Strong Mothers, Strong Daughters: What the Research Says

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-05-10.

How a Mother's Example Can Influence Her Daughter

Do strong mothers raise strong daughters? Research suggests a mother's example does matter. Girls often name their mothers as their main role model and turn to them first for support. Large studies also link a mother's working life to her daughter's later career. But "strong" does not mean tough or flawless. What seems to pass from mother to daughter is a way of handling life: setting standards, recovering from setbacks, and asking for help when it is needed.

Here is what the evidence says, where popular claims go too far, and how any parent or caregiver can model this kind of strength.

What the research actually shows

The strongest evidence comes from a cross-national study led by Kathleen McGinn of Harvard Business School, with Mayra Ruiz Castro and Elizabeth Long Lingo. They analysed survey data on more than 100,000 men and women in 29 countries. Compared with women whose mothers stayed home full time, daughters of employed mothers were:

  • about 1.21 times more likely to be employed themselves;
  • about 1.29 times more likely to supervise other people at work;
  • in the US sample, earning roughly $1,880 more a year on average.

The link held even after the researchers controlled for the mothers' education. Sons of working mothers did not differ much in their own employment. They did spend more time caring for family members, and they held more equal views about men's and women's roles. Adult children of employed and stay-at-home mothers reported similar levels of happiness. Children of working mothers were not worse off.

The teenage years point the same way. A Girls Leadership study with the shoe brand Keds, published around 2015, asked girls aged 13 to 17 about bravery and role models. Girls named their mothers as role models more often than teachers, friends or fathers. In the widely reported headline figure, 63% chose their mother. And 77% said they turn to their mothers for support and encouragement, nearly half of them before anyone else. That cuts against the stereotype that teenage girls only listen to their friends.

Executive coach Bonnie Marcus has also written that in a survey she ran of several hundred professional women, the most ambitious ones credited their mothers with shaping that ambition. It is an interesting finding, but it was a small self-selected survey, not a controlled study, so treat it as a clue rather than proof.

Where the popular message goes too far

Articles on this subject often claim that a strong mother is the most important predictor of a girl's success. No study shows that. Children are shaped by many things: fathers and other caregivers, teachers, friends, money, health, neighbourhood, opportunity and their own temperament. A mother's example is one strong influence among many.

The research also does not say that stay-at-home mothers raise weaker daughters. The McGinn study measured employment, not character. Many of the qualities people mean by "strong" can be modelled by any parent, whatever their job:

  • self-respect and clear boundaries;
  • persistence after failure;
  • honesty about feelings;
  • kindness that does not slide into being a doormat.

Finally, a girl with a difficult or absent mother is not destined to struggle. Grandmothers, aunts, fathers, coaches and mentors can all fill this role. Psychologists who study resilience consistently find that warm, trusting relationships with adults matter more than the exact family arrangement.

How a Mother's Example Can Influence Her Daughter

Why a mother's example carries so much weight

Children learn more from what adults do than from what they say. Psychologists call this observational or social learning. A daughter watches how her mother handles pressure at work, disagreements with a partner, money worries, illness and disappointment. Without anyone explaining it, she builds a picture of what a woman can do and how a woman is treated.

That picture can widen her options or narrow them. A mother who speaks up in a meeting, takes on a challenge or leaves a relationship that hurts her shows her daughter those choices are normal. A mother who constantly runs herself down, or puts up with being disrespected, teaches a quieter lesson too. Daughters often notice the gap between what they are told ("you can be anything") and what they see.

The qualities daughters tend to pick up

Self-respect and boundaries

Girls who see their mother calmly refuse unfair treatment learn that "no" is a complete sentence. That carries over into friendships and, later, into romantic relationships. Recognising controlling or disrespectful behaviour early is one of the best protections a young woman can have.

Getting up after a fall

The road to any goal is rarely straight. A mother who admits a mistake, says what she learned and tries again teaches more than one who always seems to have everything under control. Crying is not weakness. Giving up straight away is the habit to avoid.

Kindness with limits

Strong mothers often model forgiveness and generosity, along with a clear line where tolerance ends. Daughters learn that being kind and being a pushover are different things.

Wearing more than one label

A woman can be a parent, a professional, a friend, a carer and someone with her own interests all at once. Seeing a mother juggle several roles, imperfectly, helps a girl resist being boxed into just one.

How to model strength in everyday life

  • Think out loud about setbacks. "That didn't go how I wanted. Here's what I'll try next" shows persistence better than a lecture does.
  • Let her see you ask for help. The Girls Leadership research found many girls believe asking for help is a sign of weakness. Watching a capable adult ask a friend, colleague or doctor for support breaks that myth.
  • Talk about money and work. Explain choices about jobs, budgets and saving in age-appropriate ways. Financial confidence is part of independence.
  • Respect her no. Asking before hugging her, and taking her objections seriously, teaches her that her boundaries matter.
  • Listen at the right moment. Many teenagers need to decompress after school before they talk. A quiet car ride or a late snack often works better than questions at the door.
  • Support her goals, not yours. A strong example gives a daughter confidence to choose her own path, which may look nothing like her mother's.

A relationship, not a template

The best mother-daughter relationships are rarely about a mother being impressive. They are about a daughter feeling safe, valued and taken seriously. In that kind of relationship she can try, fail and try again. If you were lucky enough to grow up with that, you probably carry it in how you set your standards and how you treat yourself.

If you did not, it is never too late to find mentors who model it, or to become that example for a girl in your own life.

Sources: Harvard Business School Working Knowledge, Kids of working moms grow into happy adults (McGinn, Ruiz Castro and Lingo); Girls Leadership, Here's the research on teen girls that really surprised us; Bonnie Marcus, survey of professional women on ambition (reported in her 2015 writing).

COMMENTS