Originally published 2020-07-15.

In June 2020, the Scottish Parliament voted to end the licences that had allowed salmon farms and fisheries to shoot seals to protect their stock. The change was part of the Animals and Wildlife (Penalties, Protections and Powers) (Scotland) Act 2020, and the licensing reform took effect on 1 February 2021. Killing a seal without a valid licence is now a serious offence, punishable by up to five years in prison and an unlimited fine.
It was celebrated by animal-welfare groups as a landmark, and it was. It is worth being precise, though: the law did not create an absolute ban on killing seals in every circumstance. It removed the specific licences that let fish farms and fishing interests shoot them.
What exactly changed in the law
Seals in Scotland were already protected under the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010. That Act allowed ministers to issue licences to kill or take seals for a list of purposes, two of which covered protecting the health and welfare of farmed fish and preventing serious damage to fisheries or fish farms. Fish-farm operators made heavy use of these licences.
The 2020 Act deleted those two purposes from the list and repealed a related power that let people enter land to protect fisheries from seals. It also toughened the penalties. Serious cases tried on indictment can now bring up to five years' imprisonment, while lesser cases can bring up to 12 months and a fine of up to £40,000.
Licences remain possible for narrow purposes that have nothing to do with protecting fish stocks, such as animal welfare or scientific research. So the accurate summary is that Scotland ended the shooting of seals to protect fish farms and fisheries, rather than every form of seal control.
GREAT NEWS: Scotland bans seal killing in major victory to end fish farm shootings! 👏 https://t.co/FCWbaasP93
— Humane Society International (@HSIGlobal) June 18, 2020
Why seals were being shot
Scotland is one of the world's largest producers of farmed Atlantic salmon. Open net pens in sea lochs hold tens of thousands of fish, and to a hungry seal they can look like an easy meal. Seals can tear nets, kill or injure fish and stress the whole pen, causing real financial losses.
Wild-capture fisheries had their own complaints, because seals eat many of the same species fishermen target, and they sometimes take fish straight from nets. For years, shooting the animals blamed for the damage was a legal, licensed response.
The welfare argument
The campaign to end the practice was led in large part by Humane Society International, which argued that shooting seals at sea is rarely clean. A seal in the water is a small, moving target, and wounded animals can swim away and die slowly, often without ever appearing in official figures.
Mark Simmonds, a marine scientist with HSI, put the organisation's case plainly when the vote passed: "it is simply unacceptable to kill them for eating the fish in their ocean home." Conservation groups also pointed out that targeting individual seals did little to solve the underlying problem of poorly protected pens.
The trade factor nobody expected
Animal welfare was not the only pressure. The United States, a valuable market for Scottish salmon, introduced rules under its Marine Mammal Protection Act requiring countries that export seafood to the US to show their fisheries meet standards comparable to American ones on marine mammals. Killing marine mammals to protect fish farms is not allowed in the US, so licensed seal shooting put Scotland's exports at risk.
Ending the licences therefore protected seals and an industry worth hundreds of millions of pounds a year to the Scottish economy at the same time. It is a good example of how international trade standards can quietly drive wildlife protection.
Scotland's seals in context
Two species of seal live around Scotland: the grey seal and the smaller common, or harbour, seal. The UK is a global stronghold for grey seals. Estimates put the British population at around 157,000, roughly a quarter of the world total of about 632,000. Older figures, often quoted in news reports, put the UK share closer to 40%, but counts vary by year and method.
Grey seals eat mainly fish, especially bottom-dwelling species such as sand eels, cod, flatfish and herring, plus octopus and lobster when they can find them. An adult averages about 5 kilograms of food a day. They breed on remote beaches and islands, with females giving birth to a single pup that can quadruple its weight in under three weeks on extremely rich milk.
Humans are not their only threat. Orcas are the main natural predator of adult grey seals, and some large sharks also hunt them. Harbour seals have had a harder time than greys, with sharp declines in some parts of Scotland, which made conservationists especially keen to remove any avoidable deaths.
How fish farms keep seals out now
Without the option of shooting, farms rely on prevention. The main tools include stronger and better-tensioned nets, additional outer nets that keep seals away from the fish, keeping pens free of dead fish that attract predators, and careful choice of site.
Acoustic deterrent devices, which emit loud underwater sounds to drive seals away, are also used, but they have their own critics. Some scientists and campaigners worry that the noise can disturb whales, dolphins and porpoises, so their use has itself come under scrutiny.
Why it matters
The change did not end every conflict between seals and the fishing industry, and it did not make seals untouchable. What it did was close the door on a practice that caused suffering, was hard to monitor, and threatened Scotland's trade. For one of the world's most important grey seal populations, it marked a clear shift from killing problem animals to designing the problem out.
Sources: legislation.gov.uk: Animals and Wildlife (Penalties, Protections and Powers) (Scotland) Act 2020; legislation.gov.uk: Section 14, killing, injuring or taking seals; Wikipedia: Grey seal; Humane Society International on X, 18 June 2020; Humane Society International press statement (June 2020).

COMMENTS