Couple Gives Former Brotherton Reservation Land to Lenape Group

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
The Hogans' Land Donation and Its Meaning Beyond Price

In September 2018 a retired New Jersey couple, Jim and Margaret Hogan, handed a wooded lot in Tabernacle Township to a Lenape descendants' organisation for a token price of one dollar. They had bought the land in 1973 for $9,000 as an investment. Only later did they learn it once belonged to Brotherton, the first and only Native American reservation New Jersey ever created. Here is what happened, what Brotherton was, and why a small parcel carries a large story.

A $9,000 investment that never took off

The Hogans' 1.5-acre lot sits on Route 206 at Tuckerton Road in rural Burlington County. When they bought it, the parcel was zoned for commercial use, and they expected the highway corridor to boom the way the Philadelphia suburb of Cherry Hill had. Jim, a construction-equipment salesman, recalled to the Philadelphia Inquirer that they had no idea of the land's past when a family from Pennsylvania sold it to them.

The boom never came. Tabernacle stayed a quiet Pine Barrens township of about 6,800 people, and the lot stayed mostly trees apart from a small farm stand Jim built and used for a short time. The couple tried to sell it on and off for decades. After one more buyer pulled out in 2017, they decided to give it away instead.

Jim, 84 when the story was reported in 2019 and a father of five and grandfather of seven, explained the choice simply: the history between the United States and Native Americans had been poor, and he and Margaret wanted to do something about it, even on a small scale.

What Brotherton was

The Hogans' Land Donation and Its Meaning Beyond Price

Map of Lenapehoking, the Lenape homeland, showing dialect areas across New Jersey, eastern Pennsylvania, southern New York and Delaware. Map by Wikimedia Commons user Nikater.

The Lenape, also called Lenni-Lenape or Delaware, lived across what is now New Jersey, eastern Pennsylvania, the lower Hudson valley and northern Delaware long before Europeans arrived. English colonists named the Delaware River after Lord De La Warr, an early governor of Virginia, and the name stuck to the people too.

By the 1750s colonial expansion had squeezed Lenape communities hard. In 1758 the colonial legislature bought about 3,000 acres in what is now Tabernacle and Shamong townships and set it aside as a reservation. Governor Francis Bernard named it Brotherton; the Lenape name was Edgepillock. The local historian George D. Flemming, author of a 2005 book on the site, has argued that the colony also hoped the reservation would persuade Indigenous groups to drop land claims elsewhere and keep the peace.

The Presbyterian missionary John Brainerd oversaw the settlement, and at its height it was home to roughly 200 people, with a sawmill and gristmill nearby; the village of Indian Mills in Shamong preserves the memory in its name.

How the reservation was lost

Brotherton struggled from the start. The Revolutionary War disrupted the area, Brainerd left in 1777 and his death removed the settlement's main patron, and disputes broke out over leasing and selling parcels to white settlers. In 1780 community leaders signed an agreement opposing further sales.

In the late 1790s the Oneida and Stockbridge communities in New York invited Brotherton's residents to join them. Many at first refused to leave their home in Jersey, but by 1801 most families agreed. The state passed an act to sell the reservation and use the proceeds for the move, and the land was sold off in 1802. Some of those who went north were uprooted again in the 1820s and travelled more than 900 miles to the Green Bay area of Wisconsin. A few families stayed in New Jersey and gradually blended into surrounding communities.

Who received the land

County records show the deed passing in early September 2018 to the Brotherton Indian Reservation, an organisation based in Denville, Morris County. Its leader, Joseph Littlefeather, had recently been elected chief of the Sandhill Lenape Cherokee Tribe, a New Jersey group representing several hundred people who trace their ancestry to Brotherton, about 30 of whom live on or near the old reservation.

Littlefeather thanked the Hogans and described modest plans: a farm stand, and eventually an office so that members living in the south of the state would not have to travel so far for meetings. He stressed that the group takes no money from the state and has no dealings with the federal Bureau of Indian Affairs. He also reassured neighbours, as the Inquirer reported, with a short line: "We're not going to go down there and throw everybody out of their houses."

Not everyone was in the loop. Tabernacle's mayor, Joseph Barton, said he had not known about the transfer, and he pointed out that any building on the lot would need approval from the township's zoning and planning boards and from the Pinelands Commission, which regulates development across the protected Pine Barrens.

Recognition and Native identity in New Jersey

New Jersey has no federally recognised tribe. The main federally recognised Lenape nations today are the Delaware Nation and the Delaware Tribe of Indians in Oklahoma, the Stockbridge-Munsee Community in Wisconsin, and several Lenape communities in Ontario, Canada, all descendants of people pushed west over centuries.

The state itself recognises a few tribes, including the Nanticoke Lenni-Lenape, the Ramapough Lenape and the Powhatan Renape. In March 2019 the state attorney general's office announced settlements affirming the recognition of the Ramapough and Powhatan Renape nations. Groups such as the one led by Littlefeather sit outside both lists, which affects funding and legal standing but not their members' sense of history.

Why a one-dollar gift still matters

A lot of 1.5 acres does not undo the loss of 3,000, and nobody involved claimed it did. Its value is symbolic and practical at once: it gives descendants a foothold on ground their ancestors lived on, and a place to meet. The story also shows how land histories hide in plain sight. The Hogans owned a piece of Brotherton for 45 years before they understood what it was.

Gestures like this are part of a wider movement, sometimes called "land back", in which private owners, churches and local governments return land to Indigenous communities. Most cases are small and local, and each depends on the people involved agreeing on what the land should be used for. For anyone curious about the history under their own feet, county historical societies, state archives and tribal organisations are good places to start.

Explore the related article: The 2016 March of Hope and Women Wage Peace.

Sources: Kevin Riordan, The Philadelphia Inquirer, 1 June 2019; Wikipedia: Indian Mills, New Jersey (Brotherton history); Wikipedia: Lenape; map by Nikater via Wikimedia Commons; earlier write-up at The Mind Unleashed.

COMMENTS