premiums, and some are effectively priced off the road.
Applied to policing, insurers would assess each officer’s risk using their record. An officer with a clean history would pay little or nothing extra. One with a string of complaints or payouts would see the price climb. In Biaggi’s words, the purpose was to create “a financial disincentive for police misconduct”, and she argued that rising premiums could push an officer to change their behaviour or leave law enforcement.
Northeastern University law professor Deborah Ramirez, one of the best-known advocates of the idea, told NPR in June 2020 that insurers could act as an independent early-warning system. Because it is hard for police to police themselves, she argued, an outside party that prices risk might spot dangerous officers sooner than internal discipline does. She also said insurance alone would not be enough without changes in how powerful police unions defend members accused of misconduct.
The arguments against
Police unions opposed the bill strongly. Their main objections were cost and recruitment: they said officers are already underpaid relative to the risks of the job, and that adding a personal insurance requirement would make it even harder to attract and keep good people.
Critics also raised practical questions:
- Would insurers take part? Some brokers and insurers explored building police liability products in 2020, but others privately worried about entering such a politically charged market.
- Would they have the data? In many states police disciplinary records are confidential, which would make it hard to price risk accurately. New York itself repealed its secrecy law for police records, known as 50-a, in June 2020.
- Who carries the extra cost? If premiums rise across the board, the bill could end up costing taxpayers more without changing behaviour much.
- Could it deter proactive policing? Some argued officers might avoid difficult but legitimate work to protect their premiums.
Similar ideas elsewhere
New York was not alone. Activists in Minneapolis gathered signatures in 2016 to put an insurance requirement for officers on the city ballot, but a court ruling kept it off. In June 2020 Colorado passed a broad police accountability law that makes an officer personally liable for up to 5% of a judgment, or $25,000, whichever is less, if their employer finds they did not act in good faith.
Cato Institute scholar Clark Neily, a libertarian critic of qualified immunity, has suggested that individual policies of around $500,000 to $1 million would cover most claims, with cities insuring larger losses. The fact that supporters range from civil liberties groups to free-market think tanks shows that the idea does not fit neatly on a left-right line.
Where things stand
Bills like S8676 are a starting point for debate, not settled policy. A bill must pass committee, both houses of the legislature and be signed by the governor before it becomes law, and Biaggi’s 2020 proposal did not complete that process. Similar proposals have been raised again in New York and other states since, including at New York City Council level.
For anyone following the issue, the key questions remain the same: who pays the base cost, how risk is measured fairly, whether insurers can see the records they need, and whether a financial nudge can change behaviour on its own. The New York State Senate’s legislation website shows the current status of any bill by number.
Sources: New York State Senate, bill S8676 (2020); Claims Journal (Bloomberg), July 2020; The Independent; NPR interview with Deborah Ramirez.

COMMENTS