Morrisons' Plastic-Free Fruit and Veg Aisles: What Changed in 2019

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-06-26.

Morrisons Expanded Loose Produce in a 2019 Packaging Initiative

In May 2019 Morrisons, then the UK's fourth-largest supermarket chain, announced that it would add plastic-free fruit and vegetable areas to 60 of its stores during that year. Shoppers could choose from up to 127 kinds of produce over the seasons, sold loose, and either carry them to the till as they were or put them in recyclable paper bags. The retailer estimated the change would save about three tonnes of plastic a week, roughly 156 tonnes a year.

Headlines at the time described Morrisons as the first supermarket to "ban" plastic on fruit and veg. That overstated it. Packaged produce stayed on sale in a neighbouring section, and the plan covered selected stores rather than the whole estate. What Morrisons did claim, and what Greenpeace UK acknowledged, was that it was the first major British grocer to roll out a dedicated "buy bagless" greengrocery area in a large number of shops. Here is what the scheme involved, why it mattered, how it compared with rivals, and what research has since shown about selling produce loose.

What Morrisons actually introduced

The new areas were designed to look like an old-fashioned greengrocer's. Instead of pre-weighed bags of apples or cling-wrapped cucumbers, produce sat in open crates and shoppers took as much or as little as they wanted. The photo above, released with the announcement, shows a Morrisons worker holding a wooden tray of mixed vegetables in front of loose displays of leeks, peppers, onions and potatoes.

The key details, according to the company's own announcement of 20 May 2019, were:

  • Up to 127 varieties of fruit and vegetables available loose across the year.
  • Rollout to 60 stores during 2019, then to further branches as they were refurbished.
  • Recyclable paper bags for anyone who wanted one, or no bag at all.
  • A projected saving of around three tonnes of plastic a week from the new shelves.

Drew Kirk, Morrisons' fruit and veg director at the time, said many customers wanted the option of buying loose, and described the move as a return to traditional greengrocery.

Why the trial results mattered

The decision followed a ten-month trial in three stores: Skipton, Guiseley and St Ives. Purchases of loose produce there rose by an average of 40 per cent. That figure is the reason the rollout made commercial sense. Supermarkets often argue that shoppers prefer the convenience of pre-packed bags; the trial suggested that when the loose option is attractive, well stocked and easy to use, a significant number of people choose it.

Two numbers are worth keeping apart. The 40 per cent rise was measured in the trial stores. The three-tonnes-a-week saving was a forecast for the new areas, based on the hope that other stores would see a similar shift. No public figure has confirmed how much plastic the 60-store rollout saved in practice.

The scheme also sat inside a wider plan. Morrisons said its plastic initiatives announced up to that point would remove about 9,000 tonnes of unnecessary or problematic plastic a year. That total included 174 million plastic produce bags taken out of its fruit and veg aisles and 600 tonnes of unrecyclable polystyrene removed from branded products. It expected paper carrier bags to cut a further 1,300 tonnes.

How other supermarkets were responding in 2019

Morrisons was not acting alone. British retailers were under heavy pressure after years of coverage of plastic in the oceans, and several were testing ideas at the same time.

Tesco ran a one-month trial in spring 2019 at its large Watford and Swindon stores, removing plastic packaging from 45 fruit and vegetable lines, including onions, apples and mushrooms. In 2018 it had also announced aims to remove hard-to-recycle materials from its own-brand packaging and make all its packaging recyclable or compostable by 2025.

Waitrose had announced in April 2018 that it would remove disposable takeaway cups from its cafés, and during 2019 it tested other ideas, including home-compostable produce bags and refill stations. Greenpeace welcomed Morrisons' move but urged every UK supermarket to go further, pointing out that some staples, such as potatoes and apples, would still be sold in plastic.

The common thread is that each chain changed specific categories or stores rather than its whole business. These were meaningful experiments, but they were steps, not bans.

Does selling produce loose really help?

A frequent objection is that plastic wrap protects food and keeps it fresh for longer, so removing it could simply swap a plastic problem for a food waste problem. Research published since 2019 suggests that, for most whole, uncut produce, the opposite is true.

In February 2022 the UK waste charity WRAP published a study of five commonly wasted items: apples, bananas, broccoli, cucumbers and potatoes. Its researchers stored them in their original packaging and loose, at different temperatures. They found that plastic packaging did not necessarily extend the life of uncut fresh produce and could even increase waste. WRAP estimated that selling these five items loose and removing best-before dates could save around 100,000 tonnes of household food waste and more than 10,300 tonnes of plastic a year.

The reason is simple. Loose produce lets people buy the amount they actually need. A single shopper who needs three potatoes no longer has to buy a 2.5 kg bag and throw half of it away. WRAP's tests also found that apples kept in the fridge showed no deterioration until about two and a half months after their best-before date, which suggests many households discard food that is still good.

There are exceptions. Some delicate, cut or high-moisture items, such as salad leaves, berries and prepared vegetables, do last longer in packaging. WRAP's recommendation was to sell loose wherever that does not increase overall food waste, rather than to remove every wrapper.

What shoppers can do

A packaging initiative only works if people use it. A few habits make loose shopping easy:

  • Take reusable produce bags or a few washed paper bags to the shop, and keep them with your shopping bags.
  • Buy loose for the items you use in small amounts, such as onions, peppers and potatoes, so less food is wasted.
  • Store most fruit and vegetables in the fridge below 5°C; WRAP found this alone greatly extends their life. Bananas, whole pineapples and unripe avocados are the main exceptions.
  • Judge freshness by look, smell and feel rather than only by a best-before date, which is about quality, not safety.
  • Give feedback. Supermarkets track what sells; choosing loose produce when it is offered is the clearest signal you can send.

The bigger picture on supermarket plastic

Morrisons' 2019 rollout is best understood as one early example of a wider shift in British grocery retail. Plastic carrier bag sales in England's main supermarkets had already fallen sharply after the 5p charge introduced in 2015, which showed that small changes at the till can alter habits on a large scale. Loose produce aisles applied a similar idea to the fruit and veg section.

The limits are just as important. A loose aisle in some stores does not describe a supermarket's total plastic footprint, which also includes meat trays, drinks bottles, ready meals and the packaging that arrives at the back of the store. When judging a retailer's claims, it helps to ask three questions: how many stores and products are covered, whether the savings are measured or projected, and what replaces the plastic that has been removed. Paper bags, for example, have their own environmental costs and are only an improvement if they are reused or recycled.

Seen in that light, the Morrisons scheme was a genuine, practical step that gave shoppers a real choice, backed by trial data. It was not the end of plastic in the fruit and veg aisle, and it was never meant to be.

Sources: Morrisons corporate news, 20 May 2019; FoodNavigator, May 2019; FarmingUK on the Tesco trial, March 2019; FoodNavigator on the WRAP report, February 2022; The Scotsman.

COMMENTS