25 Cups of Coffee a Day and Your Arteries: What the Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-06-26.

A 2019 study from Queen Mary University of London found that heavy coffee drinkers, including some who reported drinking up to 25 cups a day, did not have stiffer arteries than people who drank less than one cup. That is reassuring news for coffee lovers, but it does not mean 25 cups a day is safe. The research looked at a single measure of heart health, and most health authorities still advise keeping caffeine to about 400 mg a day, roughly three to five 8-ounce cups of brewed coffee.

Here is what the researchers actually measured, what their findings can and cannot tell you, and what wider evidence says about coffee and the heart.

Coffee Consumption and an Arterial-Stiffness Study

What the 2019 study found

The work was led by Professor Steffen Petersen and part-funded by the British Heart Foundation (BHF). It was presented in June 2019 at the British Cardiovascular Society conference in Manchester.

The team studied 8,412 people in the UK. Each had an MRI scan of the heart and an infrared pulse wave test, two ways of assessing how stiff the arteries are. Participants were sorted into three groups according to how much coffee they said they drank:

  • less than one cup a day;
  • one to three cups a day;
  • more than three cups a day.

People who drank more than 25 cups daily were excluded. After accounting for age, sex, ethnicity, smoking, height, weight, alcohol, diet and high blood pressure, the researchers found no link between coffee intake and stiffer arteries. Even in the highest group, arterial health was no worse than among people who barely touched coffee.

The researchers noted that earlier studies suggesting coffee stiffens arteries had produced inconsistent results, possibly because they involved fewer participants.

Why arterial stiffness matters

Healthy arteries are elastic. Each heartbeat sends a surge of blood into them, and they stretch slightly to absorb it before springing back. With age, and with conditions such as high blood pressure and diabetes, the artery walls gradually lose that flexibility.

Stiffer arteries are a problem because they cushion the heart's pumping less well. Pressure waves travel faster and bounce back to the heart sooner, which makes the heart work harder and can strain delicate blood vessels in the brain and kidneys. Measured stiffness, usually expressed as pulse wave velocity, is linked to a higher risk of high blood pressure, heart attack, heart failure and stroke.

So if coffee did stiffen arteries, it would be a genuine concern. That is why the 2019 result was welcomed: it suggests that this particular worry about coffee may be overstated.

What the study does not show

News coverage at the time often went much further than the evidence, with headlines implying that 25 cups a day could not harm your heart. The BHF itself was more careful. Its associate medical director, Professor Metin Avkiran, said the research "rules out one of the potential detrimental effects of coffee on our arteries."

Several limits are worth keeping in mind:

  • One measure only. The study looked at artery stiffness. It did not examine heart rhythm, blood pressure spikes, sleep, anxiety or other effects of very high caffeine intake.
  • Very few extreme drinkers. The top group covered anyone drinking more than three cups. Only a small number of people reported intakes near 25 cups, so the findings say little about that level specifically.
  • Self-reported intake. People estimated their own consumption, and cup sizes and coffee strength vary enormously.
  • Observational design. The research found an absence of association; it was not a trial in which people were assigned different amounts of coffee.
  • Conference presentation. Results presented at a conference have usually had less scrutiny than a full peer-reviewed journal paper.

The researchers also noticed that moderate and heavy coffee drinkers were more likely to be men, to smoke and to drink alcohol regularly. They adjusted for these factors, but such differences show how hard it is to isolate the effect of coffee alone.

How much caffeine is too much?

The US Food and Drug Administration says that for most healthy adults, up to 400 mg of caffeine a day is not generally associated with harmful effects. The 2015–2020 Dietary Guidelines for Americans similarly described three to five 8-ounce cups of coffee a day as compatible with a healthy diet.

Caffeine content varies widely. According to the FDA, a 12-ounce serving of regular brewed coffee contains somewhere between about 113 mg and 247 mg. On those figures, 25 ordinary cups a day could easily add up to several thousand milligrams of caffeine, many times the suggested limit.

Signs that you are having more caffeine than your body tolerates include:

  • a racing heart or palpitations;
  • jitteriness, anxiety or restlessness;
  • trouble sleeping;
  • headaches, nausea or an upset stomach.

Sensitivity differs from person to person, partly because of genetics. Pregnant or breastfeeding women, people with certain medical conditions and people taking some medications may need less, and the FDA recommends that they discuss their intake with a health professional. Pure or powdered caffeine products are particularly dangerous because a tiny amount can be toxic.

What else research says about coffee and health

Over the past two decades, a large body of observational research has painted a mostly positive picture of moderate coffee drinking. The American Heart Association has summarised studies linking regular coffee consumption with:

  • a lower risk of type 2 diabetes;
  • a lower risk of Parkinson's disease, with one study suggesting a possible link to lower Alzheimer's risk;
  • lower overall mortality, including deaths from heart disease, for both regular and decaf coffee;
  • a lower risk of coronary heart disease in women.

Coffee also contains antioxidants. Because these studies are observational, they show associations rather than proof that coffee itself causes the benefits.

The way you prepare coffee matters too. Paper filters trap a compound called cafestol that can raise LDL ("bad") cholesterol, so unfiltered methods such as French press may carry more cardiovascular risk when consumed in large amounts. And what goes into the cup can outweigh any benefit: sugary syrups, cream and blended coffee drinks can add hundreds of calories.

Common myths about coffee and the heart

"Coffee is bad for your heart." For most healthy adults, moderate coffee drinking has not been shown to harm the heart, and the 2019 study adds evidence that it does not stiffen arteries.

"If a study found no harm, unlimited coffee is fine." Absence of one harm is not proof of safety. Very high caffeine intakes can cause unpleasant and occasionally dangerous effects.

"Decaf has no caffeine." It has much less, but not zero; the FDA puts it at roughly 2 to 15 mg per 8-ounce cup.

"All coffee drinks are the same." A cup of filtered black coffee and a large sweetened frappé are very different from a health point of view.

The practical takeaway

If you enjoy a few cups of coffee a day, current evidence suggests you do not need to worry that it is stiffening your arteries. Keep total caffeine around the commonly recommended limit, favour filtered coffee, go easy on sugar and cream, and pay attention to how your body responds, especially your sleep.

If you have a heart condition, high blood pressure, an irregular heartbeat, or you are pregnant, talk to your doctor about what amount of coffee is right for you.

Sources: British Heart Foundation, June 2019: Coffee not as bad for heart and circulatory system as previously thought; FDA: Spilling the Beans: How Much Caffeine Is Too Much?; American Heart Association News: Is coffee good for you or not?; Wikipedia: Arterial stiffness.

COMMENTS