Originally published 2020-07-14.

On the afternoon of Friday 12 June 2020, a 92-year-old woman walking to her pharmacy in Manhattan was shoved from behind by a passing stranger. She fell, struck her head on a fire hydrant and was taken to hospital. Four days later, on Tuesday 16 June, the New York Police Department announced that it had arrested 31-year-old Rashid Brimmage and charged him with assault.
The attack was caught on a surveillance camera, and the short clip travelled quickly across television news and social media. Here is what the reporting at the time established, what it did not, and what the case says about the safety of older people in a big city.
What happened near Gramercy Park
Police placed the attack on Third Avenue between East 15th and East 16th Streets, on the edge of the Gramercy Park neighbourhood. The NYPD's own appeal gave the time as 3.23 p.m.; news reports rounded it to about 3.30.
The footage shows a man walking along the pavement. As the elderly woman passes him, he pushes her hard and keeps going without breaking stride. She goes down and her head hits the hydrant at the kerb. Two young women who saw it helped her up and one of them called an ambulance.
She was treated at a local emergency room for bruising to her head and scalp and was otherwise reported to be okay, which, given her age and the force of the fall, was a matter of luck as much as anything else.
Nothing in the published reporting suggests the two had any contact before the shove. Police described it as a random, unprovoked attack, and no motive was ever made public.
The arrest of Rashid Brimmage
The NYPD released stills from the video with a "wanted for assault" notice and asked the public for tips. According to ABC7 New York, it was an officer who recognised the man in the footage that led detectives to Brimmage. He was taken into custody and charged with assault.
Reports at the time described him as having a long criminal history, but the numbers varied from one outlet to the next. Early stories said 65 previous arrests; police later told ABC7 the figure was over 100 and called him a career criminal and a "transit recidivist". Outlets also gave different home neighbourhoods, some saying Harlem and others the Bronx.
Police said he had become a registered level 2 sex offender after a 2014 conviction for persistent sexual abuse. In the months before the Gramercy attack he was also accused of assaulting at least three other people, reportedly including a man in an East Harlem pizza shop in March and two people in a Bronx doughnut shop in February. Like every accused person, he was presumed innocent of those allegations unless proven otherwise in court.
We could not find a reliable published record of how the June 2020 assault case ended, so we are not reporting a verdict or sentence.
The woman behind the headlines
The victim, a retired teacher, did not want her full name made public; one station identified her only as Geraldine. Speaking to CBS2 reporter Jenna DeAngelis a few days after the attack, she showed the bruises on her head and arm and described what she remembered.
The detail that stayed with her was that her attacker turned around. "He did look back to see me fall on the floor," she told CBS2. With a face mask and a sun visor on, she believed he had barely seen her face and had simply picked out an old woman walking slowly.
The physical injuries healed faster than the fear. She said she would no longer walk the streets on her own and planned to stay at home for a while. Even so, when asked what she wanted for the man who hurt her, she answered with more grace than many would manage: she hoped that in jail he would "think about what he did" and try to make himself a better person.
This callous crime didn’t merit coverage on the big networks. Why? Violent racism? Who are his role models? https://t.co/Yipg6TQrig
— Laura Ingraham (@IngrahamAngle) June 17, 2020
Why the clip spread so widely
Random violence caught on camera always draws attention, but this video landed in a particularly tense month. It was June 2020: New York was emerging from its first Covid-19 lockdown, and the country was in the middle of mass protests after the killing of George Floyd.
That context shaped how people reacted. Fox News host Laura Ingraham shared the clip on 17 June, asking why the main networks had not covered it and raising race as a possible motive. Others pointed out that local stations had covered it extensively and that police had not described any motive at all.
Both points are worth keeping apart. The video shows an act of senseless cruelty against a frail person, and it is reasonable to be angry about it. What the video cannot show is why it happened, and the officials handling the case never offered a reason.
Older people, falls and street safety
For a person in their nineties, a fall is far more dangerous than for a younger adult. Bones are more fragile, balance is slower to recover and a head injury can take days to show its full effect. That is why anyone who sees an older person knocked down should call emergency services even if the person insists they are fine, and why it matters that the two passers-by in this case stayed with her until help came.
A few practical habits can make a difference for older people walking alone in a city:
- Keep a charged phone within easy reach and save an emergency contact on the lock screen.
- Walk on the inside of the pavement where possible, away from the kerb, hydrants and parked bikes.
- When an errand can be shared with a neighbour, friend or volunteer, do it together, especially in the first weeks after a frightening incident.
- Report every assault, however small it seems. In this case, a clear police appeal and a recognisable image were what led to an arrest within days.
Fear after an attack is normal and can linger. Families can help by checking in often, offering to walk with the person and, if anxiety stops them leaving the house for weeks, encouraging them to talk to a doctor.
What we know and what remains open
The core facts are well documented: the date and place, the injuries, the arrest four days later and the assault charge. The suspect's exact number of past arrests and his home neighbourhood were reported inconsistently, and the final outcome of the case was not widely reported.
What the story shows most clearly is how much a few seconds of thoughtlessness can take from someone. Geraldine walked out to collect a prescription and came home afraid of her own street. The quick help of strangers and an alert police officer are the parts of the story that offer some comfort.
Sources: ABC7 New York: 92-year-old woman speaks out after random attack, suspect arrested; WFTV/Cox Media: Woman, 92, randomly attacked while walking in New York; CBS2 New York interview (June 2020).

COMMENTS