First published February 24, 2020.

In April 2018, fishermen off Grand Cayman came across a huge drifting fishing net packed with dead sharks and fish. The net was about 40 feet (12 m) across and roughly 40 feet deep, and it was still trapping animals as it floated. Photos posted on Instagram by local fisherman and dive instructor Dominick Martin-Mayes spread around the world and turned a local sighting into a lesson about "ghost nets": fishing gear that has been lost or dumped at sea and keeps catching marine life with nobody there to haul it in.
Early posts spoke of hundreds of dead sharks. Local reporting at the time was more cautious, describing perhaps 30 or more sharks plus hundreds of fish, some too decomposed to identify. The exact count was never settled, and the net had partly spilled its contents by the time it was recovered. Either way, the scene showed in one frame what ghost gear does.
What the fishermen found off Grand Cayman
The net was spotted late in the afternoon of Monday, 16 April 2018, about four miles off Grand Cayman. Martin-Mayes and the other people on his boat photographed it and sent its coordinates to the Cayman Islands Department of Environment. They could not move it: a net that size, waterlogged and full of carcasses, was far too heavy for a small boat, and diving into a mass of floating mesh carries a real risk of entanglement for people too.
Shark conservationist Guy Harvey, who is based in the Cayman Islands, said it was almost certainly an illegal pelagic gillnet, a type of net hung vertically in open water that catches whatever swims into it. Among the trapped animals was a juvenile oceanic whitetip shark, a species now listed as critically endangered.
(The Instagram post originally embedded here is no longer available.)
How the net was finally pulled out
For several days nobody could find the net again. The Department of Environment searched for it, including with a reconnaissance flight, and officials feared it had drifted out of Cayman waters.
Then, on the Thursday, local angler Charles Ebanks found it snagged on a reef north of Rum Point. Following the department's advice, he freed it and tied it to a dive mooring overnight. Early the next morning he went back with his brother, Adroy Ebanks, who free-dived on the net and bundled it with ropes. They towed it across the North Sound to Harbour House Marina, where an excavator lifted it out of the water.
By then many of the dead animals had fallen out. Department staff and the Ebanks brothers released live lobsters, crabs and small fish that were still caught in the mesh. Deputy Director Tim Austin called the outcome the best case scenario, because the net was finally out of the ocean.
How long had it been drifting?
The net itself held clues. Guy Harvey pointed to adult sergeant major fish living around it, which suggested the net had been in the water long enough for juveniles to grow up there, a process that can take a year or more. A dive instructor noted a large lobster that had settled in the net as a larva. Experts quoted locally guessed the net could have been adrift for up to two years.
That is the core problem with ghost gear. A lost net does not stop fishing. Animals that get trapped and die attract scavengers such as sharks, which then become trapped themselves, and the cycle repeats for as long as the net holds together. Modern nets are made of durable plastic, so that can mean years.
Ghost gear and the Great Pacific Garbage Patch
The Cayman net was a single object, but lost fishing gear is a large share of ocean plastic. A 2018 study in the journal Scientific Reports, led by Laurent Lebreton of The Ocean Cleanup, estimated that the Great Pacific Garbage Patch holds about 80,000 tonnes of plastic spread over roughly 1.6 million square kilometres, and that fishing nets make up nearly half of that mass (the study's figure is about 46 percent).
It is important to keep that number in context. It describes the floating material measured in one region of the North Pacific. It is not a figure for all ocean plastic worldwide, and it says nothing about the Caribbean specifically. Other estimates suggest ghost gear makes up around a tenth of marine litter globally; the totals vary widely because lost gear is hard to count.
Bycatch: the wider cost of fishing nets
Ghost nets are an extreme form of a broader issue called bycatch, meaning animals caught unintentionally while fishing for something else. Older articles often quote a single percentage for how much of the world's catch is bycatch, but the figures depend heavily on how bycatch is defined. Some fisheries, such as shrimp trawling, have historically discarded several kilograms of unwanted animals for every kilogram of shrimp, while others are much cleaner.
For sharks the impact is clear. Populations of oceanic sharks and rays have fallen by more than 70 percent since 1970, and fishing, including bycatch in longlines, trawls and nets, is the main driver.
What helps: from net recovery to better gear
There is no single fix, but several approaches are working:
- Reporting and recovery. The Cayman case shows the value of boaters reporting coordinates quickly, and of authorities having a plan and the right equipment, ideally a large boat with a crane, before a net drifts away.
- Gear marking and tracking. Marking nets and fitting them with trackers makes it easier to find lost gear and to hold its owners accountable.
- Port collection and recycling. Disposal costs are one reason old nets get dumped. Free collection schemes and recycling programmes, which turn nylon nets into yarn, carpet tiles and clothing, remove that incentive.
- Coordinated action. The Global Ghost Gear Initiative, founded in 2015, brings together governments, fishing companies and conservation groups to share solutions.
If you dive, sail or fish and come across a drifting net, the safest thing to do is record its location and report it to the local fisheries or environment authority. Recovering a heavy net is a job for trained crews with proper equipment, as the Cayman divers wisely recognised.
Sources: Photographs by Dominick Martin-Mayes (Instagram, April 2018); Cayman Compass: Ghost net slips through Cayman's grasp; Cayman Compass: A killer net in Cayman waters; Wikipedia: Great Pacific garbage patch; Wikipedia: Ghost net; Wikipedia: Bycatch.

COMMENTS